©1981 Cynthia Voigt; (P)1992 Recorded Books,LLC
Home school family with six children ages 7-21. We love listening to audible books together. We like Twaddle-free books.
Overall I enjoyed this story. I have always enjoyed survival adventure stories. This is the story of 4 siblings who are deserted by their father years ago and then their mother leaves them in a shopping mall and doesn't return. THey were on their way to visit an unmet aunt. THe children have very little money and only their wits and legs to travel the couple hundred miles to their aunt. They visit their aunt and then when that doesn't work out they split to go meet their 'crazy' Grandmother whom they have also never met. THey are hard working children and use their wits and survival instincts to make it through.
Is this a realistic story? No. I was also annoyed at the author's attempts to make it a 'deeper' book by trying to address the topic of death. Nobody dies in the story! It is just painted on like a facade. There is no moral basis for their discussions, just random thoughts. Still trying to figure out why she went there at all. It accomplished nothing. My other annoyance with the story was the obligatory flesh reference... giggling over the jiggling of ladies breasts. Really? Totally pointless. My third annoyance was her attempt to discriminate about when stealing and lying was ok and when it wasn't. Again, there was no reference point for these decisions, just their own feelings. They didn't really wrestle with it, just kinda did what was easiest for them. I guess in our world, feelings and ease trump everything.
I like Barbara Caruso as a reader. She was great in the Anne of Green Gables books. There were some technical glitches in the middle of the book where there was an echo.
Bottom line was that I liked the adventure part of the story, it is well written, I disliked the annoyances. It is not a book that I will be giving to the kids to listen to and I very well might return it.
This book is earmarked for children, however, it is in no way a juvenile read. The children who are the characters in this novel experience situations that an adult would confront, given the same set of circumstances, in their pursuit to find a home for themselves and keep their family together. There is the refreshing absence of dirty language and obscene material. I recommend the read for ages 10 and above.
I have always enjoyed this story. It was a wonderful read aloud when our children were young teens. Such a wonderful story of family pulling together when the chips are down. And making the most of the family you have. For how bad things get it has a triumphant finish.
I'm in the process of redoing all my reviews.
In 1981, Cynthia Voigt wrote this, the first award winning book of what was to become a six book series about the four abandoned Tillerman children, Thirty-five years later, it is as eminently readable as it was then. Voigt minces no words as she demonstrates the plight of children, parentless or otherwise, in society, a universal problem even today. Abandoned by their parents, the four children, led by their thirteen-year-old sister, make the impossibly long trip, on foot from Massachusetts to their great-aunt's house in Connecticut and then from Connecticut to their grandmother's home on the eastern shore of Maryland. They could not have made that trip in today's world, but the trials they face and overcome are heartbreaking. I marveled again at the skill and craftsmanship of Voigt's writing, as fresh today as when I first read it years ago. With its compelling plot and tightly written narrative, Homecoming deserved the prestigious Newbery Medal it garnered.
I was a bit disappointed with the narrator but that is probably because I'm used to the extremely talented narrations of the likes of Simon Prebble, Barbara Rosenblatt, Stephen Briggs, and George Guidell. Still, my disappointment did not detract from Caruso's ability to keep me engaged and get the story told. I'm sure my opinion on this is not shared by others and should not discourage listeners from enjoying this most excellent book.
Jr, High Teacher
one of my favorites
When the kids were walking, walking, walking.
When Sammy stole the food.
The reader is one of my favorites.
Yes. I read the print version in middle school, but loved the audio edition for the narration.
I don't know.
Definitely Gram's personality.
The last 3 hours were. Before that, it wasn't so suspenseful. But I couldn't wait to find out what was going to happen to Mr. Rudyard, the circus, and once they got to Crisfield.
"One of my favourite books"
I really enjoyed listening to this. The narration was slow and steady so you could enjoy it fully.
Although written for children, the series can be enjoyed by all ages. Dicey and her little family will captivate you so you will hope that their long journey will take them Home.
Story just plodded on, couldn't engage with the characters, dull storyline, eventually gave up listening
It was read quiet well.
"Utterly boring, slow and repetitive"
Somebody who has time to waste
Definitely by this author
Did not finish it as got to the point when I had had enough and would not even recommend it.
Not worth commenting on.
This book should have been radically culled. If we heard about the children's food choices (mostly the same) and the dreary monotonous listing of every tiny detail once, the same tune was played over and over. Just dreadful. I got to the end of the first half and lost the will to carry on.. Believe me I tried to be fair and hoped it would get better...so have no idea how it ends.
Report Inappropriate Content