A belief in free will touches nearly everything that human beings value. It is difficult to think about law, politics, religion, public policy, intimate relationships, morality—as well as feelings of remorse or personal achievement—without first imagining that every person is the true source of his or her thoughts and actions. And yet the facts tell us that free will is an illusion.
In this enlightening book, Sam Harris argues that this truth about the human mind does not undermine morality or diminish the importance of social and political freedom, but it can and should change the way we think about some of the most important questions in life.
©2012 Sam Harris (P)2012 Simon & Schuster
"Free will is an illusion so convincing that people simply refuse to believe that we don’t have it. In Free Will, Sam Harris combines neuroscience and psychology to lay this illusion to rest at last. Like all of Harris’s books, this one will not only unsettle you but make you think deeply. Read it: you have no choice." (Jerry A. Coyne, Professor of Ecology and Evolution, University of Chicago, and author of Why Evolution Is True)
"In this elegant and provocative book, Sam Harris demonstrates—with great intellectual ferocity and panache—that free will is an inherently flawed and incoherent concept, even in subjective terms. If he is right, the book will radically change the way we view ourselves as human beings." (V. S. Ramachandran, Director of the Center for Brain and Cognition, UCSD, and author of The Tell-Tale Brain)
"Brilliant and witty—and never less than incisive—Free Will shows that Sam Harris can say more in 13,000 words than most people do in 100,000." (Oliver Sacks)
Maybe, but not if it is as short as this one.
The subject interested me and I started listening with a lot of anticipation, but the most interesting part was the beginning, where a set of very interesting experiments was presented; thereafter, it was all a bit anticlimactic.
It was more a lecture than a book. Which is OK, but I was expecting a book that develops the subject at greater length. But it is not a lecture I regret having listened to.
This is the first book I've read from Sam Harris. I loved the subject matter and the conciseness with which it was presented. I also enjoyed his narration. Love that he points out that punishment is still possible as a preventative measure, we didn't need free will, good or evil to legitimize it. We just need to consider the effects of punishment in the long run. Fascinating, I could listen to much more on this subject.
I thought I would find scholarly ammunition for what I personally am coming to believe about free will. I usually enjoy and understand Sam Harris, in his blog and in other books. But this was too scholarly and did not reach me.
Yes, because I think it encourages people to consider a new perspective that they may not have had access to.
The comparisons that are made.
At first, I found his speaking style alitle hard to follow, but by the time I reached the second or third chapter, I was accustomed to it and it became clear without having to rewind and re listen.One thing I appreciated was that he wrote the book to be accessible to more people by opting for more common words instead of long, uncommon ones... I only had to pause the book maybe 3 times to look up a word.
FREE WILL... You may beleive in it, but you may not have a choice.
The possible new perspective is well worth the relatively low price of the book.
Simply not enough time in the world to read all the books I want to, so now I listen to them.
I already have. It is very short, so it is a very very quick listen. It lays out the argument for and against free will in fairly easy to understand ways. I wished it was longer.
Not really worth using a credit on this book, but very worth the few dollars it cost me.
You're a human being with free will - you decide whether you'd like coffee or tea in the morning. You decide what clothing to wear to work. You have control over how you approach the world. You have control.
... or do you?
Sam Harris puts forth a logically woven argument in this book that will likely leave your world a little bit changed. Are you curious yet? =) This audio book is well read and absolutely worth the money.
Short and to-the-point. Sam does a great job of illustrating that we do not REALLY have free will, even if we FEEL like we do.
"The Illusion of Free Will"
My only complaint is that there is no real organization to the book, or his argument. It might help some listeners (readers) if he was more explicit about the argument behind his thesis.
It gives a well though out position that seems logically consistent describing why there is no such thing as free will. Sam Harris even addresses his critics and recognizes the irony in the simple fact that he obviously didn't have true free will to decide whether he would write this book or not.
Its conclusion is disturbing... all the more so, because he does seem to get there without cheating. Or did he? That's the question that arises in your mind after hearing it. If there is no free will, what do you do with that knowledge. He does try to address that near the end, but that was the only part that wasn't convincing to me. Other than pure denial or apathy or laziness, what stops people from living there lives in some kind of Nietzche-like nihilism.
The only "moral" point that seems to be backed up by his reasoning... and he brings this point to the forefront at the very beginning of the book... is that the criminal justice system needs to be more cognizant of this world-view when sentencing violent criminals... more specifically, that the justice system should be set up to prevent criminal behavior not necessarily punish it... since no one is truly responsible for their behavior (in his world view).
But again, what does this mean for the rest of us. He argues that this won't and shouldn't turn us all into nihilistic libertines. And he may be right but for the wrong reasons. Even if you accept his arguments, can you really embrace them fully and not go a little wacked. The lack of free will... be it a myth or not... is disturbing, very disturbing. One's own internal self defense mechanisms kick in and the reading all seems like some amnesiac's dream.
His reading of the book suffices. Its a philosophical treatise so there is no real need for anything but a straight-forward reading of the book, and Harris delivers that just fine. Of course, it always adds to the hearing of the reading when you know the narrator is the same as the author.
Why you should be nice to psychopaths cause you could be one too, who knows?
It is well thought out premise. We did not choose our genetics nor our experiences,nor can we control out thoughts or perceptions, so how can our next actions be of our own choosing when our actions are based on who we've become at that moment.
Loved the book, all ready listened to it twice and working on my third.
"mind blowing book"
Really changes the way you think. Very strong argument. Recommended to anyone who is interested. Mind it is quite short so don't blow your monthly credit on it.
A nice quick listen which is very well explained. Quite educational as I certainly know more about free will now.
Report Inappropriate Content