©2006 Lesley Cookman; (P)2007 Soundings
I had hopes for this book and it turned out to be really boring. The story line was weak. Their was much repetition so much so that I fell asleep an woke up an hour later and it was saying the same thing as when I dozed off. There are tons of long bits that are just a repeat of something that has been covered maybe 3 or 4 times.
Libby is really immature and should have been given an age in her 30's or 40's. She acted so silly just because she is interested in some man. The hops and theme of the play they were putting on at their Oast House theater was a bit boring.
The reader was good. This yawner might be good if you have insomnia. It will put you to sleep. It really needed a good editor to cut out the repetitions and pull the story together. I hate giving a bad review but had I found any reviews at all for this book I would have had something to go by. I don't recommend this book at all.
"Insipid is the word"
I am quite a fan of the 'cozy' mystery but this was more 'humdrum' than 'cozy' and I have found very little to enjoy.
The story revolves around an Amateur Dramatics Group who are putting on a Play based on real events, written by a local guy.
The narrator is ok with female voices if a little irritating but her masculine voices are bad, I had trouble distinguishing which character was supposed to be speaking. However, this was not the main problem as I had a problem getting into the story for the first 2 to 3 hours.
I became a little more engaged at the point of Murder occurring but very little was made of the Murder itself, everything pretty much carried on as before, the Play would carry on, the characters that were against the play carried on in the same vein and I became bored once again, there was another vaguely interesting segment at around 7 hours when the 'True' version of events behind the Play are revealed but then I found myself plummeted back into the humdrum once more.
I have not finished the book, I shall not do so either, I am most disappointed with it, I found all the characters annoying, the main protagonist, Libby, being the most irritating amongst them all.
I would not recommend this book as I did not enjoy, nor even finish it but I may have been spoiled for this type of mystery as I am a great fan of Rebecca Tope and Elly Griffiths who write much more life into their characters in my opinion.
"an enjoyable start to the series."
this story had two time lines, the first in the present where libby is directing a play and the time that the play is based on.
libby is the main character and there are a number of people, mainly men, who are important too, who I think will be in the following episodes of the series
i thought the characters were well written and patience Tomlinson did really well in giving each character a different voice, especially fran who has a deep husky voice
this has the potential of being as good as the rhona parish series by anthea fraser.
Report Inappropriate Content