Loretta Simpson lost her parents to a daring Comanche raid seven years ago - and now she lives as a mute with her extended family. Meanwhile, Comanche Hunter of the Wolf sees her as the embodiment of an ancient prophesy and chooses her for marriage. Still fearful of his tribe, Loretta soon finds her will bending, even as conflict between their two peoples intensifies.
©1991 Catherine Anderson; (P)2008 Recorded Books,LLC
Tell us about yourself!
I purchased this audiobook because of the many rave reviews, but unfortunately mine wont be as kind. I didn't hold this to particularly high standards because it is a romance book, and went along with most of it until about the third section. The absolute worst thing about this audiobook is the narrator. She sounds like a little old lady, and the last thing I want is a little old lady (with a whiny voice) reading sex scenes to me. The narrator breathes heavy, swallows audibly, and has a halting way of delivering the script. And she absolutley butchers the main Comanche's way of speaking. She narrates the Indians in the same stereotypical way that most people say "how" when mimicking Native Americans, deep and drawn out, and absolutey awful for the main love interest. The book itself held my interest until the third segment. I allowed myself to believe that a Comanche could speak fluent English, and believed that he could fall in love with a white girl, but the story got repetitive very quickly. He abducts her, she fights back, he takes her home, she comes back, she tries to run away, he convinces her to stay, she runs away, he goes after her. It seemed like these Indians had nothing better to do than chase after her through the whole book. And she is such a prude I felt like screaming. Also, rape is a very prevalent theme. I wasn't offended or put out by it, but it just seemed like everyone got raped or was almost raped, and just when you think youve gotten past it they vividly describe an old rape. I guess overall my expectations were that if I managed to believe this English speaking Indian falls head over heels for a white girl and chases her all over the earth then at least take me the whole way-dont have him threaten to beat her or marry other wives, and please dont give him the voice of a typecast Indian.
I acually liked the story, Hard to overcome the way you are brought up, hating "savages" and "whites" alike. I am am american Native and not so long ago in 2008 there was actually a woman who referred to us as "savages" in this time and age hard to believe! But she was upset over the Native americans opening a Casino....Some tend to forget where they come from, most all came from another country, we are the natives who's land was taken away...anyway that is another story.
I liked both main characters in the book, really seeing each other and being able to understand why each other has the feelings they do.
I didn'tt like her much but I am kind of sensitive in my hearing. She smacked to much for me and I was tempted to refund my book, which I do if I don't like the story or narrator. Long silenes also.
Think you could have used two narrators male and female for the charactors!
I enjoyed this book in paperback and I downloaded this copy to my ipod to listen to on my commute. I was unsure of the narrator after hearing the initial clip, but went ahead and used my credit on this book. Mistake!! I thought I could handle the narrator and I just couldn't do it. The story is about a youger woman and the narrator has a grating voice that sounds like she is 100 years old. I just couldn't do it... If you have any doubts after listening to the preview clip, just don't do it. It only gets worse.
West Sunbury, Pa.
A book that takes you back in time. I love stories like this, and there are many wonderful examples of life explained in this book.
Make sure you listen to Comanche Heart right after this. The books follow in order.
I recommend this to anyone who likes to relive their dreams.
I am not sure what else to say about this book ... besides I LOVED IT! You will not reqret the purchase. Also, I would love to see Madaline Stowe and Daniel Lewis play Loretta and Hunter ... it would be a box office hit.
Audio Addict! Usually listening to History these days. Love Will Durant most of all authors!
The differences between Loretta and the comanche are never overcome. There is far too much between them. I will say that I liked the hero a great deal, and I was entirely openminded. I also felt very sad for the reality that is the Native American history. But all and all I didn't buy the story.
Lost in a good book
Repetitive, irritating heroin, painfully too long.
The descriptions of the native way of life, philosophy, and language. I loved Hunter.
The smacking, swallowing, "old lady" voice, background door shutting and what sounded like dogs barking was so awful - I tolerated it but it was difficult. I found her tone was so dull that it took away from the story. She paused for so long and sometimes spoke so slowly and other times she just read along "normaly."
Oh God no! It was so long, sometimes I struggled to keep listenting.
Probably. This story had it's ups and downs, the main female character was aggravating and predictable at times.
The narration of the native language was so halting, to the point of distraction.
I think the audio edition is just as good as the print version. A lot of reviewers complained about the narrator, but I really found her to be an excellent storyteller. I remember one review in particular that didn't like the way she read the Comanche words... but in the story, Hunter is teaching Loretta the words... so he would enunciate them very slowly so she would be able to hear the syllables and learn. Didn't bother me at all.
I love all of Catherine Anderson's stories, and sometimes I'm glad I have a long commute to work so I can listen to big chunks at a time :) This is a book I have a hard time putting down!
The more I got into the story the more I lost the voice of the narrator, and heard the voice of the characters. I was not impressed with the narrator overall.
Hunter truly was the character that I liked the most. Dealing with 2 cultures, and trying to understand his destiny he was a man in an emotional turmoil
More the actual recording was the biggest distraction. To many dead spots and not enough spacing between chapters.
No I bought this book with the understanding of having several weeks of listening while I drove to and from work.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.