Alaric the Goth

An Outsider's History of the Fall of Rome

De: Douglas Boin

Narrado por: Chris MacDonnell

Duración: 8 h y 13 m

Resumen del Editor

Denied citizenship by the Roman Empire, a soldier named Alaric changed history by unleashing a surprise attack on the capital city of an unjust empire. Stigmatized and relegated to the margins of Roman society, the Goths were violent "barbarians" who destroyed "civilization," at least in the conventional story of Rome's collapse. But a slight shift of perspective brings their history, and ours, shockingly alive.

Alaric grew up near the river border that separated Gothic territory from Roman. He survived a border policy that separated migrant children from their parents, and he was denied benefits he likely expected from military service. In stark contrast to the rising bigotry, intolerance, and zealotry among Romans during Alaric's lifetime, the Goths, as practicing Christians, valued religious pluralism and tolerance.

The marginalized Goths preserved virtues of the ancient world that we take for granted. The three nights of riots Alaric and the Goths brought to the capital struck fear into the hearts of the powerful, but the riots were not without cause. Combining vivid storytelling and historical analysis, Douglas Boin reveals the Goths' complex and fascinating legacy in shaping our world.

©2020 Douglas Boin (P)2020 HighBridge, a division of Recorded Books

Nice short book that tries to upend the story of Alaric

The title is a little misleading, the author admits there are very few contemporary accounts of Alaric and the Goths and all of them are biased towards the Romans. This book focuses more on describing the cultural and political atmosphere of the Roman Empire in the late 300s-early 400s AD. Specifically their attitudes toward and treatment of immigrant groups such as the Goths. The author makes some reasonable inferences about Alaric (he led raids from an early age and rose in the ranks of the Roman military which suggests he was a capable strategist and reasonably charismatic) but doesn’t go too far into speculation about his character.
I most enjoyed the way the author re-contextualized the popular perception of the Goths, they were not marauding, German raiders, but closer to wandering Romanian refugees. They were stuck in an untenable position between raiding tribes from the north and the powerful, exploitive and increasingly xenophobic Roman Empire to the South. Overall, a nice focused history on a subject I did not know much about prior to listening to this.

The Life and Times of Alaric

Alaric the Goth might be titled "The Life and Times of Alaric". He is the Barbarian leader who sacked Rome in 410, inspiring St. Augustine's The City of God. Alaric died soon after and was buried underneath a river bed with the choicest treasures of Rome never yet found. The primary focus is the period from the Battle of Adrianople in 378 to 410. It describes how the Goths were considered "outsiders", which is to say unwelcome immigrants, who were treated poorly by racist and xenophobic Roman citizens. They were abused while at the same time employed to the do the dirty work no one else wanted. The Goth's got their revenge. Alaric's life is not well documented so Boin takes the innovative approach of describing what we actually know about this period. For example we know Alaric spent time in Athens, and Boin describes Athens from archaeologic and written evidence - the popular plays, the city layout, it being a desirable address for up and coming Romans - and places it into context with Alaric's likely experiences there at that time. In this way we travel through his life and footsteps around the Roman Empire. The small details bring it alive in a way no other book about this period has before, that I have read. It's a fascinating and effective approach to history when documentation is otherwise sparse. This period is endlessly fascinating, Boin has placed the transition from Roman to Barbarian in technicolor showing both peaceful transition and violent change, as told through the microhistory of a single man.

Ancient History Through the Lens of Current Politcal and Social Thinking

This could be and is an interesting topic for people interested in the fall of the western Roman Empire. Instead, the other make a hamfisted attempt to liken the United States and EU to Rome in terms of how immigration and border issues are handled. He even suggest the Roman’s introduced slavery to Dacia. That’s ludicrous as slavery was pretty much universally practiced in ancient times. I was hoping for a historical account of Alaric and the Goths and instead got veiled attempts to tie this period of time to the current period. I’m very disappointed.

great story told from a different perspective

if you want to learn more about the goths told from their perspective this is a great place to start. well organized and well written. enjoyable read

lots of good history!!

I enjoyed this way more then I expected. it had explanations for things I didn't think to connect. it's got more then gothic history, as would be right because they were a tribe on the move. I liked the info about the religious subjects and forming of the christianity.
I highly recommend it. the author adds well researched takes on issues and events I believe we previously misrepresented.
I enjoyed it

Wonderful Read

Truly a great book for someone who wasn’t as familiar with the Gothic culture. Alaric is a fascinating character lost in history until now.

The fall of Rome-The rest of the story

The author does an amazing job of reconstructing the career of Aleric the Goth; who was a Roman General. Spoiler alert: As a Goth, he was not given Roman citizenship and was even slighted on pay for himself and his troops. While such abuse makes the case for why Aleric sacked Rome in 410 AD, and perhaps similar treatment led the Vandals to trash Rome again shortly after, I for one, was left wondering exactly how these two attacks had such a longstanding catastrophic effect on world civilization.

More a discussion of an era

Not a lot of hard facts concerning Alaric. The discussion of Rome during Alaric's era was interesting. Not sure I buy it's message on immigration and citizenship, without doing more reading on my part. Read Adrian Goldsworthy book on the fall of Rome, if you want a different perspective.

Fascinating take on Roman Times

Truly fascinating; challenges your preconceptions and stereotypes. Useful lesson for all of us in modern times too

shoehorning modern politics into ancient history

The author is clearly trying to tie the fall of rome in with modern politics, unfortunately they distort the actual history in doing so; no the Romans didnt suddenly become xenophobic before the fall of rome, they always were massively xenophobic, even at the height of their empire, as were almost all ancient civilizations. its so painfully obvious the narrative the author is trying to forge, often skipping over some facts or presenting others in a "different light". Modern politics dont belong in ancient historical narratives. Many authors make modern parallels, but they usually keep it in the preface or introduction.