Customer reviews

4.6 out of 5 stars
4.6 out of 5
945 global ratings
5 star
72%
4 star
19%
3 star
7%
2 star
2%
1 star
1%
How are ratings calculated?
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.

Review this product



Reviews with images

Customer image
See all customer images

Read reviews that mention

holly black coldest girl girl in coldtown even though young adult really enjoyed standalone writing style vampire stories well written world building social media human blood anne rice really liked feel like midnight and winter tana and gavriel ex-boyfriend aidan twists and turns
Top reviews

Top reviews from the United States

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Kristen
4.0 out of 5 stars Flawed Characters, A Unique World, & Sexy but Dangerous Vampires
Reviewed in the United States on March 14, 2019
Verified Purchase
This is one of those books that's going to be hard to write a review for because I feel like I can't quite explain everything I'm thinking properly, but I will try.

First of all, I love vampires. And this book was vampires done just the way I like them: sexy, but unpredictable and dangerous. They might keep their fangs off you, they might give you a pleasurable bite, or they might rip your throat out; it just depends on the vampire and the moment. And even though there was a romanticism to the vampires, the author also showed the gritty, horrible, reality of them, of what they can do, of the things that happen because of vampirism (like people getting killed even if it's an accident), of what it's like to live with them in the Coldtowns.

And speaking of the Coldtowns (the places where the vampires lived), the world-building for those, or for the one that Tana was in at least, was so interesting and well done. The reality shows based there for the humans to watch, the bartering and businesses that existed within the Coldtown, the humans with shunts on their arms who were desperate to become vampires themselves, the impoverished way of living for many people in the Coldtown, the humans who never wanted to be in the Coldtown but got trapped there when it was set up, the markers for getting out and what people will do to get them, the neverending parties... So much thought put into it all. And I mean, just the idea of the Coldtowns in the first place was something unique I'd never seen before.

Another great thing about the book was the complex, flawed characters. Tana sometimes played with fire or made bad decisions but I liked her because she always kept fighting, trying to escape, not giving up, and she tried her best to do what was right. But she also knew when to stop taking shit and put herself first, even if it meant possibly hurting someone. And Aidan did a lot of messed up things to Tana, but he was still charming and sincere and sometimes sweet, and I loved his character because he was so well-written and interesting and truly flawed. I found myself falling for his charm even though I knew I shouldn't, so I could totally see how Tana fell for him. Gavriel was interesting and flawed as well, just in different, more dramatic ways because of his past and vampirism and insanity.

The book also touched upon something I think about sometimes. I read a lot of vampire books, and I wonder, what would a vampire who's been alive for a long time actually be like? Would they be like an old person? Would they act the age they look? Would they be monsters? Would they still just seem human? Would it just depend on the vampire? But that quote about Gavriel is such an interesting way of looking at it.

The writing was also pretty in this eerie, strange kind of way. And there were some brilliant quotes, like the one I shared above. I'm not sure how I feel about the flashbacks and some of the POVs that might not have been necessary, but those are pretty minor issues.

So overall, this was a kind of eerie feeling book with great writing, sexy but dangerous vampires, amazing world-building, and complex characters that I'm very glad I gave it a read!

Rating: 4 Stars

Original Review @ Metaphors and Moonlight (link in profile)
Read more
R MackTop Contributor: Pets
5.0 out of 5 stars Pleasing- Beginning to End
Reviewed in the United States on October 24, 2017
Verified Purchase
So satisfying. I can't remember the last time that a book wrapped up in a better way than I could have imagined. This book has a true beginning, middle, end. A a great story arch. Even the bad guys have a back story and are enjoyable as characters. This book is a jewel- not needing a sequel (although I would absolutely read a sequel). Furthermore, when you can compare the cold towns in the story to our prison system, the insight is both interesting and frightening. The fiscal and political investment in the institution confuses easiest and best practices. Who is redeemable? The bloodthirsty vampire? The reckless child? The self-severing teenager? The person who makes a mistake?
Read more
Courtney Garrison
4.0 out of 5 stars I am glad I went into not knowing much because wow
Reviewed in the United States on March 30, 2018
Verified Purchase
I have never read a book by Holly Black ever, so I wasn’t quite sure what to expect going into this book. I knew it was about vampires and that was it. I am glad I went into not knowing much because wow, it was so good. The writing and the characters are amazing, the way Holly Black writes is absolutely fantastic. She sucks you in and your left wanting to know more every time you read it. This book was so good I didn’t want to finish it, I wanted to hold on to as much of the story as I could.

