Winner of the 1967 Hugo award, this novel marked Heinlein's partial return to his best form. He draws many historical parallels with the War of Independence, and clearly shows his own libertarian political views.
©1965 Robert A. Heinlein; (P)1999 Blackstone Audio Inc.
"Adrenalizing, mind-stretching, conviction-testing...unmatched by any contemporary!" (Theodore Sturgeon)
Very little advanced science or technology. Ridiculously improbable story line. Story applauds a war where the people on luna (aka, the moon) kill more than fifty thousand people on earth. The story also seems to commend aspects of the old Soviet Union, arguably the worst run state in recorded history. This is an utterly bizarre book. Hard to believe this is from the Heinlein who wrote the outstanding Starship Troopers.
Improbable story line and irritating Russian accent of main character
All of them.
You never have to wait for anything if you bring a good book.
Not in a million years.
Great story about David slaying Goliath with the help of the central computer.
Uninspired, poorly directed.
Yes, but it was one of my favorite books as a teenager.
Heinlein makes an interesting plot around the idea that the moon is turned into a penal colony and then declares independence. Little of his speculative science (growing wheat on the moon? Electromagnetic slingshots for sending things to earth?) has worked out but he makes some good guesses about the future of computing considering this was written in the late 60's.
Oh, by the way, the narrator fakes a russian accent, which is off putting but you do get used to it.
The more interesting sub plot is about a computer that becomes self aware. This was the fun part that drew me in for the first third of the book. The rest of the story focuses heavily on the political circumstances they had to go through to be free and I found it trying to slog through, maybe because I was hoping for some emotional development that never materialized. The ending was good. Heinlein is a great concept guy and plotter so if that's your thing by all means get this audiobook
This listen is "middle of the pack" for me. The performance was amazing, but I found the political maneuvering a bit tedious by the end of the book
I enjoyed the early interaction between Mannie, the main character, and the self aware computer. I remember as an adolescent reader being turned off when Mike, the computer, also had feminine characteristics. (girls, ugh!). As an adult, those interactions become very amusing.
The books ending was a bit unexpected for me. I don't want to spoil it for anyone, but it left me in a reflective mood.
The performance was amazing. The narrator is able to use a variety of accents, doing feminine characters, and a computer. I really enjoyed the book.
Any fool can know something the point is to understand!
While I enjoyed the story I was stunned by the voice work on this book. Story was interesting mid-60s fair with the idea that the moon was only years away from full on colonization. Technology will require a bit of overlooking but the Botany Bay approach to the story keep me interested through out.
This is one of my favorite Heinlein stories. The characters and action are amazing and the narration is perfect for this story. If you have never read any Robert Heinlein books, this one is a can't miss. I would recommend anything he has written without question. We don't have authors like him any longer.
The Russian accent tripped me up until I learned to appreciate it(4 stars). The accent did add to the background of the story line and the narrator. The struggle for freedom and observations of different types of governments caused me to strech.
I am a big fan of Robert Heinlein. He began writing in during the hayday of pulp sci-fi magazines. I began reading his stories and books during the 1950's and I think "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress" is my 2nd favorite of his many books, only surpassed by "Methusalah's Children". I have read this book at least six times, but really enjoyed hearing it read to me. While the wonderful story didn't change, it had an entirely different flavor. I am somewhat of a history buff. This story is the history of a revolution, between the desendents of the "Botany Bay" immigrants on Earth's moon and the "Lunar Authority". The self-righteous "Lunar Authority is as oppresive as an Imperial Colonialist in Earth's History and the residents on the moon resent it. But how do you revolt against an authority that is located on a different planetary body and that authority controls all transportation to and fro. Doesn't sound doable. The problem is solved by a computer mechanic, born and raised on the moon, that works as a consultant to the authority, along with a professor who had been involuntarily transported due to subversive activity on the home planet and a beautiful blonde, whose family was exiled when she was a child and due to dangerous conditions occuring as they reached the moon, is unable to have healthy children. They get help from a wealthy French tourist, but most importantly from a self aware computer. Self aware computers are a recurring feature in several of Mr Heinlein's works. The self aware computer is the master computer that pretty much runs most of Luna for the authority. It's a wonderful ally. Most people now living don't even think about how powerful computers affect their lives on a daily basis, even though it happens on a continual basis. This novel was written in the 1960's long before really powerful computers were an accepted part of everyday life. Only large corporations had computers and their computing power was probably less then one of today's smartphones. Computer scientists venture to guess now a days that in the future computers may become powerful and fast enough to become self aware. If you consider that this story was written about 50 years ago, when computer science was in its childhood, the manner in which this story develops to its climax makes it all that more amazing. Read, listen and enjoy.
Tell us about yourself!
Okay, this book has been on the shelf for a long time.
I remember reading it in high school, read it again in college and once more mid 40's.
Still have the paperback in the attic.
The story is still great, technology is dated but who cares.
What really got me was the narration. Best I've heard in the last dozen or so listens.
Give this one a listen.
You won't regret it
Often when I've picked up a science fiction novel that I enjoyed in the past, I find it's just too dated both in technology and in character that it no longer works for me. I've read this book before, but probably at least 30 years ago. I loved it then, and I was pleased to find that I love it just as much now, if not more.
Lloyd James performs the narration narration extremely well, with just the right tone for all the characters. Although written in 1966, it wears time well. You can understand the references to nation states and political thought of the time, but it's also as easy to just go with the story without reference to the past. Of course, even the expectations of technology weren't on the mark, it doesn't matter to the story, in spite of one of the main characters actually being a computer.
Well written, wonderful characters and story.
Stranger in a Strange Land, also written by Heinlein, has long been one of my favorite books. I think Moon has climbed up that list after this listening.
Report Inappropriate Content