When DCI Andy Gilchrist is called to a crime scene to find an amputated hand clutching a note addressed to him, he is pulled into an investigation that will test him to the limit. Soon other single word clues are found along with amputated body parts and the murderer's vengeful message becomes clear as the identity of the next intended victim is revealed. But when someone close to him disappears, Gilchrist knows he is too late. Together with Nance Wilson, the sexy DC with her own agenda, Gilchrist comes to see the answer to the present murders lies within the secrets of his past.
Forced to confront his demons, Gilchrist must solve the cryptic clues and find the murderer before the next victim, a woman whose life means more to Gilchrist than his own, is served up to him piece by slaughtered piece. Frank Muir was born in Glasgow and has been plagued from a young age with the urge to see the rest of the world Twenty-five years of working overseas helped him appreciate the raw beauty of his home country. Frank is now a dual US/UK citizen, living in Lenzie and working in the US.
His first novel Eye for an Eye was chosen by Louise Welsh as the winner of the Pitlochry Award for the best crime story by an unpublished author in 2004.
©2012 T. F. Muir (P)2013 Audible Ltd
There are no listener reviews for this title yet.
"Well balanced and gripping book"
I just couldn't stop listening! The plot unravels with all the usual twists and turns, not quite sure who the final culprit is. Great story line brilliant characters and all the usual demands on on DI Gilchrist. You can almost feel the sense of panic in the story and I found myself wanting Andy to win through!
Well narrated which adds to the overall feel of the book.
Go on buy it – you will not be disappointed!
"So much gore"
The story was well told. I enjoyed the narrator better than the narrative which, for me had too much explicit detail, both of brutal happenings and sexual scenes - is Andy Gilchrist the "James Bond" of the Fife Constabulary?. However, if I gloss over those things, or if you like them, this was a good story, though I am not sure it lives up to the rave reviews I have seen to date. I will listen to the next one in the series as I feel that, all things considered, it could get better and I like Scottish detectives and Scotland.
"Great story, well read"
I discovered T.F Muir through Audible and have only listened to the audiobook versions of his novels.
I enjoyed the first one, An Eye for an Eye, and was not disappointed by the sequel. DI Gilchrist is deepening as a character and the relationship with his children and ex-wife is explored in more depth in this novel.
David Monteath gave an excellent performance, reading with great interpretation and believable accents.
It's just as well that audiobooks are portable as I found myself listening at all available opportunities - while in the car, walking the dog, cooking etc.
I don't think you need to have read/listened to the first one before getting this one as the stories are entirely separate and this doesn't refer in any way to the first book. I'll certainly be getting the next one.
"Another Gem of a Crime Thriller Series"
This is a gritty and well read series of thrillers set in St Andrews in the Kingdom of Fife. I managed The Russacks Hotel up there for just over a year and these thrillers bring back a number of memories. The stories are well written and have you on the edge of your seat at times. Twists and turns galore, you cannot help but get embroiled in the main character DCI Gilchrist and his oddball team and I am so glad I gave the series a try. I have now listened to the first 2 books and have just downloaded the 3rd. I am hooked !
"Great gripping yarn"
Gripping gruesome great
Really felt for protagonist as solving the mystery became personal
In the Robison visiting suspect and psychological stand offs
Had listened to eye for eye and enjoyed that so made sense to listens to this too and not disappointed
"Hand for a Hand"
Enjoyed this book even more than the 1st in the series.
So glad to have discovered T F Muir. The main character DCI Gilchrist is very believable and his relationship to his family is woven into the story very well.
"Sound Scottish Crime Fiction"
This is the second book in the series about DCI Andy Gilchrist set in and around St Andrews in Scotland. Being familiar with the area was one of my reasons for picking this series back up again, and I'm glad I did. I enjoyed it more than the first one. The characters are better developed, and we are getting to know Andy and members of his family more thoroughly. It's quite an intricate police procedural with some rather gruesome parts. The audiobook was narrated perfectly by David Monteith. I will definitely continue with the series.
Recommended for anybody who likes brooding British detectives who are brilliant at their jobs but deficient in their private lives.
"Keeps you guessing"
Good narration, gripping storyline and based in Scotland so it's all good!
Helps the journey go quickly as I listen in the car.
I really enjoyed the last book in the series but this has somewhat deterred me from listening to another.
Michael Ridpath - Where the Shadows Lie
Always a convincing performance
Not after listening to this
A promising opening but, possibly due to poor editing, rambling and directionless towards the end. Rather than building to a tense ending this caused me to lose interest.
Another brilliant book written and fantastically narrated. It kept me on the edge of my seat right until the very last chapter. Looking forward to reading the next in the series.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.