Customer reviews

4.3 out of 5 stars
4.3 out of 5
270 global ratings
5 star
59%
4 star
25%
3 star
9%
2 star
4%
1 star
3%
How are ratings calculated?
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.

Review this product


Reviews with images

Customer image
Customer image
See all customer images

Read reviews that mention

science fiction downbelow station signy mallory earth company space station pell station hugo award highly recommended writing style character development feels like space opera konstantin family damon konstantin captain signy good guys world building pell and its world starting point even though
Top reviews

Top reviews from the United States

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars Maybe not for everyone, but still a classic.
Reviewed in the United States on May 9, 2014
Verified Purchase
First, a couple of caveats about C.J. Cherry's writing in this book and her science fiction in general. Her stories tend to be more about culture clash and psychological tension over razor-sharp scientific accuracy or rollicking space-opera type action. That being said she DID do a lot of a astronomical research and tried to keep things internally consistent. This book was written in 1981 so many of the technological references are horribly dated (for instance, there's references to magnetic tape being loaded into computers). Since the technology is more of a backdrop for the drama, this isn't really a problem. As Cherryh states in the book's relatively new introduction, the main point of the story is about how geographic (or in this case) interstellar separation causes people to change, and how technological innovation then brings these now very different types of people together in often less-than-pleasant ways.

Cherry's writing style also isn't for everyone. She tends not to explain things right away, and a lot of the storytelling is through terse, often jargon-laden dialogue. Often the context or significance is explained later as the story or character is developed. I tend to look at this as a feature, but some people are turned off by the lack of exposition.

Downbelow Station sets up the entire Alliance-Union universe that comprised the bulk of her writing (in spite of the fact that some books published earlier are also considered part of that universe). By necessity its' scope is very broad, and there's an awful lot of characters and factions to keep track of. To me, it was sort of like Game of Thrones in space, except that there's no sex with underage girls and there's no chance the author is going to die before the story is finished. The story takes a while to really get going in part because it's got to set this grand stage. In particular, the first chapter is a somewhat dry but well-written summary of the three centuries of history leading up to the events of the novel.

In short, slower-than-light travel was how humans originally began exploring the stars. Most of the systems had no habitable worlds so self-sufficient space stations were the norm until two habitable worlds, called Pell's World (or simply "Downbelow" by the character's in the novel) and Cyteen are discovered. Pell is inhabited by sentient but primitive aliens known as the Hisa, so it's never seriously colonized. Cyteen, however, has no intellgent local life and, contrary to the orders of the distant Earth Company, the world is settled.

Eventually, faster-than-light travel is established, and the faster communications between Earth and it's far-flung stations leads to some complications. The Earth Company wants to exert more control on what it sees as its company assets, while the people who have been living in those assets for generations tend to think of them as their own property. In particular the people living on distant Cyteen and its nearby stations have gotten pretty damn strange by Earth standards. Trade disputes turn into low-grade warfare, and eventually snowball into full-blown interstellar warfare.

The story of Downbelow station is told through the leaders of the various factions that interact with each other. Those factions and the characters that represent them are:

The Earth Company. This is the large corporation that apparently had a monopoly on space travel. Due to politics on Earth the Company hasn't had any real involvement in the war since building the fleet. Now they've sent a delegation to Pell which is demanding transport further into "the Beyond." Segust Ayres heads up the team, and the chapters with the company delegates are from his point of view.

The Fleet: The Earth Company Fleet once numbered 50 captial warships ("carriers" in the book's parlance), at the beginning of the novel they are now reduced to 15 ships. The Fleet has been on its own for most of the war, getting very little in the way of guidance or material support from the Earth Company. They've mostly been resorting to hit & run tactics, with ship captains acting individually until the events of the novel unfold. The two main Fleet Character's are it's daring commander, Conrad Maizan, and Signy Mallory, the ruthless commander of the Norway and the 3rd most senior officer of the Fleet.

The Union: Centered on Cyteen, the Union is portayed as relatively alien. In order to increase their population base they cloned large numbers of soldiers, and in general their culture seems to be one of intense centralization and control. The Union characters are Seb Azov, the Union's military commander, Josh Talley, a marooned Union starship crewman, and Jessad, a Union covert agent.

The Pell Stationers: Pell Station is the largest of the star-stations, and while they have a decently habitable world below them they have chosen not to have more than a token presence on the surface due to their policy of non-interference with the Hisa. Pell Station is run by two families: the Konstantins and the Lukases, who are intense political rivals. The Konstantins are headed by Angelo and Alicia (an invalid and the sister of Jon Lukas), and their sons are Damon and Alicia. Damon is married to Elen Quen, who is from a prominent Merchanter family. The Lukases are primarily represented by Jon Lukas. The stations have tried to stay officially neutral in the war, although they rely on the Fleet for protection.

