In the dark night of the soul…
If Detective Chief Inspector Jane Tennison hadn't been a woman, she might not have noticed the victim's shoes…and that they didn't match the size given on the info sheet now so obviously misidentifying the dead blonde as a hooker named Della Mornay. Being so thorough, so good at the details, made Jane a top investigator; being a woman made the boys in the squadron want to see her fall on her face. But Jane Tennison was determined to catch the madman stalking women in London's street shadows. She had a prime suspect, and she needed to make the charges against him stick. She also needed to keep her own secret in check: she couldn't let anyone see that she was falling apart inside, as her obsession with cracking this case and breaking out from under the heel of the station house boy's club took over life, destroying her relationship with the man she loved, pushing her closer and closer to the dark urges of a killer…
©2012 AudioGO (P)1991 Lynda La Plante
I knew the story well but was interested in listening to the book after watching the TV drama series. The narrator is an excellent choice because she sounds like the Helen Mirren. I know that shouldn't necessarily be a factor but when you have seen the movie you expect to hear a tone of voice similar to what you remember. The book is brilliant and it was great to hear Linda La Plante talking about how she researched the Helen Mirren role.
Ms. Porter captures the nuances of the text and brings characters to life. She is easy to listen to and I look for books she narrates.
Plot was complex with many layers, as in life in general
Davinia does an excellent job bringing characters to life, no matter who the character is, a great talent.
Prime Suspect is known for the insights it provides into gender dynamics when a woman takes a leadership role in a traditionally male organization. While the story certainly does a good job of this, the descriptions of the emotions experienced by individual technicians while processing a horrific crime scene made me realize how current popular procedurals focus on the science, rather than the human response to the scene.
Jane Tennyson is barely likeable, but somehow she is sympathetic. An usual heroine in an unusual plot. Not the same old same old.
Prime Suspect #2!
Such credible and versatile voices for all characters. Awesome performance.
Masterpiece Mystery. Get it on Netflix.
This book is an effort to portray a woman fighting for respect, a topic that is well worth exploring. But there is no growth of character, no learning that goes on. Her winning of respects comes for no real reason, far too fast and too complete. But that is not the failure of this book. A book needs a plot, a story that develops. This plot might be worth a (very) short story but is painful when spread out to novel length. I do want to say this is very well written, the scenes are believable as are the characters. But I read stories for excitement, the slow discovery of new facts, each one uncovering both information and more questions. I also read for character development. Sadly all are lacking in this book.
No, I don't believe I would intentionally select another of Lynda La Plante's books to listen to or read. I didn't find the writing to be all that clever. I find the writing styles of Tana French, Gillan Flynn, Donna Tartt, Adrian McKinty to be far more interesting.
I felt the book to be fairly predictable and at times tedious. I admire and respect the fact that she is interested in highlighting the inequality female detectives are subjected to. However, I found the presentation of it to be mundane.
I tend to enjoy stories with flawed characters with complex backgrounds that allow me to appreciate certain qualities and loath other aspects. In this story, I found the character descriptions to lack depth. The author's descriptions seemed generally limited to relatively concise descriptions that motivated the characters to act as I would expect them to.
No. By the way, the audio book starts with a narrative from the author describing how she came to write a TV script that the book is based on and the real life female detective that helped form the main character.
The book is a New York Times Best Seller, so clearly many people enjoy Lynda La Plante's work. I would guess that the reader who likes a concise story with an "underdog" protagonist, may like this book. A reader that prefers books with complex characters may be less likely to find it a great read or listen.
Registered Physical Therapist, many interests and hobbies, love reading and listening!
Excellent character development, both protag and antagonists. The narrator is masterful in communicating irony, suspense, and humor!
Yes, life and death scenarios. I didn't know who to trust.
No extreme, just enjoyable, and I plan to listen to it several more times!
I'd seen Prime Suspect on TV as soon as it came out, thus never read the book. But on a whim I decided to try it. It helped that Davina Porter read it, she's among the very best of the best. I'm glad I gave it a go. For me, it was actually better than the film, except for the lack of Helen Mirren. Jane's a hard character to like, but certainly interesting and realistic. The criminal and the crimes are way weird, but my main entertainment was watching the police wend their way through the evidence, and plot their tactics. Good job by all.
Characters and situations in this murder mystery are well-rendered and interesting, but the plot is routine for this genre. Narrator does an excellent job of producing the different voices and maintaining the pace.
Report Inappropriate Content