Customer reviews

4.2 out of 5 stars
4.2 out of 5
5,509 global ratings
5 star
45%
4 star
36%
3 star
13%
2 star
4%
1 star
2%
How are ratings calculated?
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.

Review this product



Customer images

Customer image
See all customer images

Read reviews that mention

robert harris von braun world war wernher von kay caton-walsh german rocket rocket program rudi graf historical fiction good read werner von well researched air force officer and a spy tells the story launch site looked forward destroy the launch auxiliary air historical detail
Top reviews

Top reviews from the United States

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Dan Berger
VINE VOICE
5.0 out of 5 stars A German and a British woman who have never met are connected by the trajectory of a V2 rocket
Reviewed in the United States on November 24, 2020
Verified Purchase
I’m glad someone based a World War II story on this subject that seems not to make it into fiction that often. The V2 rockets are the theme of “Gravity’s Rainbow” by Thomas Pynchon, but despite its Important Literature gloss it’s a famously unreadable book not reaching many readers.

You wonder why V2s don’t get into novels more often. After all, they fit right in with the stereotype of brilliant German scientists doing cutting edge work for an evil cause.

The Germans build this stunning weapon, the first ballistic missile, and use it to terrifying effect starting in late 1944. It’s too late to change the war’s course, but the Nazis make propaganda with it. Morale is damaged as the British government can’t protect its people from it.

The V2s don’t kill an extraordinary number of people, around 9000, far fewer than have died in accumulated bombings of England going back to the Battle of Britain - or in Allied bombing raids on Germany.

But they are terrifying. Their engines cut out after launching them on a perfect path toward London, and then they hurtle silently at several times the speed of sound, until crushing through British roofs, homes, business buildings and streets with no warning a few minutes after launch. There’s no time to get to an air raid shelter.

They are also aimed at Antwerp, the Allies’ key Continental port after D-Day. But most target London.

They don’t have a long range. Developed at Peenemunde on Germany’s Baltic coast, and manufactured by slave labor at Nordhausen out of range of Allied bombers, they must be brought by rail to the Dutch coast near The Hague to be fired.

I gather the British clamped such secrecy on it, suppressing photos of the damage and at first trying to pass off missile hits as gas main explosions, that they didn’t enter the written record quite the way they should have. The V2s did have lasting impact: they damage or destroy nearly 600,000 homes, making many people homeless and contributing to a London housing shortage for years after the war.

Here, Harris tells the story through two principal characters. On the rocket manufacturing side is Rudi Graf, a rocket scientist and boyhood friend of rocket program leader Wernher von Braun. Graf’s entire adult life has been spent on rockets. His and von Braun’s futuristic fascination with them, dating back to their youth in Weimar Germany, was always about going to the moon.

Through Graf’s eyes we get a close-up view of the compelling von Braun. He wangles financial support from the new Nazi regime when he is only 20. He seduces Hitler himself with his visions (and was said, I’ve read elsewhere, to be the only person to dare crack jokes with him.) Effortlessly charming, an aristocrat without being a snob, he knows the right thing to say to everyone. He collaborates with the party and SS without becoming enamored of either, in order to get what he needs to build his rockets. Harris has a great quote here about von Braun not building rockets to win the war, but having a war to build his rockets.

With the SS calling the shots, the factory becomes a slave labor project. Many more slaves die at Nordhausen than British civilians do in London. The Nazis starve the German population, taking the entire potato crop to make ethanol for rocket fuel.

Graf is von Braun’s rocket specialist at the launch site, fixing last minute problems just before the candle is lit. He grew up a Social Democrat and has drawn scrutiny for loose talk once while drunk, but von Braun has managed to protect him. In the days this story covers, he’s having more trouble justifying what he’s doing and with SS bigs breathing down his neck, he’s a long way from von Braun’s sheltering wing.

On the receiving end of the V2s is Kay Caton-Walsh. We meet the young WAAF officer as a building where she’s just dallied with her married lover is hit by a V2.

She survives with bumps and bruises, he’s hurt worse, but the incident exposes their affair. Sensing she’s just a notch in his bedpost, needing to flee the gossip and his wife, Kay finagles a transfer. She’s been analyzing air photos of occupied Europe, and has spent hours poring over Peenemunde and the forested launch area near The Hague. The trouble is the British can’t find it, and the reason they can’t is that the launch sites are portable.

Her new job takes her to the front lines in Belgium to work on that problem. A brand-new WAAF team will take data from radar units tracking a rocket from moments after launch. When the impact site in London is pinpointed and telephoned to them, they quickly calculate its trajectory back towards the exact launch site, and transmit that to RAF pilots already in the air. They’ll try to take out the next missile being readied for launch.

There are a few problems with the story. You don’t get a sense for how Kay or her lover, or anyone in a building, survives a direct V2 strike. The rocket is 45 feet high, weighs 14 tons, strikes its target at 3000 mph, and is armed with a ton of high explosives. But the casualty counts Harris cites show lowish death tolls the norm: these fantastically expensive rockets kill only a few people at a time. Any Middle Eastern car bomb parked in a market or outside a mosque kills more for a fraction of the cost.

