©2005 David Bodanis; (P)2005 Books on Tape, Inc.
"This entertaining look at how electricity works and affects our daily lives is highlighted by Bodanis' charming narrative voice and by clever, fresh analogies that make difficult science accessible." (Publishers Weekly)
This was arguably one of the most enjoyable books I've listened to in a long while. While my own background is Electrical Engineering, there were concepts and ideas presented in such a simplified manner that this book should be required reading for all students. The history of how our version of electricty came to be was interesting not so much for how the various discoveries came about but the from the human side. There were many interesting stories that I had not heard before or fully understood the personalities involved. The narration is very well done which adds to the enjoyment.
An example is the authors discription of how RADAR really works, not how people thinks it works and how something devised to protect England was taken from the creator and used to firebomb a German city to the absolute distress of the creator. You get the full impact from the joy of discovery to the total dispair as women and children were incinerated.
You feel the joy of Alexendar Graham Bell working to help the deaf while bringing us the Telephone which revolutionized the world.
And while the all widgets are cool, the author goes into how electricty makes us humans work. I learned more from this book than I did in two semesters on biology. Maybe I paid more attention this time but I dont think so, I think it was the excellent presentation of what could be very complex material.
All in all, this is must-listen to audiobook.
Given the number of medium to bad reviews here, I thought I'd throw in my "plug." Since I never use audiobooks for scholarly reference, I am not as concerned about accuracy as I might be reviewing a printed text. While the points on accuracy or oversimplification made by some of the reviewers here are well taken, they didn't affect my pleasure in the work, which I thought an excellent audiobook. The writing is quite good and intelligent, at a good pace for audio, so even the author's digressive flights of fancy on the social effects of the transistor, for example, are enjoyable, imaginative riffs. The history of electricity presented here is periodic and a bit quirky, not at all comprehensive. Each episode centers on one or two historical figures and their advancement of electrical knowledge, from Volta to Turing, from telegraph and radar, up to microchips and synapses. The stories are well-told and I actually appreciate the "oversimplified," Dickensian manner in which the author paints his characters in moral hues as villains (Morse, Shockley, etc.) or heroes (Faraday, Turing, etc.) I knew nothing about the topic, so learned much, listened to most chapters twice, and was inspired (or perhaps embarrassed) into learning a bit more about electricity, which is, after all, the deity underlying our modern social structure. Overall, very good audiobook. The reader is good--pleasantly, gruffly avuncular. If you don't know much about electricity I believe you'll like it and learn.
No mention of Tesla with regards to radio or the AC motor should give you an idea of the major omissions this audiobook has.
I knew little about electricity other than Thomas Edison worked with it before encountering this book. It is well written, informative, and makes the technology available to the listener. Placed in historical context, the heroes and frauds alike are introduced with enthusiasm and grace.
For a delightful change of pace, you might just enjoy Bodanis' Electric Universe. It is well written and well read which alone would put it on my own list.
A lover of thrillers and enthralling stories told by dramatic and well read narrators.
The books starts well, and gives us something to work with, but the narrator's voice is too gravely and distracting. He makes the book boring, and makes me feel like I'm listening to a science professor who should have retired 5 years before.
The author can write. The telling is quite fast paced and random topics are woven together by the universal thread of electricity. On writing and telling, the book is five star. Alas, the author is neither a scientist nor understands how to check historical facts.
One minor example is when he talks about Lord Kelvin and the age of the earth, he takes a quote out of context, “assuming no other source of heat”, and weaves a fantasy about how Lord Kelvin anticipated radioactivity. This story is well known, Lord Kelvin, one of the great thinkers of all time, refused publicly to add radioactivity into his calculations even when his private letters showed he began to doubt his previous arguments.
I can forgive a great old man for not wanting to admit to a failing, but I cannot forgive an author who reads some scientific fact or historical bit and weaves a tale that does not reflect the known historical interpretation.
Another example is when he talks about Turing but completely ignores Dr. John W. Mauchly and J. P. Eckert, Jr who built the first completly electronic computer (ENIAC). Turing’s lasting contributions were theoretical not practical, he actually failed in his attempt to develop a programable computer. But no reader would know Mauchly and Eckert ever existed fromt his book nor that Turing did not invent software!
Time and time again the author regurgitates science with the wrong slant: the words are all correct but the overall impression is slewed.
So the book is a fun read, use the book as a jumping off point to learn more, just don’t use the book as a reference on how electricity, or scientists, work.
I really enjoyed this book. However, I thought it spent way too much time on the World War II story (basically development of Radar). I remain unclear on when and how the ability to generate electricity mechanically (as opposed to chemically) developed, and finally, there was a lot about electricity and telegraphs/telephones, but not much about how eletricity as a means to drive motors developed in comparison.
This well researched book added much human interest and background to many of the scientific and technological developments behind electricity and electronics. The author's overzealous attempts to simplify generated too many totally inappropriate analogies and lead me to suspect that neither the author nor the editor ever took even high school physics. Nonetheless, I learned much from the book and even more from following up on interesting leads mentioned in the book or omitted from the book (e.g. De Forest's invention of the vacuum tube).
Another geek book but I loved it. Gives a good overview of the history of electricity and really kept my interest. A lot of fun if you like this sort of thing.
The first part of the book was very engaging. The science and development of electricity was presented within a historical context, with a focus on individuals and their struggles to understand their universe (if you are a LOST fan, you will love the background on Michael Faraday and his contemporaries). Fascinating stuff about the laying of the first transatlantic telegraph cable, the war effort, etc. However, two-thirds of the way into the book, it entered the modern era, and it became a science lecture about electrons, etc. Probably interesting if you really like the nuts and bolts of science; pretty darn boring for an English major. This is the first audio book I simply couldn't finish.
Report Inappropriate Content