Through Shade and Shadow felt very much like setting the stage – that is, establishing the characters and building parts of the fantasy world before the protagonists become engaged in the main conflict. But as stage setting goes, this book did pretty well as the action was fast, although it was not always as immersive as I might have liked.
The violence in Through Shade and Shadow was the result of bigotry and intolerance, after a mass murderer was identified as a Shade. Shades were previously considered a mythical species with supernatural healing capabilities, so the hatred that erupted was from a fear of those who are different. To reinforce that idea, the author had the persecution extend well beyond the Shades and the other fantasy species (Shadows, Shifters, Sages) to many other groups and organizations. Over the course of the story, blacks, immigrants, synagogues, gays, Planned Parenthood, and others were attacked, often with horrific results. While the use of these examples brings to mind real world events, the breadth of the persecution seemed generally unrealistic. Even the story’s references to extreme religious close-mindedness, hatemongering on the political front, and violent military stereotypes did little to make these events seem more than a listing of historical intolerance.
The book spends some considerable time developing the lifestyle and gifts of the two primary characters, Mason Jerah, a Shade, and Alaric Lambrecht, who is a Shadow. Both are being thrust into roles much greater than anything they had experienced before and it is easy to feel their growing pains. Beyond these two individuals, the author expounds on a variety of other fantasy species and their gifts – the ability to feel another’s emotions, to see another’s thoughts, to plant thoughts, to create false appearances, to control fire, to control light, and so on. While variety may generally add interest to a story, when so many supernatural capabilities are available in a fantasy world, creating obstacles becomes a matter of explaining why a gift doesn’t work and eliminating problems just takes the right gift at the right time. The creation of tension and its resolution starts to feel artificial, subject completely to the stage of the story.
So, while the plight described in Through Shade and Shadow will, unfortunately, bring to mind many real-world events, the breadth of the persecution and the lack of boundaries on supernatural gifts tends to render the story somewhat strained.