The Abstainer

A Novel

By: Ian McGuire

Narrated by: John Keating

Length: 10 hrs

Publisher's summary

“This is Dickens in the present tense, Dickens for the 21st century.” (Roddy Doyle, The New York Times Book Review)

An Irishman in 19th-century England is forced to take sides when his nephew joins the bloody underground movement for independence in this propulsive novel from the acclaimed author of The North Water.

Named One of the Ten Best Books of the Year by Chicago Tribune and One of the Best Books of the Year by The New York Times • The New York Public Library • New Statesman • Publishers Weekly

Manchester, England, 1867. The rebels will be hanged at dawn, and their brotherhood is already plotting its revenge. Stephen Doyle, an Irish American veteran of the Civil War, arrives in Manchester from New York with a thirst for blood. He has joined the Fenians, a secret society intent on ending British rule in Ireland by any means necessary.

Head Constable James O’Connor has fled grief and drink in Dublin for a sober start in Manchester. His job is to discover and thwart the Fenians’ plans, whatever they might be. When a long-lost nephew arrives on O’Connor’s doorstep looking for work, he cannot foresee the way his fragile new life will be imperiled - and how his and Doyle’s fates will become fatally intertwined.

In this propulsive tale of the underground war for Irish independence, the author of The North Water once again transports listeners to a time when blood begot blood. Moving from the dirt and uproar of industrial Manchester to the quiet hills of rural Pennsylvania, The Abstainer is a searing novel in which two men, haunted by their pasts and driven forward by the need for justice and retribution, must fight for life and legacy.

©2020 Ian McGuire (P)2020 Random House Audio

Critic reviews

“Compelling ... The physical world that [McGuire] imagines assails the reader’s senses: the stink of a tannery, the clangour of factory bells and the way O’Connor’s grief drives him to a ruthlessness beyond his nature.” (The Economist)

“O’Connor’s showdown with Stephen Doyle delivers a gut-wrenching finale that will leave readers hoping desperately that McGuire (The North Water, 2016) has an O’Connor prequel in the works. O’Connor’s palpable alienation and the subtly drawn comparisons between the Irish insurgency and America’s then-recent civil war create layers of depth in this exceptional period thriller.” (Booklist, starred review)

“[A] taut, atmospheric tale ... McGuire demonstrates a mastery of classic realism. [This] crackling work is one to savor.” (Publishers Weekly, starred review)

Ruthless

Well written depressing story read by narrator employing whispering and modulation, then full voice for affect. If you turn up the volume for very quiet bits, it’s followed by loud, punishing noise. It’s ceaseless.

Excellently written, wonderful descriptions, depressing

The book is incredibly well written but is Depressingly realistic . The title is significant. I listened to it and the narrator was excellent. The writing is Dickensian as per the New York Times reviews. And the story is like the history of Ireland, frustratingAnd feels hopeless.

Not very good.

I loved North Water so I was really looking forward to this one.

It is OK. But not even close to as well written and cleverly plotted as North Water. The narration in Irish is good. But when the narrator switches to some weird Long Island/Brooklyn accent for one of the main characters it is kind of cringy.

The bar was set high by North Water. This one is not ven close. Some authors only have one great book in them.

Great story, Disappointing end

Without giving it away, the ending is less than satisfactory, appearing to be whipped together to meet some unbeknownst writer / publishing deadline or requirement where an inconsequential character is given the final word. It makes me wonder if the author ended up despising the protagonist he created. After feeling excited throughout, I ended up exhausted and disappointed. It’s a great story, but be prepared to be left wanting in the end.

Great start - strange finish

It’s pretty good but to focused and narrow to be really helpful. The end is just hopeless. Kinda like: ‘I need to finish this somehow’. A bit disappointing. The narration is excellent though.

Challenging.

I read the north water and loved it. I think this is a great piece of writing as well, but it’s not easy. I decided to ignore the negative reviews I read and I’m glad I did. The historical context, the story, the language all make it worthwhile. That said, I felt a little disappointed with the last chapter. It’s just one way the story could end. The rest of the ride was exceptional enough that I took it in stride, These books remind me of Cormac McCarthy’s writing and I think they’re classic. Looking forward to the next one. But yeah if you’re looking for easy reading or uplifting conventional fiction - the kind of stuff that there’s way too much of on offer in my opinion- you’ll probably be disappointed. The material is believable - and based on historical events - and I think it’s worth considering what life would be like for characters such as these. Imagining such a world requires empathy and offers a bit of perspective on my life of relative comfort, which is valuable in itself.

“Pinky Blinders” meets “The Abstainer”

Story could have been a third shorter and more focused on main character’s search for love. Story does link closely to “Pinky Blinders” (Netflix Series)except for the time difference.
Narration is very good.

STOP NOW! TOO MANY SPOILERS!!

This is a terrific story. I was absorbed. It paints a very bleak and sensory picture, and if you enjoyed North Water, you will love this. Some of the other reviews are too revealing with regards to the ending. Don't blow it by reading more reviews ... just go by the stars if you want to gauge other readers' opinions. I will leave it at that. enjoy!

Engrossing heartbreaking story

I enjoyed the book a lot and was totally engrossed. I would give 4.5 stars, though, because I found the end chapter strange and unsatisfying (as some other reviewers wrote). I don’t think it is a spoiler to say so. Listen to the book. You will be moved and the drama is excellent. I also would take a bit of a star away from the reader, who tended to lower his voice sometimes for effect, but then I couldn’t hear everything he said, had to back up, listen again at higher volume, then lower the volume again. This was disrupting. Considering how much I enjoyed the book (if “enjoy” is the right word for a book depicting so much misery and strife), those are minor matters.

On par with Northwater

If you liked the North Water you’ll like this. If you don’t enjoy this book you’re likely a boring and/uninteresting person.