To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Review this product
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
4.0 out of 5 starsShmata history in UK and U.S.
Reviewed in the United States on May 16, 2015
Admirable, concise research was obvious from beginning to end in this tome. Learned an awful lot of the remarkable folk who braved physical hardships galore (traveling from London to Australia in the latter part of the 19th century). AntiSemitism, prevalent during these trying periods, was overcome as well,owing to stouthearted, undying ambition and family ties. Knowing the history of the "rag trade" as related by the author gives the reader overwhelming admiration for these heroes of this trade.
4.0 out of 5 starsI actually at times helped my brother who had a 'schmatte' stall in the famous Petticoat Lane in the East End of London so all t
Reviewed in the United States on June 8, 2015
I found this book extremely interesting and nostalgic if you will for having been born and growing up in London, I actually at times helped my brother who had a 'schmatte' stall in the famous Petticoat Lane in the East End of London so all the places mentioned in the book like Houndsditch and Brick Lane brought back many memories. So did the "tricks of the trade" of the pedlars. Reading about the same thing happening in America was also fascinating. Kudos to the author!
Insightful, vividly even entertainingly written, this study takes a global perspective. It adds immeasurably to our understanding of the role that the schmattes trade has played in the rise of Jews not just economically but socially as well. As a comparative study, it breaks new ground. A worthy winner of the National Jewish Book Award
4.0 out of 5 starsIntriguing story of Jewish economic evolution in the US and, to a much lesser extent, the British Empire.
Reviewed in the United States on June 24, 2015
This is a superb work of economic and ethnic history. There is abundant information about the relationship of Jews to the clothing industry following the waves of immigration 1880 into the 20th century, but here we see how the stage was set in the previous century. Many Jewish immigrants began as rag pickers, became peddlers of used clothing in remote but accessible areas, then established fixed stores. One of the most interesting points in this fascinating book was the importance of trade with plantation owners in the South, slaves (an enormous market for "shoddy" roughly made clothing), and tenant farmers after Reconstruction. In both cases, barter was often the means of exchange and commodities and land served as collateral. When buyers couldn’t pay, the merchants seized the land. In fact, in that fashion (excuse the pun--Mendelsohn has an eye-roll inducing penchant for them), one entrepreneurial Jew came to own 24,000 acres in Natchez, MS, which must have fanned some anti-Semitic flames. The clothing trade thus served as the way into banking and commodity trading.
While the book purports to deal with the USA and the British Empire, the latter is really there to serve as a kind of foil that reveals how different circumstances affected Jewish entry into the clothing trade specifically and the economy in general. While Jews in the US had a later and less auspicious start than those in the British Empire, (and by that Mendelsohn mostly means England, Australia and a few references to the West Indies), the "elaborate and geographically dispersed distribution chain" in the US laid a very effective foundation.
Through the clothing trade, Jews received schooling in essential skills essential for rapid advancement in a modern economy: "practice in petty entrepreneurship" and "sensitivity to the whims and wants of the market," but most importantly, "self-employment rather than wage labor" to facilitate a quick rise from the working class. The key to the success of Jews in the US was entrepreneurship in a field that required minimal investment of capital to start. Genius.
Mendelsohn showed clearly how specific economic behaviors and historical events informed each other. In places, there were points of momentous import that that needed greater emphasis, but that's to be forgiven. He admirably resisted the temptation to explore other areas of Jewish history that were outside of his thesis (we can research Judah Benjamin on our own, e.g.). This is a great read and with the emphasis on interdisciplinarity and teaching entrepreneurship in schools, this would make an excellent addition to summer reading lists.
Wonderful history of the Jews in the US and England and how they were in the garment business. From peddlers to the clothing factories to success in finance. The sweatshops of the lower east side to supplying uniforms in the civil war. A great read to understand the success of Jews in America.