Mostly, though, this is a fine glimpse into every angle of the V2 story. The ground forces supporting the RAF late in the war when the Luftwaffe can no longer attack Britain. The WAAFs who do sensitive intelligence jobs. The starving Belgian civilians recently liberated by the Allies, their society more problematic now than we might imagine. And German rocket scientists who make their deal with the devil and survive the terror regime to develop a weapon of mass destruction - just to pursue their rocket-building dreams.

Von Braun uses a line about how the first person to set foot on the moon has already been born. Neil Armstrong was born in 1930, and von Braun, who transferred his loyalties to the USA and led the building of NASA’s rockets, lived to see him do it. He arguably put Armstrong there.
Read more
Kindle Customer
2.0 out of 5 stars Plotless
Reviewed in the United States on November 28, 2020
Verified Purchase
I loved Robert Harris' recent efforts Munich, Conclave, and An Officer and a Spy. All of those take an actual historical setting, and in two of those even an actual historical occurrence, and almost let the story tell itself. That works when that story, and the historical context, is as incredibly fascinating (Officer and a Spy) or morbidly interesting (Munich) as those stories actually were. It doesn't work, however, if there really isn't a story that can tell itself. And that's the issue in this book: it's mildly interesting to read about Wernher von Braun's combination of genius and personality that first propelled the German and then the U.S. rocket program forward. But you can look that up on Wikipedia. Beyond that, I waited for 95% of the book when an actual story would start, or if there'd be some gigantic unexpected plot twist at the end that would make the largely uninteresting exposition up until then finally interesting - but none of that happens, and you put the book away wondering what the point was.
Read more
a reader
2.0 out of 5 stars a disappointment
Reviewed in the United States on November 18, 2020
Verified Purchase
I've read three or four of Harris' books but this one fails terribly. The first part is interesting for the technical details about the V2 rockets and the effort to locate their launch sites. But the plot generally is just a sappy soap opera centered around some female mathematicians. I have great trouble giving up on a book so I give two stars because I finished it but that's all.
Read more
steve A
4.0 out of 5 stars Opposite sides of one story.
Reviewed in the United States on November 29, 2020
Verified Purchase
The author did a fantastic job capturing the ambience and real characters who were involved with and affected by the V2 rocket program during the latter days of world war two. The most impressive accomplishment was breathing life into two protagonists on opposite sides of the conflict, in Britain and in Nazi occupied Netherlands.
The only reason I didn't assign five stars was that I felt there was enough material here to justify a longer book, developing the historical material more deeply. For example, the launching of the missiles continued for four more months beyond the November 1944 setting, while allied troops were nearby on their advance toward Berlin. There may have also been a great story in how the scientists and engineers managed to avoid the Russians and deliver themselves into the hands of the Americans. Also, the two protagonists eventually met in London after the war, but their relationship was never developed.
I leaned quite a bit about how the missiles operated and how their launch sites can be determined from calculating their parabolic trajectories using quadratic equations with logarithmic exponents.
A very rewarding read.
Read more
William de Rham
4.0 out of 5 stars More of an “Historical” than a “Thriller.”
Reviewed in the United States on November 27, 2020
Verified Purchase
Robert Harris’s V-2 is a two-plot novel focusing on Germany’s V-2 rocket program from both the German and English perspective. There are two main characters: Rudi, a German engineer who works with Werner Von Braun; and Kay, an English WAAF assigned to a project to locate and destroy V-2 launch sites in Holland.

Although billed by some as a thriller, V-2 is actually more of a fictional examination of all facets of the V-2 program, from its origins with Von Braun and his rocket club, to its construction through the employment of slave labor, to the effects of its use against England, to British attempts to combat it with radar and slide-rule mathematics, to its central role in the post-war development of the US space program and the Apollo moon missions.

Anyone interested in rocketry and its history should enjoy Mr. Harris’s latest offering.
Read more

See all reviews

Top reviews from other countries

S. Evans
1.0 out of 5 stars Time Harris retired from writing.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on October 9, 2020
Verified Purchase
I once ranked Robert Harris alongside the truly great modern thriller writers. up there with Phillip Kerr, Frederick Forsyth and John le Carrier, in the tradition set a generation earlier by such greats as Len Deighton, Alastair Maclean and Hammond Innes. After strugglng with the wafer thin plot and abysmal characterisation in the first hundred or so pages of V2 I wonder, not for the first time, how I ever came to be a fan. Has Harris been taking lessons in padding from the arch plodder Sansom? The boring heroine accepts a cigarette although she doesn't really smoke, and having finished it throws the stub out of the car. Really? She didn't drop it in the petrol tank, or shove it up someone's arse? At least that might have encouraged us to read on. Not once does someone arrive at a military unit without being stopped by a guard and having their papers examined. Over and over. Hard to understand why Harris keeps writing when he obviously no longer takes a pride in it. A quiet and surely very comfortable retirement should now beckon. But please, no more books like this one which, as another reviewer has pointed out, would never have found a publisher coming from an unknown author. Let this once fine writer take a hint from his increasingly lukewarm Amazon reviews, so much more reliable than the sycophantic drivel in the national press.
Read more
gerardpeter
5.0 out of 5 stars Cupid's Rocket
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on September 22, 2020
Verified Purchase
Robert Harris is simply very good at historical fiction.

