The devastating Phryne Fisher is under fire again in her fourth mystery.
A very young man with muddied hair, a pierced ear and a blue tattoo lies cradled in Phryne's arms. But sadly, it's not another scene of glorious seduction - this time it's death. The Honourable Miss Phryne Fisher, beautifully dressed in loose trousers, a cream silk shirt and a red-fox fur has just had her windscreen shot out inches in front of her divine nose. But worse is the fate of the pale young man lying on the road, his body hit by bullets, who draws his final blood-filled breath with Phryne at his side. Outraged by this brutal slaughter, Phryne promises to find out who is responsible. But Phryne doesn't yet know how deeply into the mire she'll have to go: bank robbery, tattoo parlours, pubs, spiritualist halls, and the Anarchists. Along this path, Phryne meets Peter, a battle-scarred, sexy Slav, who offers much more to her than just information. But all thoughts of these delights flee from Phryne's mind when her beloved maid, Dot, disappears. There's nothing Phryne won't do to get her back safely.
Solve another case with Phryne Fisher.
©1992 Kerry Greenwood (P)2010 Bolinda Publishing Pty Ltd
"Those who like their heroines resourceful and their mystery plots leavened with humor will read this with pleasure." (Publishers Weekly)
" A fresh time period and location, a feisty main character, and a well-developed sense of place distinguish this historical mystery series." (Booklist)
Mystery reader (especially series) and Austen lover
When I first discovered the Phryne Fisher Mysteries, I loved the carefree and lighthearted atmosphere created by the author, Kerry Greenwood, and the narrator, Stephanie Daniel.
Death at Victoria Dock opens with Phryne's windshield shattering from gunfire, and her discovery of a wounded young man who dies in her arms. This beginning signals a Phryne Fisher adventure which is not so lighthearted as the rest.
In trying to solve the murder of the young man, Phryne becomes involved with Latvian anarchists (who apparently really were active in 1920's Australia), some of whom kidnap her secretary Dot. She takes an anarchist known as Peter Smith for her lover, and opposes the actions of the other anarchists, leading a plan which thwarts a planned bank robbery by the Latvians.
In the meantime, Phryne has taken on an investigation into the disappearance of a 14-year-old girl who is assumed by her father to have run away. The girl is in school with Phryne's adopted daughters, so they help with the investigation, which uncovers some unsavory goings-on within the girl's family. Needless to say, Phryne solves the mystery and recovers the girl.
All this is accomplished by Phryne with her usual aplomb, but not quite with the same elan as usual. I think this is probably because of the more serious crimes being dealt with. Even at a slightly less lighthearted level, this tale is fun and enjoyable, and even teaches a bit about Australian history. Stephanie Daniel does her customary extraordinary job of narration, giving life to Phryne, Dot, the girls, Bert and Cec, and all the other characters.
In addition, like the other Phryne Fisher audible books, there is the added bonus of a conversation between the author and the narrator, usually talking about where Greenwood got her ideas for the plot of that particular book, and the historical basis for those ideas.
Once again, I highly recommend the Phryne Fisher books to those who like a mystery which is lighthearted, not too violent, and not too graphic in the lovemaiking department.
I'm a Huge Phryne Fisher fan, and I have read all of the Phryne Fisher books that Audible doesn't have yet. And, I loved this one! It is one of the stories that shows the author's skill in her ability to draw the very complex main character of Phryne Fisher, as well as all of the wonderful secondary characters. Also, as usual, the reader is wonderful. Kerry Greenwood & Stephanie Daniel are a great combination!
Love books! Classics and lighter fiction, mysteries (not too violent please :-). And selective non-fiction--whatever takes my fancy.
Phryne is back--maybe better to say, Stephanie Daniel, the narrator who IS Phryne to those of us who listen to these delightful books--returns to her adoring listeners (of whom I count myself one for sure!)
Here Phryne is working a double mystery. One comes about because she is present when a young man has been shot, she holds him in her arms as he dies, and thereafter intends to avenge his murder. (Partly because he was so "young and pretty.") And when Phryne intends something--she does it. This is really the main story in the book--the one with all the action, but there is a secondary mystery as well--this one involving a young girl who has gone missing. A quieter part of the story, but very touching, and a way to bring in the assistance of Phryne's two adopted girls.
The thing about these narrated productions is the quality of them from beginning to end. They include wonderful 20's style music, some of the best narration of any series I know, and a general sense of fun and engagement, despite there is a serious story going on. Phryne can be serious--but she alternates all her work with a lifestye that is so glamorous and romantic, that it tends to help the whole story keep a light tone.
One tiny remark--and this is my pet peeve about many series, where the author reveals things that have occurred in past books--it happened again here. Suggest you read these from the beginning--even though, if you really don't care about that, this will stand on it's own just fine. Wish there were more stars to give to Stephanie Daniel, who just "is" Phryne Fisher to me. Highly recommend for a great listen!
I like the series, but didn't care for the reader, specifically the way she choose to read male voices. I'll get the others as ebooks or hard copy. pity.
Just when you think you know how it will all end another angle enters the story. Mystery is there, Phryne's individual style is paramount to the story. Excellent!
"Excellent as usual"
I always enjoy mysteries about this particular lady. She makes me laugh, makes me want to thump the nasties. A thoroughly good plot very well read as always.
"An Australian accent is NOT cockney"
I like the Phryne Fisher books.
No Australian book narrated by this woman.
She was awful. Truly dreadful. She has NO idea of an Australian accent. It is not cockney or any of the London or British regional accents. Phryne may have an RP English accent but not the other characters. It totally ruined the whole book... To the point I haven't even finished listening. If I could find this book on kindle I would return it.
Intense irritation at the choice of narrator.
I have no idea who chose this narrator but it was a very poor choice. As a reader I'm sure she is fine - but for an English book. I hate hate hate her portrayal of the Australian characters - which in the books have been stated as having Australian accents. As I said, it has totally destroyed this audiobook.
"A little dull."
I love the Phryne Fisher series, but this wasn't up to the usual standard. The story didn't really grab me and the authors need to have more than one storyline going on at once made it all feel a little rushed. The ending almost felt like an afterthought. The narration was great as always.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.