After writing 16 Inspector Lynley novels, New York Times best-selling author Elizabeth George has millions of fans waiting for the next one. As USA Today put it, "It's tough to resist George's storytelling, once hooked." With Believing the Lie, she's poised to hook countless more.
Inspector Thomas Lynley is mystified when he's sent undercover to investigate the death of Ian Cresswell at the request of the man's uncle, the wealthy and influential Bernard Fairclough. The death has been ruled an accidental drowning, and nothing on the surface indicates otherwise. But when Lynley enlists the help of his friends Simon and Deborah St. James, the trio's digging soon reveals that the Fairclough clan is awash in secrets, lies, and motives.
Deborah's investigation of the prime suspect - Bernard's prodigal son Nicholas, a recovering drug addict - leads her to Nicholas's wife, a woman with whom she feels a kinship, a woman as fiercely protective as she is beautiful. Lynley and Simon delve for information from the rest of the family, including the victim's bitter ex-wife and the man he left her for, and Bernard himself. As the investigation escalates, the Fairclough family's veneer cracks, with deception and self-delusion threatening to destroy everyone from the Fairclough patriarch to Tim, the troubled son Ian left behind.
Crack another case with Inspector Lynley.
©2012 Elizabeth George (P)2012 Penguin
I really wanted to love this book. All of my favourite characters were back - Lynley, Simon, Deborah, Barbara - and there were many twists and turns, plots and counter-plots - usually something that I enjoy. But there were too many stories within the story, making the writing seem a little forced. Many of the characters were simply unlikeable, including, at some points, the grieving Lynley. Deborah St. James was particularly unsympathetic in this book - dishonest and foolish - something I was somewhat sad to see. People aren't perfect but I prefer even flawed heroes/heroines to remain noble. There were some story lines that had real "heart" (like the one involving Freddy and Minette); others that were torn from the headlines with, I felt, the desire to shock but which only felt empty to me. I remain a fan of Ms George and sincerely hope that she will pick up the plot points delivered in the very last paragraph of Believing the Lie in her next book. I care about what happens next....
I would only buy an earlier work of Elizabeth George - I'm afraid this indicates a downhill trajectory.
I'm looking for another mystery.
The narration matched the characters quite nicely, either strong or simpering. It made the entertwined stories easier to follow.
I was quite disappointed and afraid this shows the author is losing touch with reality. The original premise doesn't make sense, and sends the main characters to a place improbably full of people with every kind of sexual secret. The gay men are all liars, cheaters or pedophiles, and the author works in way too many homophobic slurs and weird sexual connections. The main characters have lost all depth except self absorption. This is my last George book.
Bit too long
The gender twist
Excellent differentiation between genders and ages - fantastic job
I adore Elizabeth George, so I couldn't wait to get this. It is good, but once the mystery was solved, I had a hard time listening to all the loose ends getting wrapped up. Some of it them were too cheesy for me. I want more Havers, Lindley and murder!
OCD over books, listening to 1 a day; ANY genre, fact & fiction. Influenced by Audible reviewers so I keep mine unbiased - FRONT to BLACK!
It is just too long and too confusing. Elizabeth George is one of my favorite authors but this book feels like a mish-mash of short stories written by rookie writer wannabes compiled into a 23 hour painful mess!
I've read or listened to many of George's prior books in the Inspector Lynley series and loved them, except for #16 "This Body of Death". It wasn't as good as its predecessors but it was no where as bad as THIS one!!!!
Davina Porter is the reason that I decided to give George another chance. But she has nothing to work with here. Porter is great with different characters, sexes, dialects and accents. However, there are so many characters in this book - most of them forgettable - that Ms. Porter didn't stand a chance of delivering her usual masterful performances. By hour 10, everyone begins to sound alike.
MAJOR DISAPPOINTMENT! Followed by acute narcolepsy! I turned on this book last night, without utilizing the sleep timer. I immediately fell into a deep sleep and slept for 10 hours straight until my phone battery went dead. I suffer from chronic insomnia and normally take a sedative to get 3-4 hours of sleep. But, thanks to this awful book, I may be able to flush my meds down the toilet!
After missing out on 10 hours of this book while sleeping, when I went back to the book, I felt as if I hadn't missed a thing! I was already confused over the multiple weak story lines and a kazillion uninteresting characters BEFORE sleeping through almost half of this book. The main character, Inspector Lynley, gets totally lost in this offering. It is just too long! I don't think Elizabeth George could stand listening to this hot mess.
I normally buy my audiobooks based on the reviews of Audible members. Unfortunately, I failed to read the reviews here. I bought this book because I'd just finished a great 4 book series narrated by Davina Porter, along with the author's reputation. I should have read and heeded the reviews. .
I love Davina Porter as a narrator and I used to eagerly look forward to Elizabeth George's novels, but this last outing angered me even more than the last. Her treatment of every single non-heterosexual character in this installment was appalling and frankly unforgivable.
She could have eliminated extraneous, whiny and cliched characters to deliver a story with more depth and resonance. Tightening up of the narrative could have also done wonders.
There will surely be a follow up, but I'm staying clear.
If "typical" is the Elizabeth George of the early 2000's, then this is yet another digression, or actually a series of digressions packaged into a novel. After dropping Elizabeth George while trying to wade through one of the several books that came between "A Traitor to Memory" and the present day, I was eager to try her again. However, I was again disappointed with the byzantine story arcs, the wealth of unnecessary detail, and the protracted scene development. I also had to ask, when in the middle of a particularly overdone scene, how important is this to the main story? And is there a "main" story? This novel seems to have the curious paradox of elaborate backstories on the one hand, combined with not enough detail on the other.
I would not recommend this - simply because the reader receives not nearly enough benefit compared to the effort involved. Technically, George is masterful, and manages abundant detail and descriptive passages with grace and expertise. However, she leads the reader into one disenchanted forest after another, which cannot be seen for the trees.
Davina Porter's narration is excellent, as usual. Her characterizations are relatable, precise, and the reader always knows who is speaking. But she's not enough to give this book the boost it needs to stay on track.
One of the best I've heard.
The story kept me listening all weekend. The long story with intricate plot lines are riveting. You never know if Elizabeth is going to save someone or not and it keeps you wondering and worrying. She has no favorites in age, gender, etc.
Tim's problems are so devastating.
I'm a huge fan of Elizabeth George and have read all her books. My first listening experience of her books was
Yes. As I said although this was not her best, she's a wonderful writer and not every book can be a masterpiece.
Great accents, captured the personalities of the key characters well.
I would recommend this book to someone who is already familiar with Inspector Lynley books or with the BBC TV series. Otherwise, by the time the listener knows all the characters, he/she will be finished with the book. The plot is twisted; it does keep your interest, but the book's climax was disappointing (Is that giving too much away?)
Freddie was my favorite character. He just seemed to always know what to do, although he never made a show of it.
Great reader. Distinguished her voice for each and every character and I don't know how!
I wanted to strangle some characters - actually, almost all of them!
It was just what I would expect from Elizabeth George - delectable. Wonderful, complex characters you've come to know and love. Intriguing multiple storylines. (Audible, PLEASE offer more of this author's UNABRIDGED past works.) And Davina Porter's narration, as always, is perfect.
Report Inappropriate Content