Seeking the answers to this terrible dilemma, Sally realizes with growing horror that there is a guiding hand behind all this deceit; someone who hates her so passionately that he has devoted years to bringing about her ruin. She has no choice but to escape with her child into the crime-ridden slums of London's East End. Suddenly it isn't only Sally's reputation that is in danger.
Don't miss any of the Sally Lockhart mysteries.
©1991 Philip Pullman; (P)2005 Random House, Inc. Listening Library, an imprint of the Random House Audio Publishing Group
"The writing style is lively and direct, and there's lots of action. While Sally's story is for mature readers, it is never sordid or sensational. This is a suspense novel with a conscience, and a most enjoyable one." (School Library Journal)
"A suspenseful, textured mystery. Especially fine is his use of details, 19th-century London comes alive here. Remarkable, too, is the way Pullman interweaves subplots....Those who have enjoyed Sally's adventures before, as well as those new to the series, will find this a fascinating read, pulsing with life." (Booklist)
This very well read (Anton Lesser) edition of the third of Philip Pullman's Sally Lockhart trilogy is, like the other works in the series, rather darker than one quite expects, and not everyone or everything is better in the end. In other words, far more like real life than most. The story is compelling, the characters (mostly new in this book) are interesting and unexpected. The book can certainly be read standalone - there's really no requirement to read the earlier volumes - but some of the context is, obviously, lost.
This suspensefull and compelling novel is set in 19th century London, with a back drop of the pogroms in Eastern Europe and the non-entity of women. Sally is an independent financial advisor, with a child and no husband, who is thrust from her relatively privileged position into the East End. Her determination to survive, to protect her child and her reputation, and to overcome her enemy are mixed with the learning process of a privileged Londoner suddenly finding herself very much a part of the open sewer that was the East End. Where she makes new friends and unexpected allies in her fight.
Compelling listening, I found myself finding excuses to go on long drives so I could listen to this book. Highly recommended.
While I agree that this may not be Philip Pullman's best book, it was very entertaining - not one dull moment, non-stop action and fascinating characters. And, as with every audio book I've listened to that's narrated by Anton Lesser, I was dazzled by his skill. He really creates people out of thin air. He conjures up a two-year old girl as beautifully as an elderly man, and he really seems to become the people. When Lesser narrates he even distracts from minor plot holes. It's a joy to listen to the range of accents he masters.
Positive things first: Anton Lesser is a wonderful narrator, he is one of my absolute favorites on Audible and would be reason alone to get this book.
I am not very impressed with plot though, somehow it has less thrill, less color and mood then first and second books, it is very predictable and it gets to the point of being really annoying to hear about a "Mystery" which is really none for hours and hours. Secondly, it is really heavy on socialism. This is a bit personal but I grew up in country with "advanced socialism" and I know how it looks and feels, how the system punishes any kind of initiative and forces everyone to be "equal" if they like it or not. While I understand how it arose among injustice of 19th century, it still represents a red flag to me because I know what it leads to.
The first two books in the trilogy were enjoyable. This is a very poor third. Much of the appeal of the earlier books lies in the character of Sally, who is independent, resourceful, and clever. In this book, however, Sally is faced with a grave personal crisis and instead of trying to help herself, leaves matters in the hands of a condescending do-nothing when it is glaringly obvious to both the reader and Sally that his course of action is going to plunge Sally further into disaster. After her spineless inaction has placed Sally in the necessary jeopardy, Sally's character is permitted to be less inert. Unfortunately, this is when the socialist propaganda takes over. At the culmination of the book, Sally makes an impassioned speech proclaiming that the villain is not evil -- it is the owners of the means of production, and the lawyers and doctors and bishops, who are Truly Evil. Sally's oration comes not long after another character has declaimed on the unfairness of making negative judgments about groups of people rather than considering them as individuals. Pullman either fails to note the inconsistency of the positions his characters advocate, or intends to send the message that persons lower on the socioeconomic scale must be treated fairly as individuals, but that persons with property or authority may be demonized en masse. The story does not compensate for the sermonizing. As noted by other reviewers, any half-awake reader will have figured out who the villain is many frustrating chapters before Sally works it out.
Overall this trilogy is interesting, but definitely not Phillip Pullman's best work. This final book in the trilogy is extremely predictable - as if we didn't know who Sally Lockhart's biggest enemy was after reading the first two books in the series. I'm not a practiced mystery reader, but there were no surprises, not even the final methods of escape and redemption. In addition, the entire first half of the book is a seemingly endless tale of unfairness and suffering, which gets old very fast. The narration is fantastic, though, which is why I gave it 3 stars. I guess I would find it hard not to buy the final book of a trilogy, but be forewarned that it's pretty disappointing.
I love to read with my ears while doing chores, running or driving.
Sometimes dark and stressful but worth listening to all three books. Great stories and perfect narrator. Can't think of a better match.
The fantastic reader, Anton Lesser.
No favorites, all the young heroes have wonderful personal charms.
He adds emotion and realism to what is sometimes a difficult or not-so-great passage.
I loved how seriously the young hooligans took their job of rescuing and taking care of Sally's young daughter. It was so touching how each one made her feel safe.
Yes. I NEED BOOK FOUR IN AUDIO! AS SOON AS POSSIBLE, PLEASE! :)
I love books.
I loved this whole series. The narration is amazing. Each story flows wonderfully into the next, even though some years pass between each of the three stories in the series. This story is more complex, and a little harder to follow in parts than the previous two. However, it is well written and exciting. I didn't want it to end.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.