Brighton, 1950: When the body of a girl is found, cut into three, Detective Inspector Edgar Stephens is reminded of a magic trick, the Zig Zag Girl. The inventor of the trick, Max Mephisto, is an old friend of Edgar's. They served together in the war as part of a shadowy unit called the Magic Men. Max is still on the circuit, touring seaside towns in the company of ventriloquists, sword-swallowers, and dancing girls.
Changing times mean that variety is not what it once was, yet Max is reluctant to leave this world to help Edgar investigate. But when the dead girl turns out to be known to him, Max changes his mind.
Another death, another magic trick: Edgar and Max become convinced that the answer to the murders lies in their army days. When Edgar receives a letter warning of another 'trick', the Wolf Trap, he knows that they are all in the killer's sights....
©2014 Elly Griffiths (P)2014 Quercus Editions Ltd
For me it was not, since I found the story contrived and unappealing. Maybe I am unfair, since I really enjoy her Ruth Galloway series and expected to be as absorbed and attached to the characters and was not at all.
I will listen to the last installment of the Joe Sandilands series.
maybe the end…because I was glad to be done...
For me it does not, even though not liking one book does not mean the next one cannot be much more gripping.
I am eagerly waiting for the next Ruth Galloway book, one of the best mystery series around, for me.
So poor in plot structure and reading; I cant think of anyone who would enjoy this after earlier Elly Grifith's books.
I was looking forward to trying something new by Elly Griffiths after enjoying her Ruth Galloway stories. Unfortunately this story failed to engage me on any level. The characters were one dimensional, the back story unbelievable and the plot twists could be seen a mile off. The action switched between the two lead characters, Max and Edgar, but the combination of stilted dialogue and poor narration often meant I was struggling to remember which character's viewpoint it was. The narrator didn't seem to have the vocal range necessary to cope with such a wide range of characters.
All in all a very disappointing story and I hope Elly Griffiths won't feel the need to return to the lives of the Magic Men.
"Good enough but not exceptional"
Yes. It was a bit predictable and some of the characters a bit stock, but my expectations were not high.
I have listened to the whole Ruth Galloway series and was getting very involved with the characters, but I do not think the main character in The Zig-Zag Girl could support a sequel. Let Elly Griffiths prove me wrong!
"The Zig Zag Girl"
It was nice to have a book set in the world of magic, however indirectly. Not something you read about very often. The time period is interesting too, with the world a little bit dark and a little bit in flux.
The narrator unfortunately was not good. Very much on one tone all the way through, and no real characterisation, making it quite difficult to differentiate between the characters. He is a big negative, and I will make a point of avoiding him in the future, I'm afraid.
I thoroughly enjoy the Ruth Galloway books so I did approach this with a certain amount of trepidation, but narration aside, I thoroughly enjoyed it. It is imbued with the warm humour that characterises Ms Griffiths' other books, and is certainly well worth a go. But do be prepared for that narrator which made listening to it a good deal more of a task than was necessary.
"Very different from Ruth Galloway"
Brighton just after the war, seedy and slightly "foreign" . A body in three pieces, a policeman who was part of a team of magicians; the magic men who during the war dreamed illusions to fool the enemy. Then more bodies. The writing is sedate, the characters polite, only the magicians are exotic. The mystery unfolds slowly but I could not stop listening. Recommended, but don't expect anything similar to her other Norfolk stories
"JP Priestly meets Jonathan Creek"
Come on Elly. The concept/ of magicians/just after war is wonderful. I absolutely adored the first half of this tale (as will all lovers of Empires Lost and Good Companions/JP Priestly. But sadly the last half of this tale lost its way,
This could indeed be the start of a great series - but you need to give it a lot more TLC Elly Griffiths before it becomes a good one.
Yes, enjoyable but I kept feeling that there was another book I should have read first. Possibly one called 'The Magic Men'! This feeling wasn't dispelled until towards the end, when the previous lives info the main protagonists became clearer. None the less - a good listen.
"Couldn't finish this one"
No, it felt dated and I didn't enjoy the narration.
I have loved listening to ALL the series of archeology books featuring Ruth and Nelson. This seems to lack drive, and just seems to stall and is a bit dull by comparison.
I found it slow, and just couldn't get into it at all. I tried 3 times, perhaps it was after the previous series that it did not come up to scratch.
Didn't finish it
Someone with little imagination and no common sense, the plot was easy to predict from the first chapter.
Something by Pratchett, to cleanse my audio pallet.
His narration was strong, the only positive thing about this book.
Daniel Philpott was very good in narrating the story. Elly Griffiths told a very good story.
Report Inappropriate Content