A guest at the hotel, Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, suddenly finds himself in the middle of a murder enquiry, and the hotel is full of possible suspects.
Listen to another Three Pines mystery.
©2008 Louise Penny; (P)2009 Blackstone Audio, Inc.
"[I]ntriguing, well-crafted....Seamless, often lyrical prose artfully reveals the characters' flaws, dreams and blessings." (Publishers Weekly)
This is my first book by this author and narrator. At first thought it was very slow with the murder not taking place until almost 8 or 9 chapters into the book. Then thought there was way too much detail about unrelated snippets. But in reality there is little excess in the story as themes are woven together through three story lines that intersect. The poetry which is a mainstay of the Inspector's life view adds deep flavor to the themes and the narrator's reading is wonderfully paced and nuanced.
My heart hurt for the rich but dysfunctional family at the center of the murder, but I was truly sad to find out the murderer and the reasoning. Ultimately a riveting audio book.
I am a college professor and professional actor, director and playwright. The peformance of the book is as important to me as the writing.
Love Louise Penny's writing. She creates a great series of characters, with wry and funny details, she also puts together a compelling mystery. This particular story is set in a wonderful location ripe for a bizarre group of people to become intertwined and is most satisfying. Inspector Gamache is one of the best characters in literature- his realtionship with his wife is so lovely and heartening. This is the third book in the series and is by far the best so far. I highly recommend it. And all the Canadian French details and food descriptions are charming as well.
The world of inspector ganache enfolds and entrances the reader with characters fun to know and confidence that, except for the murder victims, everything will
be ok in the end and the journey will be entertaining and piquant.
I loved both print and audio. The advantage of audio for me is that I tend to read too quickly to catch every important detail, and audio gives me the opportunity to hear what I sped past on my way to the conclusion. I own both print and audio.
Still Live (Louise Penny's first)--both are excellent.
Retired "Okie" librarian & happy to have found Audible for good stories & staying in touch with new authors & books.
So far all of Penny's books that I have read/listened to have ranked in my top 10%! I've reviewed her books before & am trying to pace myself, saving and savoring each as long as I can.
P D James' books come to mind. Both authors are favorites and don't disappoint. Of course the comparison with the classic writers Agatha Christie and Nagio Marsh is possible. Classic & classy Penny's books surely are.
Cosham is chief inspector Gramache. His voice is perfect for Gramache and the other characters, male & female.
I learn something with all of the Penny books. I love how she ties in the plot and the titles and how the characters grow and flesh-out in a smooth and inconspicuous fashion. This is less a mystery in Three Pines than one with some characters we met in the Canadian village of Three Pines. Give yourself a present of a Louise Penny mystery.
I'm an avid listener. Audio books are a mini-vacation for me. They fill my "need to read" when I don't have time - which is most of the time. Great element of multi-tasking!
This volume of the 3 PINES series doesn't take place in 3 pines, except for a couple of scenes, which adds a bit of newness to the undertaking. Rather than serving as a catalyst, Inspector Gamache and his family are central figures. (Saying more will give important discoveries away.) Another family is the primary focus - their history, their current relationships based on the past, and how their childhoods influence their adult behavior. Much more of a psychological profile of life and death than is usual in these books, but Penny is able to add grit while maintaining much of the humor and coziness this series is known for.
A classic detective mystery lover. Especially mysteries taking place in quaint English villages!
If you love this series you will want to listen to this one but in my opinion it isn't as good as the first stories.
The secluded mountain resort setting and back story is interesting and so is the premise for the murder but frankly it seemed like we were half way through the book before anything happened. Really. Nothing happened. The author seemed fixated on describing the affluent messed up family from every way possible. Over and over. And over.
It was really slow moving compared to the others in the series.
He is a joy to listen to. Ralph I love ya.
I love books!
Book #4 in the Chief Inspector Armand Gamache series. This one was set at a remote resort on a lake somewhere around Montreal. Like all of the earlier books in the series, while you are experiencing the book there seem to be 4-5 characters that you honestly believe could have committed the murder. But the Chief Inspector methodically works through the clues in figuring it all out. In this story there was a very wealthy but dysfunctional family staying at the resort at the same time as Gamache and his wife, so he's there when the murder happens and the whole story takes place right there. One of Louise Penny's strengths, along with her great character development, is her insight into human nature. There is one particular quote in this book that struck a chord with me and is central to the book's theme. For someone who has suffered a loss it is "lament what you've lost but be happy for what you have". I'll look forward to #5!
Myst/thrillers, some contemporary and ✨fun fantasies✨are my favorites but always open for a good story.
Another hit from Louise Penny, she is so clever and masterful at spinning a great tale. I love how she layers her stories, close attention must be payed or the underlying wit may be missed. She has a wonderful knack of illustrating the perfect blend of seriousness and humor.
This addition to the series starts with Inspector Gamache away on holiday with his lovely wife. Unfortunately it turns into a working one when there is an unexpected death of one of the guests. Accident or not? All the of the guests staying at the resort, including the deceased party, have come for a family reunion. Unbeknownst to the Gamaches, some dear friends from, Three Pines, arrive and as it turns out have come for the reunion as well. They are happy to see them until chaos ensues, accusations fly, and pandemonium breaks out surrounding the suspicious death.
The patients have escaped and are running the asylum, is all I could think when it came to this family. Inspector Gamache has his hands full, very full. A good mystery and, to me, this one was more Agatha Christy-esc than her prior books. Ralph Coshams narration is consistently A+ great. It always feels like coming home when I start a Gamache adventure. Onto the next.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.