©1989 Terry and Lyn Pratchett; (P)1995 ISIS Publishing Ltd
When I drive, I read... uhm listen. I like SciFi, Fantasy, some Detective and Espionage novels and Religion. Now and then I will also listen to something else.
There are very few books that deserve to be revised. Guards Guards, the first of the Night Watch Discworld novels is one of these few. With the classic performance of Nigel Planer it felt like bounching into an old and beloved friend with whom one has lost contact many years ago. Planer's voice and the late Sir Terry Pratchett's "serious" humour still makes an excellent escape from the rush and turmoil of everyday life. This audiobook is a golden oldie to be revisited every once and again.
Nigel Planer is amazing! The voices you will hear are the same you've imagined in your head, when reading paper book. I enjoy Pratchett again, but this time on the street, in subway, everywhere.
It is Pratchett, so ..... everything.
The real authentic voices.
I really enjoyed this audio book. The narator did his best to really place you in unbelievable adventure, with characters that are very easy to identify.
An avid, omnivorous but critical reader.
It is definitely one of the better books. It rolls along with the occasional laugh out loud segment and frequent guffaws.
Its hard not to like all the characters. Pratchett develops his characters as if they were real people. I do like Sam Vimes though. He's an interesting mix of the alcoholic veteran and the suddenly energetic action hero - surprising himself as much as the reader.
Inflection, accents and delivery pace all bring the characters to life and the events are vested with excitement you might not discover just reading it yourself. There are very few readers I think I'd trust with a Discworld book and Nigel is great.
Not especially. This is a light tale that gallops along exuding fun, humour and wrapped around a cracking good story.
Yes. As much as I admire Nigel Planer, I do wish the voice he used for Sam Vimes had suited the character a little better. The voice is a little nasal and somewhat dull. Vimes is many things but he's certainly not stupid.
story amazing. Pratchett at his best. narrator excellent does wonderful voices. production value of very poor quality and disappointing with sudden stops and starts and a point where the reading fades into background and then paragraph starts over again.
these are wonderful books by Terry Pratchett. please see that your production does them justice in future.
Sam Vimes and his ragtag group of night's watchmen are, personally one of my favourite storylines in the Discworld series.
The starting point with this book!
It has the all standardpoints from Terry Pratchett's books.
Humour, action, darkness, depth, enjoyment, and above all, Death. With a capitol D.
loved the book of course, and for the most part narration is fine but carrot and vimes sound like yokels, which is not how I have them in my head. So not good for me.
"Good, but not the best of the series"
Guards! Guards! is one of the earlier discworld books and is the first time we are introduced to the City Watch making it their first in that line of books set in the discworld.
This is a fantastic story and it is well read, however the truth is that Planer is not as good at the unabridged recordings as Briggs and as a result I have lowered my score.
There is also the fact that as this is an early Guards book its just not as fleshed out as some of its sequels and as a result I cant really give it five stars because doing so would cheapen the five star novels from later on in the series.
If you love Discworld you will love this (I did), however while listening to it just remember that there is far better to come
I love the characters in Terry Pratchett's books, Lady Sybil is wonderful - I imagine her like a ship in full sail, although each of the Discworld novels follow on from eachother, they are equally brilliant as 'stand alone' stories. I do feel strongly that Terry Pratchett is a brilliant man, and that his humour is intelligent and pokes fun at the stupidities of our human race!
"A Great Bedtime Listen!"
Funny and sweet and unpredictable. Perfect escapism after a busy day. Narrated very well by Nigel Planer.
My favourite discworld story brought to life by Nigel Planer. I've owned and loved Tony Robinsons abridged version but this is better. The full text contains a lot of additional humour, the story holds together better, and I like planar's restrained style especially his deadpan Vimes. Highly recommended to all dragon lovers.
brilliantly introduced into the night watch story line and the brilliantly cynic Sam vimes!!! classic
Beautifully written, brilliantly read with real character infused by Nigel Planer. Absolutely Hilarious. Only let down but rubbishy sound quality of old "audiobooks - when are we going to get cd quality?
"Excellent despite not loving Terry Pratchett"
I never thought that I would say this about a Terry Pratchett book, it was very amazing! I really loved it,I think I got onto the wrong foot with Terry Pratchett, but I could never get into his books then my brother made me listen to this one and I loved it, I couldn't put it down and have loved the entire series, really worth a read whether you are a Terry Pratchett fan or not.
"one of my favourites"
you can't hold a better mirror to our world. oh and it has a bloody great big dragon in it.
"Warning! Do not listen in public!"
Time and time again. It always makes me laugh out loud, something always takes me by surprise.
Corporal Nobbs, disqualified from the human race for shoving... or is it Lance Constable Carrot the 6 foot dwarf, a picture of innocence, or ... there are just too many to choose from.
No, but I will do now.
Sorry don't do this - read books instead.
This is laugh out loud funny, hence my warning. Listen and enjoy.
One of Terry Pratchett's disc world greats.
Well there is about 3 other books in the disc world colletion that centre's around the the night watch.
There are parts where the gap between words is too long or short where it has been cut.
any part about Knobby knobs.
Read all the disc world colletion.
Report Inappropriate Content