Customer reviews

4.7 out of 5

9,927 global ratings

5 star

80%

How customer reviews and ratings work

Review this product

Reviews with images

See all photos

Sort reviews by

Top reviews from the United States

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

D. Safir

Simply a masterpiece of history about one of the darkest times in man's life on this planet.

Reviewed in the United States on January 5, 2018

Verified Purchase

This is an incredible book. I have not ready any other histories of Nazi Germany, but I can't imagine another more comprehensive account of the horror that was the Third Reich. This was not an easy read. I started this early in my life and, for reasons I don't recollect, never got into it. That was a long time ago. I finally decided that I must read this, if only for the fact that my family went through this and beloved members of my family lost their lives to this. I can't say this was a totally enjoyable read, but that was not the purpose. In reading this book I began to get a clearer understanding of how such an atrocity could have come to exist. There are many ironies in the book. If Hitler's grandfather had not belatedly married his grandmother, he would have remained Adolf Schicklgruber and certainly would not have achieved any of the power that he did. And the plots to overthrow him, from within his own ranks, time and again failed, once only by the fact of a detonator failing to go off. There are so many fascinating things to learn in this book. You do not have to be a history buff, only to have the need to understand how such an abomination could happen. There are many names, too many for me to keep track of. And I finally stopped reading every footnote. If I was given a test on this material, I probably would flunk it. But reading it, not as an obligation, but for an understanding of this bleak moment in our world's history, it is a masterpiece. Taken from the actual written diaries and source material from the Nazis, themselves, this is the ultimate book on Hitler, the Nazis and the Third Reich. If you choose to read this book, be prepared for an extremely detailed account of every correspondence, letter, speech, meeting that went on with each move and conjecture in this almost chess game of a war. It can get tedious. This is not an action novel. Sometimes you want to yell out, "Come on! Get on with the action!" But this is a history, not a novel. You have to understand that and go with it. Also, I started to get annoyed that there was so much on the war and nothing about the concentration camp atrocities and the genocide that was taking place. Mr. Shirer decided to put that all in one chapter about three quarters of the way through the book. So, it is not left out. Just put in its own special chapter. One glaring omission, which I cannot understand is that there is not one mention of Dr. Mengele, the most infamous doctor of the Third Reich, although there is a sub-chapter on the doctors and their cruel medical experiments. Maybe someone can explain this to me. All in all, this is a masterpiece and a must-read for anyone who wants to know about this event in history!

Minnie I.

Sixty Years Later, This Book Remains Chilling and Foreboding

Reviewed in the United States on January 15, 2019

Verified Purchase

After visiting a reunified Germany, I began to wonder how such intelligent, organized, proper people could have fallen for the myth of Hitler. So I decided to read this book. And although the book doesn't specifically address this issue, even sixty years later, it provides insights into the ways a population (and the world) can be hoodwinked. As such, it also provides a stark warning to the 21st century about leadership, charisma, propaganda (the control of the media), courage, and critical thinking.

Shirer, unlike so many of today's "journalistic" books, provides a narrative that is probably 90 percent objective. Throughout the book, Shirer bases his reporting on sources captured after the Nazi defeat. These include memoranda, entries from personal diaries, and even some one-on-one interviews with former Nazis. You can see the era's bias such as those against homosexuals (often referred to as "perverts") come into play, but given WHEN the book was written, this is not unexpected nor does it diminish the significance of the report. When Shirer expressed a personal opinion, like those from his diary, he made it blatantly clear that these were his impressions. So what I appreciated most about this book is that Shirer cited almost everything he wrote about (I wish they had used letters or numbers for the chapter endnotes instead of asterisks in the Kindle edition) and often included exact verbiage (translated from German, of course) from the documents he reviewed.

