©2004 Spider Robinson; (P)2005 Blackstone Audiobooks
Surprisingly, the author is a very good reader, one of the better ones I have heard and it was a pleasure to listen to him. The story takes place in and around Vancouver both in the city and surrounding countryside. Descriptions of people and places are vivid and often humorous - the protagonist/narrator has a wry outlook on life that sometimes made me laugh out loud (not easy to get me to laugh during my commute). The characters are rich and interesting, often quirky and always satisfying. The beginning of this book is great. The ending is not as good as the beginning but it is good. The middle of the book just never happened and it's very frustrating to go from "Wow, I can't wait to hear what's next" to "whoa - it's over!?" so fast. The author is very skilled at building suspense but just when he had me eager to hear what's next he turned around and went off on a tangent about other people and prior times. These tangents are often charming and well written but they cover characters not central to the plot, happen too often and eat up the pages I wish had been the middle of the story. I feel like I was introduced to these people and then never got the chance to get to know them. So if you want a good listen, okay, it's a good listen. If you want to listen to a good mystery novel, you may find yourself frustrated.
I'm amazed that this book is not higher rated. It's absolutely wonderful. The characters are great, the story is suspensful and the whole thing just works.
I was suprised to learn when I finished listening to it that it was actually narrated by the author. It's one of the best read audio books that I've have ever listened to!
As you can tell, I really enjoyed this book. I highly recommend it and I think you will enjoy it too.
A reasonably good story, though nothing like you would expect based on the Callahan's tales. Normally I try to review the audio side of things, figuring that there are many reviews of the content at other booksellers. But I have to mention that the content is somewhat disturbing and more visceral due to the audio experience. It is certainly not the nastiest, and certainly not the scariest or most violent, story around, but it has some "I wish I had never heard something that creepy" bits that remind me of wishing I had never seen the movies Seven or 8mm. Fair warning -- be sure you like stuff like that.
The narration by Spider is a bit weak. Far from the worst around, for sure, and the critics of his narration have gone a bit far. Since it is his story, there is some value added in him narrating it. But you certainly would not want him as a narrator for someone else's work. He really only has three or four character voices, and there are (a few) more than four characters that need voices.
Overall, I would have to say that this is fine, but there are better choices for Robinson irreverence, for spooky stories, for characterization, and for narrations (though maybe not all four at once).
Reading Spider is just like hanging out with an old friend. I can just easily identify with his writing style and his train of thoughts. This book started out a bit disjointed but finished strong. I enjoyed it.
I'm an avid audio book listener as well as a long form voice over (audio book narration) performer.
I really enjoyed this book and was sorry when it ended. Unlike a couple of reviewers here, I thought Spider did a wonderful job narrating his own story. After all, who knows the characters better than the person who wrote them? The pacing was fast, the story was intense, and while mostly one dimensional, the characters were wonderfully engaging. The story does wrap itself up very quickly, but is ultimately very satisfying in the end.
as great a writer/story teller as spider is /he is a bad narrator. i missed barrett whittner's delivery of this geneus' lines...can i ask for a redo...by barrett? amazing what a voice can do.
Not any more I don't think.
I'll try something else. How about a 'Sector General' or Zenna Henderson book?
"Hold on tight...."
It takes a rare talent to do what has been done here. This book contains concepts of torture and sadism that might well make you lose your breakfast to think about...were it not that they are sorrounded by the warm humour and fast wit that is unique to Spider Robinson. Even a book like this, remenicscent of Dean Koonz and Stephen King, he can turn into a feel-good experience. And don't fool yourself, early on, that you can predict the plot....you won't!!!
Report Inappropriate Content