Q Section: The survivors of the other Company star-stations that have been evacuated by the Fleet and sent to Pell. Due to the fact that one of the other stations was destroyed by sabotage the Konstantins put them in quarantine (or "Q") until they can be properly identified and any Union agents are weeded out. Q section is nominally led by Vassily Kressich, a refugee who's really a puppet for the criminal gang that actually runs Q.

The Merchanters: "Merchanter" is the name for the family-run trading ships that ply the various stations. The Merchanters have a gypsy-like lifestyle: the live most of their lives on their starships and only interact with the stations to trade, recreation, and to add to their gene pool. Elen Quen is the primary merchanter character. The rest of her family is a casualty to the war, she survived because she elected to have a child with Damon Konstantin. The Merchanters are also officially neutral, even though they technically did start the war when they resisted Union attempts to seize their ships and called for Company help.

The Hisa: Small, furry, primitive humanoids native to Downbelow. Called "Downers" by the humans. They have a very peaceful, relatively non-materialistic culture. The Konstantins have had a very "hands off" approach to the Hisa and their world. They only maintain a small human presence on the planet (mostly farms to support the station and trade foodstuffs with the merchanters and fleet), and "hire" Hisa workers to help out with the planet-side base as well as helping with maintenance on the station. The Lukases would like to exploit the Hisa more, but are often blocked by the Konstantins from doing so. The main Hisa characters are referred to by the names given to them by the humans: Satin, Bluetooth, and Lily. They are probably the least well-developed of Cherry's aliens, and mainly serve to illustrate the various personality traits and motivations of the human characters.

As the story opens, the war is clearly winding down. Signy Mallory is leading a refugee convoy to Pell to unceremonously dump the survivors of two stations (Mariner and Russell). At Mallory's urging, Angelo Konstantin set's up a quarantine section fot the refugees because the survivors are traumatized, may contain one or more saboteurs (Mariner's was "blown"), and certainly contain criminal elements. She also finds out there's a delegation present from the Earth Company, which is demanding she take them closer to the battlefront. Mallory refuses, warns the Konstantins that more refugees are coming, and leaves. At the same time, there is a changing of the guard on the human outpost on Downbelow. Emilio Konstantin is replacing Jon Lukas as the head of the outpost, Lukas returns to the station just as these destabilizing influences arrive, and sees an opportunity to better his position or at least make sure he loses less than the Konstantins.

What follows is a series of events and rising tension between the various factions as it's clear the Fleet is losing the war rather rapidly, and increasingly acts in predatory ways towards the stationers and merchanters it was originally supposed to protect. It's quite clear Union wants to control the entire Beyond (the area outside of Earth's solar system) and is willing to do anything to achieve that goal. The Merchanters and Stationers are trying to hold on to what they've got as the situation unravels, with the latter suffering further because of the conflicting interests of the Konstantins, Lukases, and Q Section. Added to this are the goals of the Earth Company, which are not necessarily in the best interests of anyone else.

As I said before, the story starts somewhat slowly, but I found the novel's climax rather satisfying and several of the key characters rather compelling. One of the things I like about Cherryh's characterizations is that while the various characters often have very strong convictions or motivations for what they do, there isn't any sort of "black and white" morality and her characters tend to be rather nuanced. This isn't to say that her work is nihilistic, but that it tends to read more like real-world history and not at all like a morality play.
Read more
Robert Hafner
4.0 out of 5 stars Fantastic Book, Horrible Editing on the Kindle Edition
Reviewed in the United States on December 21, 2014
Verified Purchase
This is a fantastic book that takes place in a universe full of depth.

Too bad the editors of the Kindle edition just called it in. I have never seen so many typos in a single book, but it goes beyond just that. There are multiple places in the book where the wrong character name is used- in one chapter I was horribly confused as to how characters managed to magically transport themselves from the surface to the space station, and then half way through the chapter they start using the right names again. Dialogue is ridiculously hard to follow because they shove multiple characters lines into the same paragraph with nothing to distinguish one from another.