While his coverage of the Fuhrer and his growing megalomania is frightening enough, I found that his reporting on Joseph Goebbels' role in creating an atmosphere of belief in the Nazis in Germany the most frightening--and foreboding--of all. Goebbels understood from the getgo that people believe what they want to believe, and he used this understanding effectively. Goebbels controlled ALL media, all messaging, all symbolism for the Reich. As a media professional myself, I was stunned at his ability, as early as the 1930s, to understand the power of popular media. Not only did he use thuggery to silence opposing views, but his media savvy in movie-making, radio broadcasts, timing, event-staging, and even bunting were used to inspire a demoralized population into believing or at least not contradicting the unthinkable. He successfully usurped music, philosophy, and even religion to create a mass delusion among the German people. In my opinion, this may have been one of the main reasons a decent population eventually was caught up in the whole hegemony of Hitler. Certainly, there are other important contributing factors--the economy, a weak government, the depression, etc.--but Goebbels leveraged all of this things to create the big lie that others, particularly the Jews and the Slavs--were responsible for the fate of Germany. To me, this insight has the most relevance for today when Hollywood creates its own version of history, where "journalists" have no problem slanting news (on both sides of the aisle) to their point of view, where politicians have no problems with telling people what they want to hear, and where both political parties have stooped to a level of name-calling and dehumanization of the other. These were tactics that were found in the political milieu of Nazi Germany. While we have not reached that level, it is important to understand just exactly what and how Goebbels created a societal belief that supported the war machine and extermination of so many innocent people. And part of that media message was always terror and intimidation.

Besides this insight, Shirer provides us with personal glimpses into some of the key players of the Reich. He documents how "fateful" incidents impacted the decisions of the combatants' strategic decisions and the outcome of the war. The book is long and detailed but provides a good look at this unfortunate time in history. While most of the "greatest generation" have long since left this world, this book reminds us of the circumstances that created the twelve horrific years of the Third Reich. It is vital that we remember those years and the lessons learned from World War II. Unfortunately, I think many people will think the sheer volume of this book is overwhelming. But once into the book, I think readers will find it hard to put down. I know I did.

Top reviews from other countries

Translate all reviews to English

brunobv

Livro em Primeira Pessoa

Reviewed in Brazil on August 19, 2023

Verified Purchase

Ao contrário dos demais livros sobre o tema, como a trilogia de Richard E. Evans, esta obra é escrita por uma testemunha ocular dos fatos. Willian Shriver foi correspondente jornalística na Alemanha durante o entre guerras, e narra fatos históricos com riquezas de detalhes que somente quem esteve presente aos eventos seria capaz de capturar. Todavia, não é uma obra enciclopédica. É um instantâneo riquíssimo em detalhes e costurado de forma magistral, uma leitura muito agradável e informativa, ainda que, de certa forma, já esteja datado por alguns conceitos hoje ultrapassados.

Louis Duong

Authentic Retelling of Nazi Germany

Reviewed in Canada on July 2, 2021

Verified Purchase

The author writes in detail about his experiences and the events that occurred in Germany before and after the rise of Nazi Germany in this lengthy book. The retelling of the development of the Nazi state is neutral, factual and is worded in a way that is easy to understand. The author also speaks about Hitler's personal life and what Germany was like while Hitler was a child. Quotes are given from people who were in the Nazi state and from Mein Kampf, Hitler's Propaganda Book, to help the reader understand the situation in and Germany at the time and Hitler, who's personality is only known on the surface level to many. Footnotes are written within the chapters to provide clarification and give additional information of certain things or people. Overall, this book is suited to those who desire to better understand the history of Nazi Germany or want an insider perspectives of the events that transpired in the Nazi state.

Lord Denning

Excellent if you excuse the homophobia

Reviewed in the United Kingdom on February 10, 2024

Verified Purchase

I would not consider myself a big history buff or even a big reader, but this is a brilliant read. Better paced and more gripping than most fiction. It is regrettable that the author makes some homophobic remarks in places - I guess he was from a different time himself, much like the monsters he is writing about.

Kyrylo Shaptala

A must read

Reviewed in Germany on January 29, 2023

Verified Purchase

Great book but really inconvenient to read

Diogo

Must read

Reviewed in Spain on December 7, 2022

Verified Purchase

Just read it.

See more reviews