This is set in November 1944. The V2 was a ballistic missile targeted on London, the final fruit of a military project that stretched back a decade. By the time it was used France had been reoccupied and the Red Army was outside Berlin. It had no impact on the outcome of World War 2. The rocket programme was to achieve longer term significance when it was taken over by the Americans who recruited its leading engineers and scientists.

We meet Dr Rudi Graf, a fictional assistant to Wernher Von Braun. Like his mentor he was drawn to rockets by a dream of space travel and a journey to the moon. He is more than unhappy about the use of his ideas but feels he has no control. “He felt himself to be like one of the rockets – a human machine, launched on a fixed trajectory, impossible to recall, hurtling to a point that was preordained”.

At the other end of the rocket, literally, we meet the fictional Kay Caton-Walsh a WAAF in England, “middle-class well-educated young English woman”. She works in military intelligence tracking the flight of the V2. Her commitment to her role is rather greater. The novel alternates between Kay and Rudi.

Harris explains how the rocket worked and its limitations, and how British intelligence tried to deflect its aim. I found this really interesting. Harris also builds up tension and excitement in his description of the launch of the V2 and its flight and fall. He captures well the tiredness and weariness and hunger as the long war comes to an end, and the search for love and affection.

Harris explains how he came by the idea and appends a reading list on historical background. What is his own is the craft of telling a story. His writing seems effortless and the ending is just what it should be.
Read more
Michael Field
5.0 out of 5 stars Victory v Vengeance
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on September 22, 2020
Verified Purchase
Robert Harris is one of my favourite authors but I can never be sure of whether each book will be one comes up to his best standards, perhaps to make a story gripping which should be dull, or one which might not make the most of its subject matter.

This is a wonderful book, which halfway through I thought I had some doubts about, but no. The technical side is fascinating and the way it comes together with the human one is spot on.

The scene setting is so immersive that it makes you tense and glance around. People's characters are vividly drawn and movingly respected. The story is just that, slowly and impeccably consistent. In short, the author at his best.

I can't think of another situation in my experience of fiction where characters are so dramatically linked at a distance between their different worlds as Rudi and Kay, when a V2 is flying. A scene right near the end, which I mustn't spoil, is almost unbearably poignant.

There's a personal element for me. Mum was in the firing line of the rockets. Victory or Vengeance? Their world or ours? See both here and thank all goodness it went the right way.

Full marks.
Read more
CBS
4.0 out of 5 stars Very Good; Perhaps Not His Best
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on October 1, 2020
Verified Purchase
Robert Harris is one of the very few authors whose books I buy without prior inspection. Not all his books are equally good; for me The Ghost and The Fear Index were ho-hum. But the classics: Fatherland, Enigma, Pompeii; and the three Cicero titles, are without equal. To those add An Officer and a Spy and Munich. In short, Mr Harris' works are almost all brilliant. They do atmosphere so well and tangibly that you can almost cut it with a knife; technical detail is always good; historical accuracy is excellent; and characterisation and observance of idiosyncrasies are marvellous. And finally, if those weren't enough, writing style and plot just pull you along.

V2 is good, if not in the very top rank. It betrays something of having been written quickly while under COVID 'lockdown'. The history, as ever, is good: of the V2 itself; of the attacks on London; of the terrible subterranean factory of Nordhausen/Mittelbau-Dora. The plot is clever. The ending is beguiling, reminding me a little of the denouement of Pompeii (check and compare for yourself).

There's no danger of ever wearying or considering abandoning the book. The characters are maybe a bit cardboard. More could have been done with Kay Caton-Walsh, although Wernher von Braun and his (fictional) sidekick Rudi Graf are well depicted. I somehow didn't get the sense of wartime atmosphere you can almost 'taste' in Enigma and Munich. As an aside: is not Kay a bit casually promiscuous for a 24-year-old upper-middle-class young lady in 1944 England?

But the book is still very good and I recommend it without hesitation. Mr Harris has matured in the 30 years, almost, since Fatherland. The stories are now somehow quieter and more observational. A few reviewers say that not much happens. They don't know their Harris: body-counts, gore, sex, overt violence and catastrophe are not necessary to spin a good tale. This is one.
Read more
Time Traveller
2.0 out of 5 stars Candidly not very good, even on the historical aspects.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on September 21, 2020
Verified Purchase
I was suprised by how relatively unengaging this was, perhaps because the writing seemed rather rushed. Harris has written some great historical novels in the past, there is a lot of critical stuff missing here that could easily have been slipped in, including, to take just one example, the relatively successful efforts of British Intelligence to divert the missiles away from London via deceptive feedback. Characterisation also felt a bit haphazard and not especially convincing, compared to some of his earleir works.
Read more

See all reviews