Phryne Fisher, scented and surprisingly ruthless, is not one to let sleuthing a horrific crime get in the way of an elegant dalliance.
The redoubtable Phryne Fisher is holidaying at Cave House, a Gothic mansion in the heart of the Victorian mountain country.
But the peaceful country surroundings mask danger. Her host is receiving death threats, lethal traps are set without explanation around the house and the parlour maid is found strangled to death.
What with the reappearance of the mysterious funerary urns, apair of young lovers, an extremely eccentric swagman, an angry outcast heir, and the luscious Lin Chung, Phryne’s attention has definitely been caught.
Phryne’s search for answers takes her deep into the dungeons of the house and of the limestone Buchan caves. But what will she find this time?
Solve another case with Phryne Fisher.
©1996 Kerry Greenwood (P)2011 Bolinda Publishing Pty Ltd
Mystery reader (especially series) and Austen lover
This Phryne Fisher adventure is a bit different from earlier Greenwood books. In "Urn Burial," the author has decided to play a game as many earlier mystery writers did in the 1920s and 1930s, sometimes including Agatha Christie. The game involved following the Rules of Murder which had developed over the early years of the genre, and which were "codified" by mystery writer Ronald Knox in 1929.
Knox set forth 10 rules, which he followed in his books (several of those books are available on Audible), including things such as there must be a large party at a country house, no magic or similar gimmicks can be used to solve the crime, there may be no Chinamen introduced into the story, and other matters. (You can find Knox's Rules set forth in the Wikipedia article on The Golden Age of Detection Fiction.) In addition to following those rules, Greenwood also pays homage to Agatha Christie in several details, including naming one of her characters Miss Mary Mead.
I found the story quite engaging, although in a different manner than the previous Phryne adventures. Despite the different structure, however, Phryne is still Phryne, stylish, passionate, self confident, and very much her own woman. As is usual with Phryne books on Audible, there is at the end an interview between the author and Stephanie Daniel, the voice of Phryne, and in these conversations you always pick up a little information about Australia in the 1920s or about Australian history or grography.
I have yet to find a Phryne book on Audible which wasn't fascinating, entertaining, and great fun. They all give you hours of lighthearted adventure, and I love them!
Light, entertaining and easy to listen to.
In the cave towards the end
We listen to Greenwoods books as we drive. We love all her books.
"A children's story that can only be enjoyed by children is not a good children's story in the slightest.” --C.S. Lewis
Possibly. I haven't gotten around to listening to any of my books over again. Although I do read them over and over, so you never know.
I think as the books move on, Kerry Greenwood's descriptions and storyline get stronger.
I've been listening to the entire series. This was standard performance, I wouldn't have expected anything else--although STOP SINGING. Jeez.
Yes, but it's kind of a twist, so I don't want to give it away.
Ugh. The sex is getting to be a bit too much as far as Phryne is concerned. It's fine with me if she wants one lover a book, but two? Not necessary, and it really skeeved me out, especially since they were both within a day of each other, and technically she was "with" one of them. I thought it was crude and manipulative. I don't appreciate cheating in real life, why would I want to read about it? (the other lovers within the book/storyline don't bother me one bit, although somebody who is more...prejudiced...may take issue).
You can always count on Phryne Fisher for a bit of light fun. This one is a bit different from others in the series, as the author tips her hat (or sticks out her tongue) at Agatha Christie. The story is full of the usual Christie tropes (the isolated country house, the long returned secret relative, and on and on) but Greenwood pokes and tweaks them in a very un-Christie way.
It wasn't my favorite of the Phryne mysteries by far, but was quite an enjoyable diversion none the less.
Love these stories! Watched All of the movies! Loved reading and listening too Enjoying them All three Ways !!
Australian Film Noir, with a brassy, strong female lead!
An Agatha Christie Who Done It, we'll sort of. As a fan of period mystery fiction, this is one of the best. We have Phryne in a Agatha Christie mystery, but with characters we have come to love.
Loved story, but found several of the voices sounding the same making it difficult to always tell who was talking!
But do plan on buying and listening to more cause the story was so intriguing!
By Kerry Greenwood
Narrated by Stephanie Daniel
An interesting take on the old house party mysteries. The book even has a cast lists like in some Agatha Christie books. Set at Gothic country house, where all the occupants have secrets and the bad guy uses those secrets against them. Kerry Greenwood hit on all the tropes, but gives each one her own twist. Pay close attention to the names of characters, there are jokes hidden there. The book is a fun read. If listening to the audio book Stephanie Daniel does a great job reading.
You have to love Phryne
The boathouse and the cave were both equally memorable.
Possibly too many characters.
"Fabulous story as usual."
Wonderfully written and narrated,long may Phryne reign !!! I cannot get enough of her adventures.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.