Except that Tony doesn't want to do this anymore.
But the case is about to come uncomfortably close to home. The next victim is a friend of his. And his former partner, DCI Carol Jordan, is herself in Germany, working undercover in a world where human life is cheaper than a drug deal. She needs his help as much as the beleaguered European police forces do.
Confronting the worst of contemporary crime and struggling to unravel roots that lie deep in the tormented past of Nazi atrocities and Statsi abuses, Tony and Carol are forced to battle for their survival against overwhelming odds.
Deftly merging the dark world of forensic psychology and the crime-streaked word of post-Cold War Europe, McDermid has created a truly original crime thriller for our time.
©2002 Val McDermid; (P)2002 Audio Renaissance, a division of Holtzbrinck Publishers, LLC
"With consummate skill and pacing, [McDermid] braids together the complex story lines through surprising revelations, heartstopping suspense, and cruel double-crosses." (Publishers Weekly)
"Guerin Barry narrates changes in location and high-action sequences without a hitch." (AudioFile)
"The Last Temptation is a masterful examination of evil and relics of the Nazi and Stasi years in Germany." (The Guardian)
I chose this book because I have enjoyed the BBC productions of the Tony Hill mysteries. This selection was a disappointment on 2 levels.
1) The author does a good job of constructing and pacing the criminal and forensic aspects of the story, but unfortunately does not have a good ear for realistic dialogue between characters. They always sound as if they are on stage, feeding us needed information for plot purposes.
2) With characters that are exclusively British or European, this book cries out for a reader that is British and also able to manage credible European accents. This reader is American and his attempts at accents reminds me of Saturday Nite Live style characatures, especially the heavy-handed German voices. The over-all emotional tone is of the "stiff upper lip" Brit style, and his rendition of the main female character verges on the falsetto. The intrinsic dialogue flaws from the author are just magnified by this poor choice of reader.
Those who don't already have a "mind's eye view" of Hill and Jordan from the BBC productions may not feel as critical of this presentation as I am. The story itself is good. I recommend listening to the sample to make a choice about selecting this book or not.
If you are considering trying your first Val McDermid audiobook, choose The Distant Echo--the narration is far better. Indeed The Distant Echo is one of the very best audiobooks I've ever heard.
Not that this book is poorly ready, just that the style is a bit flat, compared to the lively Scottish brogue used to read McDermid's other novel.
I also found the characters in this novel a bit flat compared to what I know McDermid can do based on her other novels. Perhaps the problem is the abridgment--I was periodically left with the impression that I was getting the facts, the plot line but not really gaining enough insight into the motivations of the characters. I suspect an unabridged version would have "read" better.
I have enjoyed both paper books and audible books by Val McDermid in the past, but I wasn't happy with this reading. Barry has a pleasant voice when narrating the story but did not do well on the character's accents or the women's voices. At times the emphasis points of sentences was off, like you'd find in an amateur theater production. I didn't finish the book, it annoyed me so much.
I liked the German setting.
The previous book in the Tony Hill/Carol Jordan series was read by Michael Tudor Barnes and the characters rang true. That was not the case in this reading.
It inspired me to cut my losses and not finish it, which is always irritating because I feel like I wasted a credit. In the future I will listen to samples before I buy
Someone listening to the story for the first time or who hasn't listened to the other stories as an Audible book.
It wasn't for me. I didn't care for the addition of music, I think it cheapens the story and the performance. My issue isn't so much with Barry's performance, but with my expectations and previous experience listening to Gerard Doyle's readings. It is Doyle's voice that I want and expect to add his flavor to the characters. It was very disconcerting to deal with a different representation of my beloved Tony & Carol.
All the music interludes should be removed!!
The story didn't flow. I felt like I missed something. It didn't feel as detailed as other novels, but I'm willing to consider that I felt this way because the performance so threw me.
The story is pretty typical Val McDermid, although some of the writing is not up to his usual ability. However the reader makes it worse. EVERY line is read as if it is the most important line in the book - way overly dramatic. Skip this one if you value your mind and ears.
I am no longer going to follow this series. The writing gets worse with each book.
I really like this author and series, but the narrator ruined this story for me. Had this been one of the first ones I picked up, it would have been my last and I would have missed out. Overall, this was a real bummer. The other narrators for this series are far superior.
This was arguably the most ridiculous and contrived plot I’ve read this year – full stop…
Let’s just see... You’ve got a minor Polish drug/human trafficker making inroads into England… The British Govt wants him stopped. So instead of doing something simple, like getting MI6 to assassinate him, the British Govt decides to do something ridiculously contrived, complex and doomed to failure… You get an operative to assassinate the kingpin’s girlfriend (a completely innocent woman --- and oh BTW --- just happens to look exactly like DCI Carol Jorden) and a few other minor member's of the kingpin's team, but leave El Hefe and his evil Lieutenant completely unmolested... and psychologically vulnerable...
Can you guess where the plot goes from here? That’s right – straight down the toilet.
I’ve read about ten of Val McDermid’s novels… And most of them are very good... I can’t believe Val actually wrote this – the characters, plot and dialog are contrived and totally unbelievable and just not up to her other works. Either she was having a bad year, simply pumped-one-out to satisfy a publishing contract or was the work of a ghost writer… Take your pick...
Don’t spend your credits here… Even if you love all her other books -- trust me, I don't think she wrote this one...
Report Inappropriate Content