Your MC is a girl named Tana. She awakens in a bathtub of an old farmhouse to find herself in the middle of a massacre. Everyone at the party from the night before is now dead except Aiden (Her Ex-Boyfriend) and the Vampire chained up in the corner. She is soon faced with the possibility of being infected along with Aiden already being infected and makes the choice to go to Coldtown.

Coldtowns are cities that built walls around themselves to help keep the vampire population in and hopefully stop the spread of the infection. Most humans end up going to coldtown because they have glamourized vampirism so much they want to turn into one. So facing the Aiden and Herself being infected, tana heads to coldtown in her car with Aiden and Gabriel ( the Chained up Vampire)

I keep gushing over this book, but it was so good. I honestly compare it a bit to savage song by V.E. Schwab as far as the built-up cities and Humans against monsters (Vampires). I was thoroughly impressed with this books and is definitely one of my favorites this year. Overall it was such an amazing book with great writing and a fabulous world. The character building was astounding, especially with the growth after getting to Coldtown.
Read more
Kindle Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars I opened this book and couldn't stop
Reviewed in the United States on July 12, 2020
Verified Purchase
This was a truly unique look on teen culture and what modern vampires will look like. It was disturbing and suspenseful and populated by such well thought out characters. I loved selfish and jerky Aiden and the way they stayed friends despite all his faults. I loved Gavriel the mad vampire and I thought the ending was perfect. I admit I'm icked out by an actual teen getting together with a 200 year old vampire but I guess that's the genre trope. I loved the tiny love story worked into the cracks with two adorable side characters. I think Tana was my least favorite character. She was a very teenagery teenager is that she kept doing dumb things and even though she was aware they were dumb she did them anyway. I was happy things worked out but only because her stupidity eventually grew on me. She wasn't as complex as some of the other people.
Read more

See all reviews

Top reviews from other countries

Francis James Franklin
5.0 out of 5 stars A very traditional vampire tale, but with a modern approach
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on May 25, 2018
Verified Purchase
It's a long time since a vampire book caught my eye. It's difficult these days to find genre novels that are well written, thoughtful and original. Even rarer to find a YA-category novel with a female protagonist that isn't primarily angsty romance.

Which is not to say The Coldest Girl in Coldtown is without romance. It even has an HFN ending. But the romance is not central to the plot, and there's no clichéd love triangle or idolisation of unhealthy behaviours. If anything, one purpose of the story is to expose the seductive glamour of vampires as an abusive fiction.

Tana, our heroine, is seventeen, an accidental sole survivor of a massacre. She's not a Chosen One and has no special powers, but she shares a trait common to many heroes: a stubborn determination to do what is right, even in the face of mortal terror.

Immortal terror too, of course. The story is set in a world where vampire infection is rife, and where whole cities have been walled around. These are the Coldtowns of the title - although the first part of the title, The Coldest Girl in ... is misleading and probably just for effect. (How many titles start with The Girl ...?) The lives of the dead and undead within these enclaves are glamourised Reality-TV-style and broadcast to the world, luring in a steady stream of wannabe vampires with their fresh, warm, human blood.

If the basic plot is a wild, roller-coaster ride (I read the second half in one sitting), the book's unifying theme is death, where life is warm and death is cold. Vampiric infection is perceived as a creeping cold. The vampires themselves are not the evil of demonic possession, but rather once-humans cursed with - and corrupted by - abnormal lust and power.

There are also some nice historical touches, with scenes in Paris, Vienna and Russia. In many ways, this is a very traditional vampire tale, but with a modern approach, a thriller with elements of both horror and romance.
Read more
Theta Sigma
3.0 out of 5 stars Enjoyable urban-vampire tale
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on November 10, 2018
Verified Purchase
This is a fun little vampire novel that manages to carve out its own place in the genre. A well realised world that sits somewhere similar to that portrayed in the Blade films, whilst managing to put its own little twists in.