This was so bad that I'm planning on asking for a refund. I wish everyone would read this book, but for your own sake buy the paperback instead of the kindle edition.
Read more
John Bates
3.0 out of 5 stars Grows on you
Reviewed in the United States on February 4, 2019
Verified Purchase
The good guys are called "Company" and the baddies are "Union", what more do you need or want to know about the point of view being expressed here, I thought to myself. But it's not so simple in the end. Less forgivable is the happy colonialism of the good guys,and their loving enslavement of a race of simpletons who are only too happy to perform menial labor. It's too familiar and yet unexamined. But the end of the book changed my perception of some of my complaints.
What took more getting used to was the writing style which is very immediate and context-free most of the time. Much like watching a film shot entirely with a hand-held camera from a first person perspective. It's not a style I like in film and I took a long time to warm to it here as well.
But inevitably with a long well-plotted epic, the characters and story grow on you. I must admit, I never grew bored or wanted to stop reading and in the end I was glad for the experience, even if the book isn't entirely sure what it wants to say. Or perhaps its politics are just dated, from a time when mainstream thought didn't examine ideas like colonialism and slavery quite so closely.
Read more
John Stults
VINE VOICE
5.0 out of 5 stars Good, thought provoking novel
Reviewed in the United States on July 7, 2016
Verified Purchase
I read the kindle version and had no problems with it (cannot always say that about some of the ebooks). I came to thsi story having already read Cyteen (another good story) as well as several others in the company union universe. The author goes into a lot of background in the beginning setting the stage but introduces items thru out the book. What I like (and this goes for Cyteen as well) the author does not spell everything out but makes you use your mind to fill in the story. (So it you are looking for a formulaic YA story skip this one--but if you want to think this book is for you). I enjoyed the novel but if you are looking for good guys vs bad guys you will probably be disappointed as most of the characters come in various shades of gray some are just grayer than others. The story is well worth the time invested in reading it.
Read more
Barry Melius
4.0 out of 5 stars A rock and a hard place
Reviewed in the United States on April 18, 2017
Verified Purchase
All Pell Station wanted was to be left alone. Meanwhile a three way multi-system war raged. As the book opens one side is powerless,one side is losing badly and the third is moping up. And Pell Station,it's right in the middle as the last desperate moves are being made. In depth, sympathetic characters are trapped in something implacable that is going to take a lot of them down with it. Up against a wall is a good place to find out what one really stands for and our protagonists get that opportunity. They deserve sympathy and get it from the author. Presented with depth, breadth and compassion,flinching not at presenting hard truth in a grim situation C.J. Cherryh leaves us with hope. Recommended.
Read more

See all reviews

Top reviews from other countries

R G Palmer
5.0 out of 5 stars Absorbing Sci-Fi classic.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on February 8, 2016
Verified Purchase
Having read the excellent (if long-winded) 'Cyteen', I decided to read CJ Cherryh's previous Hugo Award winner, 'Downbelow Station'. And what a great book it is, filled with interesting characters, political intrigue, social commentary and 'war zone' style action: as others have said, pure 'space opera'. A bit like Star Trek, this book takes today's ideas, problems and human values and transports them into a well described future landscape. The descriptions of the docks, the space station, the planet, the battleships, are all very vivid and colourful. Yes, you could argue that whilst the 'Fi' is very well imagined, she falls down sometimes on the 'Sci' bit - tape cassettes in 2350? They are obsolete in 2016! However, this is an issue common to most science fiction - in some ways, it needs to be, because we can only relate to a lot of what is going on if we can apply at least some of our contemporary contexts to it. A really absorbing, clever, interesting book - I have already started on the next one. And it doesn't seem to matter either in which order you choose to read about the history of the Alliance/Union - these stories are interrelated but completely separate. Wish I'd discovered CJ Cherryh years before now!
Read more
Hydra
5.0 out of 5 stars A quick comment to say that I absolutely love this book
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on August 29, 2016
Verified Purchase
A quick comment to say that I absolutely love this book: the tension in it, the images of giant spaceships rolling around in deep space, the characters (I always identify Mallory with CJ for some reason!), the Downers, the whole world CJ has founded, the action…

Marvellous, simply marvellous – every time I read it I find new things in it.

I've re-read the book countless times, and am about to re-read all the Downbelow Station novels again.

What is also interesting is how CJ's style can change between different 'sets' of books. These ones are so different from the world of the Atevi and Bren in the Foreigner books, which are also superb, especially the first ten or so.
Read more
William Donelson
4.0 out of 5 stars Great space opera, good characters, pacing and descriptions
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on May 18, 2015
Verified Purchase
Very good, loved it. Great space opera, plus some wonderful alien life on the planet below. Good pacing and characters, descriptive and clever. Since this was written originally in 1980-81, the computer and technology "of the future" is very dated (with printouts being used etc), but this is still a great story, worth reading. Wish there were more of C.J. Cherryh "Alliance Universe" for Kindle format.
Read more
Mr
5.0 out of 5 stars Very pleased indeed.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on August 24, 2015
Verified Purchase
Superb re-issue. Very pleased indeed.
Read more
Buzzwagon
5.0 out of 5 stars Fantastic read
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on January 29, 2015
Verified Purchase
A hidden gem if you've not read it before.
Read more

See all reviews