Those Who Hold Bastogne

The True Story of the Soldiers and Civilians Who Fought in the Biggest Battle of the Bulge

By: Peter Schrijvers

Narrated by: John Lee

Length: 11 hrs and 11 mins

Publisher's summary

Hitler's last gamble, the Battle of the Bulge, was intended to push the Allied invaders of Normandy all the way back to the beaches. The plan nearly succeeded, and almost certainly would have, were it not for one small Belgian town and its tenacious American defenders who held back a tenfold larger German force while awaiting the arrival of General George Patton's mighty Third Army.

In this dramatic account of the 1944-45 winter of war in Bastogne, historian Peter Schrijvers offers the first full story of the German assault on the strategically located town. From the December stampede of American and Panzer divisions racing to reach Bastogne first, through the bloody eight-day siege from land and air, and through three more weeks of unrelenting fighting even after the siege was broken, events at Bastogne hastened the long-awaited end of WWII.

Schrijvers draws on diaries, memoirs, and other fresh sources to illuminate the experiences not only of Bastogne's 3,000 citizens and their American defenders, but also of German soldiers and commanders desperate for victory.

©2014 Peter Schrijvers (P)2015 Tantor

Critic reviews

"Using fresh sources and deft writing, Peter Schrijvers develops a panoramic and compelling boots-on-the-ground illumination of one of the Bulge's most epic battles." (Patrick K. O'Donnell, author of Dog Company)

How individuals experienced this key battle.

Narration: Especially clear.

Story: lives up to its promise to describe poignantly individual soldiers' experiences. Recommended.

Excellent!

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

By far the most complete story of Bastogne I've ever heard. Really enjoyed it!

Who was your favorite character and why?

All of the 101st.

Have you listened to any of John Lee’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

Nope

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Yes

Any additional comments?

None

Never Again Is My Take Away

This is the brutally honest and detailed narrative of just one month of WWII’s human carnage on the Western Front. A critically pivotal battle that hung in the balance as the ‘Fascist Reich’ made its last attempt to push the Allies back to Normandy with innocent civilians caught in the cross fire.

At times I could not bare to learn of the extensively traumatic mass causalities that had to suffer horrendous wounds, executions, starvation, disease and harsh weather exposure from, for example, Ill equipped uniforms to protect them from the constant freezing winter cold of which there was no escape.

Notably our troops were seriously out matched to the Nazis/Panzer armaments et al. So it was simply a battle of attrition for the Allies to eventually liberate Bastogne at a terrible cost.

The author brings us directly into the hellish embattled “all or nothing” fighting juxtaposed to the chronological events happening in and around Bastogne, nearly giving at times minute by minute accounts. All from the high command strategies down to the infantry having to execute them.

This thoroughly detailed account is humbling and honors their bravery and deaths-the ultimate sacrifice.

My parents lost two cousins in this battle (buried there) and one who survived, serving in the 101st/506th Easy Company Airborne.

And… it was during the Christmas season-peace on earth, goodwill toward man (humanity)?

History is in the details

If you are interested in the fog and chaos of war this book is a good one. It also includes a good look at the sufferings and slaughter of the innocent bystanders

Great Sory, Poor Narrator Choice

This has wounderful, first hand stories, which are a great insite into the critical point of the Battle of the Bulge. the narrator's English/Scottish accent is out of place while narrating American dialect. when the Narrator does General Patton' s quotes, he sounds like a bad rendition of Carry Grant trying to imitate Humphrey Bogart.

More if the truth

Many think that the battle of the bulge was just a 7 to 10 day event
My uncle was with Patton 3 rd Army for this fight and it took over 6 long weeks after the fight for Bastoin was over to push back the Germans lines

It was a turning point at the cost of many a young man

A Cold Hard View of War

Well written. Informative and a good listen. Narration is superb! I have repeatedly listened to this audio book as it holds a Cold Hard View of War.

First Read Very Good, Lacking a Crucial Point, So?

Overall I think this was a very good book. It is certainly not the book for those who do not like history or those who know nothing about WWII simply because of the massive amount of information it covers. However, if you are a person who enjoys either you'll likely enjoy this book, yet my caveat below may sway your opinion.

The narration was outstanding. I had only listened to John Lee on one previous book, Dam Busters, in which he did an excellent job, but he was better in this book. Lee was a perfect choice, but be warned; he speaks so swiftly at the beginning of the book that I thought I had accidentally hit the 1.75x speed on my iPod. That said, his diction and pronunciations are flawless and he is easily understood. The speed, in my mind, actually conveyed the sense of urgency that the American units must have felt at the onset of the German attack. Lee also has an amazing ability to switch between accents, which will likely bother some listeners, but I found it interesting to break up the drone of the information being explained. His cadence slows further on, but he doesn't abandon the sense of urgency that he starts with.

Now comes the one caveat. At about the halfway point of the book I began thinking back and trying to recall if Schirjvers had mentioned the mass murder of 84 American prisoners in the hamlet of Baugnez on 17 December 1944 at the hands of the Germans; known as the Malmedy massacre. The book does jump around and is not chronological so perhaps I missed it, but from the time I thought about it on I listened with intent to see if the horrific event was mentioned and it never was. This shocked me and, frankly, caused a certain amount of disappointment if not disdain for the author. Yes, the title is "Those Who Hold Bastogne", but Schrijvers mentioned numerous other engagements or actions outside of Bastogne yet he failed to make even a passing mention of one of the most horrific and well documented war crimes of WWII, why? He made mention of several other murders of civilians committed by the Germans and he actually made mention of a few "alleged" killings of German prisoners by American soldiers, none that I've ever heard as properly documented though. While it is very likely that during the fog of battle both sides committed acts that would or could be perceived as a murder or an extrajudicial killing those instances are far different from a planned and organized intention to march 84 unarmed prisoners of war into a field and machine gun them to death.

In all fairness to the author I do plan on listening to this book again just to determine if I missed this point of history during the first half of the book? While that is possible, it is not very probable because I can gloss over some books while listening, but key points typically strike me. If Malmedy wasn't mentioned little could justify the reason other than an author who is a very poor historian and left it out by oversight, which calls into questions all his research, or an author suffering from some twisted sense of political correctness. Either way I can state with absolute certainty that I will never again purchase another book by Peter Shrijvers if he failed to mention Malmedy. And no; I would not accept the excuse that it was too far out of place for the narrative about the battle for Bastogne itself, that would be a lame excuse.

Great historical information.

This book gave a very accurate account of the battle and the men who fought in it. It wasn't overly dramaticized and tried to present the information and a factual maner.

Loved it

Great book but probably only if you have read a lot about the bulge. Covers a lot of territory.