©2004 Susan Hill; (P)2014 Audible, Inc.
There are no reviews for this title yet.
Very long winded and slow on the take. Kept hoping for it to pick up but dissapointed
Susan Hill has been one of my favourite writers in the past but this had me asking myself if it was a Mills and Boone book, or was it a different Susan Hill? Not so.
The embarrassing crush that Freya has on her DCI is totally inconsistent with a professional detective sergeant, or any other professional woman. The country yokel accents of the 'monkey faced' detective and a uniform sergeant do not sit well with the 'proper' accents of the other ranks and other 'middle class' individuals in the story. As a former police officer I find it frustrating that Hill has not done her research into the police service.
A move into CID is not a promotion!
it is highly unlikely that a detective constable would speak to his sergeant the way he does in this book ....and certainly not in the whining voice that is sometimes used.
If a doctor went to see a patient regarding a complaint of assault or sexual assault the last thing they would do would be to ask the police to go along before they had ascertained what had occurred. The police would hardly expect to be called to go and wait outside a house while a doctor interviewed someone to ascertain if an assault had taken place.
Does Ms Hill really think that a detective sergeant will have encountered many psychopaths? It is unlikely that a police officer will meet many or any in their career!
Amazing that there is no mention of mobile phones until very near the end of book..... I assumed it must have been originally written in a time before mobile phones, otherwise why have they not have been usefully used earlier in the story? To support this assumption of an earlier era I cite the use of comments like 'yonks' by a 40 year old ...hardly a term used today. Similar expression were used elsewhere which made me cringe.
To read a book containing many characters, which need to be defined by voice, cannot be easy, but I found the narration 'over the top.'
If the book had been read aloud by a woman I suspect that the perfume YSL would almost certainly have been read as Yves St Laurent ...no one to my knowledge refers to YSL by its letter format.
Hardly a Simon Serailler novel, since he is only occasionally in it!
Obviously a number of people did enjoy it from the reviews, but I have to confess amazement that some of the critics who wrote reviews in the national newspapers spoke highly of the book.
"Disappointing, tedious and not mysterious"
I was looking for a good classic detective story, and this book was suggested in the category, with overall good reviews. Unfortunately, it was quite disappointing for a crime mystery novel. Perhaps, I was expecting a more old fashion book, or a mid. 20th century classic crime, and the book is contemporary. That I think should have been mentioned in the description. I have to say that the writing style is good, so the book does not fail there, but it fails in storyline and mystery. The narrator Steven Pacey was good, although it was odd and confusing to listen to him narrating all women's voices, as the characters introduced in the first half were mostly women. I was critical of some of the reviewers stating that this is not a book a man could enjoy, it sounded very sexist, but I have to agree that many of the descriptions of characters and relations between them were indeed tedious to listen to and had no bearing to the crimes. It is more of a social novel, if you like a fictional description of what life and people are like in a small English town, you may like it. Perhaps what grabbed the attention of some of the listeners was the chance to peek into what could be the private stories of various people, including a very soapy description of undisclosed feelings of love from first sight, and the life in a somewhat small English town. But with a Cathedral, which should have then been called a city, but never mind. Simon Serrailler is not even a main character of the book. There is no mystery of what has happened to the victims and worst of all, you get to find out who the murderer is whole 4 hours before the end of the book, what follows is tedious, there is no mystery or suspense and without giving out any specific spoilers, the ending is quite disappointing.
Even Steven Pacey, one of the best narrators, couldn't make this story interesting.
Got as far as chapter 11 then give-up!
A a great fan of Steven Pacey I admit to finding this book through his listings as performer. The book is very well read although I had great difficulty to convince myself that this was the same Steven Pacey I had grown accustomed to so readily from other books.
As far as the story is concerned I find myself with the minority of reviewers, I am unable to hold out to the end.
What makes this book so unsatisfactory is that the author overworks the situations she describes and spends so much time on details which contribute very little if anything to the story. Perhaps there is a good plot or a good detective story further down but after 4 hours of listening I am not willing to invest more time..
I thought this novel was profoundly boring, i couldn't finish it, I found myself daydreaming and having no idea what had been happening for the past ten minutes. It felt more like a love story or a drama than a detective novel. Steven Paceys narration however was flawless and I found his voice captivating, but even his narration couldn't keep my complete attention. Sorry just not for me.
"A can't put down book"
My first Susan Hill book and it will not be my last, a combination of excellent plot characters and narrative means I am heading for the store to buy my next Susan Hill today.
A nicely told story until the bizarre fate of the killer that plagues the novel, especially with the focus of the book being told from the police view point. Well narrated. I'm not sure I'll get the next in the series.
"Brilliant storytelling, superb writing!"
A terrific read, great characters and storyline. You become drawn into the twists and turns of the plot as if you are on a rollercoaster ride, it is hard to stop listening to Steven Pacey's strong narration and by the end you feel emotionally drained.
The characters were well drawn and totally believable as were the places.
I must admit to shedding a few tears at the end!
Brilliant book, one of the very best I have listened to and I can't wait to listen to more from Susan Hill.
Excellent author, very sympathetic characters and extremely good reading by Steven Pacey. I will be going straight on to the next book in the series.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.