Caustically funny, eerily accurate in its depiction of junkies, scam artists, and the walking brain-dead, Philip K. Dick's industrial-grade stress test of identity is as unnerving as it is enthralling.
©1977 Philip K. Dick; (P)2006 Random House, Inc. Random House Audio, a division of Random House, Inc.
This was my first audible book ever. Loved the narrator. Encouraged by my brother, I gave it a try. Since then I have been hooked on audible. Thanks Bro!
I have heard that PKD didn't spend a lot of time editing his work. If he had, he would have removed the nonsensical ranting about nothing that makes up the first half of the book. The second half is interesting, and the narrator is decent, but your credit is better spent elsewhere.
The change and development of the tone of the story surprised me: at first I thought the author had a Nancy Regan-style
Donna. I especially like her because of the development her character underwent. At first I was really disappointed, because initially she seemed weak and one-dimensional. Being the only female in the book, the tone of the entire story seemed distractingly misogynistic. I was really pleasantly surprised to see how strong and sympathetic this character became.
He did a good job. His voice is good and gravelly when it needs to be, which compliments the grittiness of the story.
I didn't laugh or cry, but after the book was over I definitely sat back and thought about life and existence and those type of big questions.
It is interesting to look at futuristic/distopia stories from previous generations such as this. It gives an insight into the culture and concerns of the time in which they were written. Today, it wouldn't make as much sense to write this sort of book, since rampant drug abuse just isn't the phenomena it once was (or at least isn't perceived to be so threatening to mainstream society). It is fascinating to see how a reality such as this may have seemed plausible a few decades ago.
Paul Giamatti brings this Philip K. Dick classic to life. The characters are distinct and fully realized under Giamatti's vocalization. I easily slipped into the story and the warped, paranoid and dual world Dick created, Giamatti enhances that voice and provides access to the action not to mention the subtext of this dystopian tale. I flew through the recording and would heartily recommend it to any Philip K. Dick fan. I hope to find more Giamatti narrations on Audible in the future. He does more than justice to this book.
I was drawn to this book, having seen the movie several times. I was amazed at the fidelity of the movie to the original manuscript. I can so clearly see various scenes of the movie as they are narrated, but with exquisite detail that augments my memory of the movie. Highly recommended.
My partner and I listened to this on a road trip and both loved it. Giamatti's reading is fantastic. Even though I've since seen the movie, I still hear the story in Giamatti's voice.
I've stopped listening to this book and come back to it twice now (listening to a couple of other books in between to take a break) and have gotten almost halfway through, but just cannot get into it. There doesn't appear to be any real plotline, just the random interactions of a group of drug-addicted losers who have absurd debates with one another that might be bearable if they were funny at all (but they just come off as pathetic). One of the addicts is an undercover cop who seems confused about what is and is not reality, though this didn't add much drama to the story for me. I find I really don't care what happens to any of the characters and don't know that I'll ever bother to finish the book. After only getting through five hours or so, I'm off to take yet another break with another book.
I am a PKD fan, but I find many of his later works challenging. This book just rambled on and on (I've not seen the movie, but in answer to the previous reviewer, they probably changed a great deal of it to dramatize it, like with all of the other PKD adaptations), to the point where I endured to finish it because I used two credits on it.
The story has a kind of "1984" feel to it, in the sense that the protagonist is basically trapped, with little or nothing he can do to survive the manipulation that has created his situation (the protagonist is rather pathetic by the end, too). The author's note at the end was moving, but all in all, the story itself felt drug-induced and disjointed, making it a struggle to keep track of what was going on.
Giamatti as the narrator was excellent. For the most part, the book just draaaaaaaged.
I have purchased many audio books from Audible and have never experienced such a disappointment with a 'book' until now --- it is enough to have me write a review! Scanner Darkly is the worst book I have ever read or listened to. The story line is nothing short of boring, it is confusing and ridiculous and a complete waste of money....I did not even bother listening to Part II .... Barely got through Part I. Save your money...its a horrible "read". I am surprised Audible has it on their site!
Some of us at work here decided to see the movie "A Scanner Darkly". Anyway, I decided to get an audio book version to try and re-familiarize myself with the story. The one I found is this one, narrated by Paul Giamatti. I listen to a lot of audiobooks, so I can get pretty critical of the readers. However, Giamatti does an excellent job of handling the different characters including women ones and different range of emotions, etc.
Report Inappropriate Content