The book was of two halves. Part western-road trip, part urban gothic-horror. The road trip feels a little too drawn out and I think more needed to be made of the second half. Some of the characters and events felt a little rushed or forced in to that second part of the story and I would have liked to have had more.

But that is the key thing here - I was invested in it, especially after the road trip, and it made for compelling reading even if it was ultimately a little unsatisfactory. Would recommend if you’re a fan of the genre.
Read more
Shirelle Charles
5.0 out of 5 stars Why isnt this a series
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on June 20, 2020
Verified Purchase
This book was not what I expected but in a good way. I thought I’d grown bored of vampire books but when I read this book I couldn’t put it down. I was so annoyed it was a standalone and not part of a series. It could so easily be. Holly Black has a way of drawing you in that make you mourn the world and the characters when you’ve finished the book. I highly recommend this book just beware that when you reach the end you’ll be desperate for more.
Read more
T. M.
4.0 out of 5 stars Tough Heroine, Troubled Anti-Hero and a Great Take on Vampirism
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on August 30, 2014
Verified Purchase
I loved this, even though it is yet another vampire book. The heroine is not a Mary-Sue, the anti-hero is convincingly troubled rather than dashing and brooding, and the plot revolves around a remotely believable premise: that Tana, the heroine, doesn't want to turn into a vampire. Unlike many YA books, her motives and goals change along with the plot, and this is a real strength.

Holly Black begins her story with Tana waking up after a sundown party, finding herself the only survivor of a brutal vampire attack. We aren't encouraged to sympathise with vampires or find them mysterious and attractive, and Tana's own past fills in some of the gaps in our vampire-knowledge without creating boring exposition-dumps. She rescues her ex and the vampire who is chained up next to him, and they make for the nearest Coldtown.

Coldtown's are like leper colonies for vampires. One big strength of Black's book is that the condition of vampirism is treated like an epidemic that must be militarily contained, and this conflicts with the way that some vampires view themselves - as Masters of the Universe and even bizarre reality TV stars.

I really enjoyed it. The plot isn't overly predictable and the characters' decisions are realistic. It's a good new twist on a tired theme, and there are no shadows of a trilogy emerging so it's a great stand-alone read.
Read more
annoushkadomynique
4.0 out of 5 stars Who said paranormal was dead?
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on May 18, 2014
Verified Purchase
You know when you go to a concert and the band leaves the stage because its “over” but the crowd knows that there will be an encore, so everyone starts chanting “WE WANT MORE, WE WANT MORE!” over and over until they come back on. Well, that’s all I can hear in my head while writing this review. Although I thoroughly enjoyed this book I cant help but feel a little let down with the ending. This is a standalone novel but could easily be part of a duology or even a series. Has Holly Black purposefully left this open ended or is that really it?

This book had been on my radar for quite some time prior to this review. Having not read anything by Holly Black before I thought it was time to give her a go. Believe me, it certainly won’t be the last time I read a book of hers. Although this had its flaws, I was able to look past them and enjoy the book for what it is.

Admittedly I'm always sceptic to read paranormal fiction as it has become annoyingly tiresome since twilight. I mean, what vampire sparkles in the sun and is a vegetarian? I'm sorry Edward but you just aren't cutting it for me. I want malicious, natural born hunters. I want vampires who kill with no remorse and take everything they can get. I’m not looking for a love story. I’m looking for straight up badassery! You’ll be glad to know that this book has it all, everything that I mentioned above and more is included is this brilliantly crafted novel.

The Coldest Girl in Coldtown was a refreshing read as it is the polar opposite of Twilight. Right from the offset I knew that I was going to enjoy this book, the premise was exciting and Holly Blacks writing was incredible. I didn’t think that I’d get so caught up in this world that Black has created but I crave more of it. No, I don’t crave it…I need it.

I don’t want to spoil you too much; instead I urge y’all to give this book a chance because if you’re anything like me then you’ll love it. This is an unforgettable book that I know I will enjoy rereading over and over again. I can’t help but think that paranormal fiction is finally redeeming itself; with authors such as Holly Black, Julie Kagawa and Jennifer L Armentrout around I have hope for the genre.
Read more

See all reviews