Customer reviews

4.3 out of 5 stars
4.3 out of 5
233 global ratings
5 star
64%
4 star
20%
3 star
5%
2 star
6%
1 star
6%
How are ratings calculated?
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.

Review this product



Top reviews

Top reviews from the United States

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Tracy Adams
4.0 out of 5 stars ... I have find it incredibly hard to fall in love with her stories
Reviewed in the United States on November 24, 2015
Since I was first introduced to Hoyt as an author earlier this year I have find it incredibly hard to fall in love with her stories. If you have yet to be introduced to the author yourself allow me to tell you that the author pens beautiful, breathtaking romances that will remind you of a gentle fairy tale.

The title of the book describes the story well, "sweet." This story is a charming romance that is not too heavy and yet certainly easy on the eyes. The romance was present throughout the book and that is what I savor the best about Hoyt as an author is that each time she manages to deliver her readers with a new romance that is as alluring as a spring bloom.

However I think the plot in this book was a little dry around the edges. The beginning was much slower than what I was expecting and the plot never really found its own rhythm. So the plot in my opinion needed to be vastly improved and so it was a good thing that the romance was so well written.

Lastly I rarely ever comment on sensual scenes because each author has their way own way of writing such scenes and yet I feel like historical, heated moments have went straight into the world of contemporary. I was disappointed to have found this in this book as well as the author herself rarely ever does this flaw. Yet, I am beginning to see it more and more in historical-romances and I am not all thrilled by the detail as I consider sensual nature to reflect the tone of both the actual book as a whole and that of the romance. So I am hoping this flaw does not continue into the new year.

For my respect for the author and for her wonderful writings of sweeter romances I would recommend this book.
Read more
Kim Lowe
5.0 out of 5 stars Sweet Surrender to the Theatrical World in Georgian England
Reviewed in the United States on November 24, 2015
No great scoundrel is ever uninteresting. - Murray Kempton

Asa Makepeace is anything but uninteresting. He is loud and proud of Harte's Folly - a pleasure garden, theater, and opera all in one for Georgian London to enjoy. Asa's love of theater earned him the wrath of his father and distanced him from his siblings. Although Harte's Folly burned down (presumably in a previous book in the series), Asa has a new sponsor (and fellow scoundrel) to help rebuild - the Duke of Montgomery.

The Duke tasks his half sister, Eve Dinwoody, to manage his financial investment in Harte's Folly. Asa is aghast to be audited ... and Eve is aghast to find Asa in bed with the opera singer. Yet Eve takes her job seriously to please her brother, the only person who cares about the mousy bastard of his father. She is soon drawn into the theater world, taking an interest in the dancers' welfare, participating in the rehearsals, and even rescuing a mangy dog despite her fear of dogs. Along the way, Eve appreciates Asa's passion for the arts. She blooms into a confident woman who realizes she wants more from life than simply relying upon her brother. Likewise, Asa allows Eve into his cynical heart. She inspires him to reconnect with his family (characters in previous books) and see that he can have a life other than the theater.

SWEETEST SCOUNDREL is my first entry into the Maiden Lane series. Somehow, I missed the previous eight books. Still, I was able to read SWEETEST SCOUNDREL as a stand alone book - the focus is on Asa Makepeace and Eve Dinwoody. Hoyt creates two unique characters who give readers a different perspective of the Georgian Era; its not all about the London Ton. Asa reminds me of Joseph Fiennes in Shakespeake in Love - his quest for theatrical perfection intersects with his growing love for Eve. Does he have enough passion for both? Is Eve willing to share Asa with the theater world?

Hoyt adds extra drama and humor to the story with the colorful cast and tidbits about theater. Hoyt sets SWEETEST SCOUNDREL apart from other historical romances with steamy scenes in which Asa teaches Eve about pleasure. Finally, Hoyt introduces each chapter with an excerpt from a fairy tale which symbolizes the upcoming action in SWEETEST SCOUNDREL. This added bonus reminds me of the fairy tales Hoyt included in her debut, THE RAVEN PRINCE. Since then, Hoyt has written 15 full length historicals. It was a pleasure to read SWEETEST SCOUNDREL to see how Hoyt has matured as a writer and even have confidence to take a chance on extraordinary characters.

I received an Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) from Forever Romance.
Read more
Gerbera_Reads
TOP 1000 REVIEWERVINE VOICE
5.0 out of 5 stars Asa and Eve build their happy ever after!
Reviewed in the United States on May 30, 2020
Verified Purchase
It seems as the series progresses, the author tries to reach a new lever of angst. I like that. As with previous stories, the author built up the set up for the next one, and, OMG, I want to read about Duke of Montgomery and Mrs. Crumb so bad. But back to here and now. I loved bawdy and loud Asa Makepeace aka Mr Harte. Underneath all that bluster and rough manner is such a wonderful man. Asa will do anything to get what he wants. And what he wants is Harte's Folly's success and Eve Dinwoody. Admittedly he took a bit of time to warm up to her, but when he looked her past strait-laced appearance and closed off demeanor he became an exceptionally patient and caring man. I loved how he seduced Eve with words, how gentle he was with her.

