The first of the classic mysteries featuring governess-turned-detective Miss Silver, who investigates a deadly conspiratorial ring.
Charles Moray has come home to England to collect his inheritance. After four years wandering the jungles of India and South America, the hardy young man returns to the manor of his birth, where generations of Morays have lived and died. Strangely, he finds the house unlocked, and sees a light on in one of its abandoned rooms. Eavesdropping, he learns of a conspiracy to commit a fearsome crime.
Never one for the heroic, Charles’ first instinct is to let the police settle it. But then he hears her voice. Margaret, his long-lost love, is part of the gang. To unravel their diabolical plot, he contacts Miss Silver, a onetime governess who applies her reason to solve crimes and face the dangers of London’s underworld.
©1929 Patricia Wentworth (P)2007 Isis Publishing Ltd.
I thought that Miss Silver was going to be a pivotal part of the plot but she barely plays into it. The story was engaging and the narrator, excellent but for me, the focus should have been more on Miss Silver and her sleuthing.
The story was so good. I didn't want to put it down.
She kept me guessing until the very end.
I would give away a surprise but the best scene is near the end.
If you can only read one of Ms. Wentworth's books, which is a very sad predicament indeed, but if only one, read this one. Her books are all on a high level of story, characters and flow. Someone who can write so many great mysteries of this type is amazing. Not since Christie herself I shouldn't wonder.
I like this story and it's twists and turns. Unfortunately, I had to restart it 3 times before I could follow the beginning.
OCD over books, listening to 1 a day; ANY genre, fact & fiction. Influenced by Audible reviewers so I keep mine unbiased - FRONT to BLACK!
I tried 2 more by Wentworth and found all three books to be the same story, just different names. Narrator Diana Bishop is superb.
In this first book, I was mildly surprised. But that's because if you pay attention, each most viable suspect - the poor relation, the jealous lover or competition, the disgruntled retainer - are all eliminated, one by one, until the LEAST LIKELY person is left standing. By the third book, I figured it out right away.
Probably not. Mrs. Silver is not as well-developed as a Miss Marple or Hercule Poirot. She's just not very interesting enough to carry a feature film. Maybe a television series.....
There's nothing overall wrong with this series. Just don't fall for the description "like Agatha Christie" as I did. Because Wentworth is not even close. These books are good for their era and as long as you wait 6 months between each in the series. I can read Agatha Christie books one after another, even a second and third time each, and still not figure out the plots. I was looking forward to listening to all of this series. However three is enough for me!
Grey Mask is not like any of the later Miss Silver mysteries. It's the very first (1929) and is complex and implausible to a degree that isn't forgiven in modern thrillers, but obviously was taken in stride in the '20s. Like another reviewer here, I had to start over to figure out what was going on. Unlike a different reviewer, I don't think Miss Silver was "barely there" --- she came in late, as always, after substantial character development early on, and if anything she had a more active, physical role than in any of the other twelve or so of these I've listened to --- she tracked people on the street, she searched a house! Well, she was younger then.
Remember that Miss Marple is not the model for Miss Silver: it was the other way around. Miss Silver was published first, and pretty annoyed Patricia Wentworth was about the "homage" Agatha Christie paid her. Killer character idea, though, as we can clearly see from the fact that both authors succeeded and are still popular, and many are their descendants, informal female detectives right down to the cozies of present time.
Grey Mask is well worth listening to for anyone who follows these easy-listen mysteries, to see how much more sensible Wentworth's plots became, and how much more charmingly predictable and knitterly Miss Silver became. And because ---------- however absurd the plot, it's GOT something. The story has life, you like the characters, you want to know what happens. Miss Silver has staged a revival and that's a good thing for those of us who want a little relaxation reading about an old friend we know well.
I loved that Charles tried to save everybody without giving up his true love. However I wish Ms. Silver played a more prominent role in the book. It was great to go back in time when women were dainty and men are gentlemen.
Well read; decent period touches. I was disappointed that Miss Silver, the soft-spoken sleuth, is not much in evidence. She is on the job but off stage much of the time.
I would recommend this book to my friends who value charming wordplay and a happy ending over a credible plot.
The plot reminded me of the books by Sapper (fun, but highly unlikely) and some of the wordplay was almost as good as Wodehouse and made me laugh out loud.
Diana Bishop was a new narrator for me and I thought she did an excellent job.
Yes, I could have listened to it in one sitting without getting bored.
I look forward to listening to more of the Miss Silver books.
Miss Silver is apparently Miss Marple taken out of her village and forced to make a living, but there wasn't enough revealed about her to know for sure. However, like Miss Marple, she is able to maintain an unerring penetration of understanding while busily knitting. Also I found the other characters to be either relatively unsympathetic or downright irritating. It isn't a good sign when one winds up wishing the death-threat would actually succeed! I think part of my reaction is owing to the talent of Ms. Bishop in bringing to life a character who talks non-stop drivel. I expect the character was supposed to be charming, but I just wanted the bad guys to cart her off so I wouldn't have to listen to her any more. The mystery itself reminded me of Saturday afternoon matinee movies popular in the 40s and 50s: a rather overwrought idea presented in predictable plot-points and played out on stock sets with uninspired dialog. I couldn't help visualizing the whole thing in black and white.
I love to read and I love to listen to good books! Because I can listen while I walk, its great for both my health and the health of my dog Rubi.
The Narrator. It just sounded wrong. Really wrong. Far to dull and she made the characters seem really insipid. Maybe they were written that way, I don't know I havn't read this particular book but really.... Really??
I enjoy reading Patricia Wentworth's books. Ok she is no Agatha Christie but her books are classic, enjoyable, nice-polite-murder-mysteries. A genre I love. However...I would not try another one read by Diana Bishop.
Perhaps she just does not like nice-polite-murder-mysteries. Maybe she was bored. She sounded bored. And ancient. And underpaid.
No. I will probably delete it from my library. Mind you, to be fair, it is the first of the series and many series start of with a slightly shaky start and grow to be worth having.
Report Inappropriate Content