In the most famous scandal of sports history, eight Chicago White Sox players - including Shoeless Joe Jackson - agreed to throw the 1919 World Series to the Cincinnati Reds in exchange for the promise of $20,000 each from gamblers reportedly working for New York mobster Arnold Rothstein. Heavily favored, Chicago lost the series five games to three. Although rumors of a fix flew while the series was being played, they were largely disregarded by players and the public at large. It wasn't until a year later that a general investigation into baseball gambling reopened the case, and a nationwide scandal emerged.
In this book, Charles Fountain offers a full and engaging history of one of baseball's true moments of crisis and hand-wringing and shows how the scandal changed the way American baseball was both managed and perceived. After an extensive investigation and a trial that became a national morality play, the jury returned not-guilty verdicts for all of the White Sox players in August of 1921. The following day, Judge Kennesaw Mountain Landis, baseball's new commissioner, "regardless of the verdicts of juries", banned the eight players for life. And thus the Black Sox entered into American mythology.
Guilty or innocent? Guilty and innocent? The country wasn't sure in 1921, and as Fountain shows, we still aren't sure today. But we are continually pulled to the story, because so much of modern sport, and our attitude toward it, springs from the scandal. Fountain traces the Black Sox story from its roots in the gambling culture that pervaded the game in the years surrounding World War I through the confusing events of the 1919 World Series itself to the noisy aftermath and trial and illuminates the moment as baseball's tipping point. Despite the clumsy unfolding of the scandal and trial and the callous treatment of the players involved, the Black Sox saga was a cleansing moment for the sport. It launched the age of the baseball commissioner, as baseball owners hired Landis and surrendered to him the control of their game. Fountain shows how sweeping changes in 1920s triggered by the scandal moved baseball away from its association with gamblers and fixers and details how Americans' attitudes toward the pastime shifted as they entered into "The Golden Age of Sport".
Situating the Black Sox events in the context of later scandals, including those involving Reds manager and player Pete Rose and the ongoing use of steroids in the game up through the present, Fountain illuminates America's near century-long fascination with the story and its continuing relevance today.
©2016 Charles Fountain (P)2016 Audible, Inc.
I am a huge baseball fan and a fan of the history of baseball. I assumed this book would be right down my alley.
However, right from the beginning it was hugely disappointing. First, there is something irritating about the narrator. Second, there is way too much backstory having to do with gambling and fixing of games way, way before the 1919 season. I get it, you don't need to spend hours on it. Way too much minutia and names galore that make it confusing and boring. Third, even the story of the White (Black) Sox is so overly detailed and minutia packed that it dragged. I was actually happy when it was done! Not worth the 10+ hours!
a lot of set up and establishing facts are presented at the outset, but once the book is done telling the stories of key figures in the black sox scandal, not much is done to make the connections back to the set up.
how much did the van Johnson/ Charles comiskey feud play into the scandal? still TBD.
also, I think the subtitle was slightly deceptive, as the author could've presented more of a case about the effect the "strong commissioner" has had on the game beyond Shoeless Joe and Pete Rose.
nonetheless, it was a very well written, well presented story about establishing a proper record of the scandal and parsing fact from what was very likely fiction.
I loved every minute of this book and highly recommend it. As a baseball history buff, I found it incredibly well researched and revealing of new dimensions of a story many people know but only on the surface. The narrators voice was smooth and easy to follow.
Thank you, Charles Fountain, for my new favorite sports novel.
Report Inappropriate Content