Eve Dinwoody is way more than what she shows the world. She locked herself away and almost threw away the key. There was a lot of vulnerability in her but also quiet strength to simply not give into panic and fear. Poor lady! I loved the moment when her curiosity got the better of her and she let Asa in. It was so s*exy and heart felt. I really felt for her when she told everything to Asa. The worst part is that in reality nobility due to their elevated status could and did get away with far worse. The law was not kind to women, children or poor in those years. The way the author tackled this matter was considerate as she touched upon the matter.

I really like Jean-Marie Pepin and Tess. They were such loyal and friendly characters. I was really happy with where they ended up by the time the book was over. Asa and the Makepeace family provided relief from tension with their huge numbers and numerous shenanigans, but at least Asa made his peace with them. This was a steadily paced, passionate and angsty historical romance. I am so glad I read it.
Read more

See all reviews

Top reviews from other countries

avidreader
3.0 out of 5 stars Disappointed
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on December 12, 2015
Verified Purchase
I really like Elizabeth Hoyt's writing - I started with the 'Princes' series and then began the 'Maiden Lane' series. Every plot is unique, the tension is palpable, the characters deep with interesting backgrounds. BUT - the last three books, Darling Beast, Dearest Rogue and now Sweetest Scoundrel have been way off the mark for me. This latest book, Sweetest Scoundrel, was so unlike her earlier writing that I ploughed through it,waiting and waiting to be caught up in her often nightmarish, intricate plots. It never happened. I liked both the hero's and heroine's characters and their interraction - but the sex scenes were unnecessarily graphic; I don't need to have male and female genitalia described in detail. I also don't know why the first 'sex scene' in the carriage was there - this is a 34 year old man, not a teenager, and a woman who, we know, has terrible issues from her childhood, asking for more explanations and demonstrations?? Please! Then we get a similar scene in the office; I really felt it was just there for titillation, not what I want from her books. There were a lot of other situations and actions that didn't work - but I would be giving the story away if I remarked on them. Suffice to say there were plenty, and I didn't like them.

The plot was so thin that I thought there must be more to come to flesh it out, but no, it plodded along and the villain was despatched neatly - and unbelievably. There was never any feeling of menace from him - and I think that is something EH has always written so well. Because I have so enjoyed the earlier books in the series, I will read the next one because we are already familiar with the hero, the Duke of Montgomery, and hope that the author pulls something better out of the hat. I believe that there are a further three Maiden Lane books in the pipeline, but I will have decide whether to read them after the next book is published.
Read more
Mrs R
5.0 out of 5 stars Another Maiden Lane Triumph!
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on January 21, 2016
Verified Purchase
Elizabeth Hoyt has created a wonderful backdrop for her Maiden Lane series and each book is a delight to read. Eve's and Asa's story is no exception. Asa is a really interesting, down to earth hero and at last we find out why he has been distant from his family for so long. He is driven by his passion for the garden at Harte's Folly and the theatrical entertainments that he works hard to produce. As he falls in love with Eve, he has to come to terms with his past and re-order his priorities for the future. His sensitivity to Eve reveals depths to his character that contrast strongly with the brash, hot tempered man we encounter at the beginning of the book. As for Eve, she is also a delight. She is plain, illegitimate and deeply traumatised by events in her own past, but when she loves, she loves wholeheartedly. (Who else could be so devoted to such an amoral and mercurial brother as the Duke of Montgomery? Val's book is next, thankfully, and I can't wait to see how Ms Hoyt can make a hero out of such a character!) Eve's journey is perhaps even more difficult than Asa's, but she is a lovely, courageous woman and it is heartwarming to see her blossom as these two unlikely lovers reach out for their HEA. I thoroughly recommend this book as well as all the others in the Maiden Lane series.
Read more
E.G.E
4.0 out of 5 stars A Sweet Tale
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on February 4, 2016
Verified Purchase
I've always loved Elizabeth Hoyt's writing since the first book of Maiden Lane and Sweetest Scoundrel fits in the series just perfectly.
It's not dramatic and scandalous as some of the other previous books, it is what the book's title states, it's a 'sweet' tale between two people who at first glance would never be seen together as a couple. Shy Eve who's a daughter of a Duke and hot-headed Asa the owner of a pleasure garden.
For me personally the love story had a modern day feel to it, these two characters had chemistry from the start even though it wasn't the best of starts, but they somehow work so perfectly together.
It's a quick, easy read, but full of character and promising storylines none the less. Can't wait for Duke of Sin!
Read more
gimmielinda
4.0 out of 5 stars A lewd, romp of a tale of unapologetic rake and ingenue.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on April 15, 2016
Verified Purchase
Asa is a larger than life character, fitting for a theatrical manager; he's had to face many setbacks and difficulties so he's pugnacious, loud and very vulgar. He loves women and he's declarative about it. Eve is the absolute opposite - sheltered and retiring and somewhat repressed; she's traumatised by an event in her childhood but, when she is compelled to spend time with Asa, she grows increasingly curious about love and passion and cannot resist being drawn to his unapologetic relish for the latter. She tentatively questions, he responds dramatically and lewdly. It's a heady combination. A bit raw for me but I admire the story.
Read more
Kellie
4.0 out of 5 stars TW: sexual assault of a child
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on August 4, 2019
Verified Purchase
Good, but Eve gets over her trauma ridiculously quickly. And the way Asa kisses her, knowing she's a survivor of sexual assault is...not great. Looking forward to the next one though!
Read more

See all reviews