Before there were 13 colonies, there was New Netherland. Founded by the Dutch, this tiny community on the edge of the wilderness supported a staggering array of peoples: Norwegians, Germans, Italians, free and slave Africans, Jews, Bohemians, Mohawk Indians, and more. Surrounded by intolerant Puritans, New Netherland took its cues from Amsterdam, Europe's most liberal city. Inevitably the Dutch and the English clashed, and a new nation was born.
With an extraordinary cast of real-life characters, including Rene Descartes and James, the Duke of York, The Island at the Center of the World is a riveting narrative and a landmark in the chronicles of American history.
©2004 Russell Shorto; (P)2004 Recorded Books, LLC
"An important work." (Booklist)
"New York history buffs will be captivated by Shorto's descriptions of Manhattan in its primordial state, of bays full of salmon and oysters, and blue plums and fields of wild strawberries in what is now Midtown." (The New York Times Book Review)
"Shorto reconstructs, in fascinating detail, the little-told story behind the Dutch settlement and its capital, Manhattan....It's hard to imagine any narrator's voice remaining fresh and compelling through 15 hours of sweeping historical narrative, but Ganser comes close." (Publishers Weekly)
I am a history buff and I loved this book and the history of New York City that it clarified. It was truly fascinating. I wish I had known this stuff while I was growing up in Manhattan. Still it was enlightening to learn about the early Dutch settlement and I would highly recommend this book to any fellow history buff. The author tells the story of NYC's early beginnings in such a way that you are sucked into it before you know it. Definitely worth a second listen.
It is true, history is written by the winners. I learned hardly anything about the Dutch Settlement of New Amsterdam in high school. (I attended private school, the vast majority of the students were Calvinist Dutch decendents.) I don't remember hearing anything about that Dutch settlement of New Amsterdam covered nearly 5 of the oringal 13 colonies. It is also interesting that the English had to hire Dutch speakers to trade with the Native Americans because that was the only other language with which the Natives were familiar. I thank the author for bringing this research to light.
This book by Russel Shorto holds a wealth of information related to the pre-English colonies in North American. At many times during this audiobook, I was fascinated by the information about the people of the New Amsterdam colony, and by the interesting relations to Dutch politics during the 17th Century. For this, the book is worth the listen.
However, what for me was very, very annoying was the continual repitition of multiple re-phrasing of statements like this: "And now we can see why New Amsterdam, and its multi-cultural state and ideals, truly formed the identity of what we now call the United States of America, and specifically the melting pot known as New York," etc etc. I believe that it is a shortcoming of the author to constantly remind his readers of the importance of the content of the book without allowing the content to stand on its own. If you can overlook the fact that at the end of nearly every chapter you are reminded of the importance of the New Amsterdam colony to the founding of the values of New York city, and therfore American itself, then you probably will enjoy this book very much.
Keep in mind that the book is dramatized, historical non-fiction and that the author has filled in the gaps between actual historical documents to present to the reader a "compelling tale," based of a historical anthropological research done by other individuals (duly credited in the book).
primarily a publication of primary source historical documents, the first 1/3 or so of the book seemed a bit repetitious and dry. i actually dropped it for a while and listened to some trashy and exciting fiction.
however, as an avid history buff who grew up in NY, i gave it a second try, and i'm very glad i did~ the flow of information, while still based on a relatively unknown cache of primary historical documents, eventually took on more of the flow of a story, and the characters fascinating players in a grand historical drama. i had no idea that the Dutch were the radical progressives of their day, and it was they that were the Europeans who brought the ideas of self-determined democratic government and pluralistic diverse society to our shores! i know the NY Native tribes, some of them, also had this type of government in their own style, and most of the Dutch honored their treaties w/Native Nations. And more! as i said, worth the time~
This was an excellent book that was thoroughly researched, which I applaud. The history was fascinating, rich in new content and truly helped the reader understand the roots of American culture. It made me appreciate the origin of the "melting pot" of cultures and acceptance that thrive in NYC today and make our country so unique. It is true the "winners write the history books", so I am thankful for the clarification. I recommend this book to anyone from NY, New England, with a Dutch heritage and/or anyone who appreciates understanding the social roots of this great country.
Who knew the Knicks' and Mets' blue and orange colors originated with the flag of the Seven United Provinces of the Netherlands? A very well-reached and entertaining telling of the history of the Dutch settlement at New Amsterdam. Bottom line, the Dutch were a lot more fun than the Puritans, and have a lot more in common with modern Americans too.
an engrossing look at an overlooked chapter of American history -- as long as the listener can overlook the author's too-frequent, preachy asides on what we owe our Dutch forebears, and the narrator's nasal voice and occasionally strident tones.
The characters of Adriaen Von Der Donck and Peter Stuyvesant particularly stand out. Rather than being somewhat cardboard, they come through as 3-dimensional human beings. Maybe someday, Von Der Donck's book on America, of which we were fed a few tantalizing tidbits, will be given a good, modern translation and published for our children to read and marvel at.
History buff stuff. I can never get enough of ood or interesting trivia, especially historically curious or contradictory. this book tells a sotry of global dimensions, one and two people at a time. I liked it.
The book really gives you insight into the Dutch development of NYC during the 17th century. Very interesting character development and reads quickly.
This book takes what could be a fascinating story and makes it quite tedious. Jumping back and forth in time confuses a narrative that is engaging enough to be taken on chronologically and a highly repetitive prose style eventually becomes quite grating - how many times do we need to be reminded of the trading rituals of the Mohawks and the Mohicans? Most distracting though is the narration. In no other audiobook have I been able to notice the loud breathing of the reader so overtly. I don't know whether that inhalation is edited out in other recordings, but I've never come across the narrator's breathing actually distracting me from the recitation of the story until now. Also, the narrator sounds like this is the first time he is reading the book: sometimes his intonation is off and the stress falls on the wrong syllable, his pronunciation of Dutch words is not consistent throughout the book and his transitions from English sentences to include a Dutch term is clunky, like he's guessing how the word should sound, in the strangest pseudo-nonspecific central European accent. Not a terrible book by any means, but the narration detracts considerably from the enjoyment of it.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.