From the author of the classic mysteries starring the irrepressible CIA spy, Mrs. Pollifax, comes a delightfully different mystery with a most unholy twist. Filled with all the hilarious surprises and good old-fashioned suspense that her fans have come to love, A Nun in the Closet is the story of two high-spirited nuns who accidentally stumble into a dangerous plot involving ghosts, gangsters, and Protestants.
©1975 Dorothy Gilman Butters (P)1995 Recorded Books
Science writer in America's heartland
This fun book is set amidst the counter-culture of the 70s, seen through the eyes of two nuns who have been locked away in cloister for years, only to find themselves confronting the world of hippies, drugs, and gangsters when they leave the convent for a trip to upstate New York. The story has a sense of innocence about it that reminded me of the 1959 movie "Some Like It Hot."
The audio edition enhanced the print version - I love Dorothy Gilman novels so I am partial to print first and audio second. I think though that I laughed a bit more with the audio version of A Nun in the Closet,
Anyone familiar with the Mrs. Pollifax series will know what to expect here, but if you aren't, you are in for a treat. One reviewer found it dated because it was set in the 1970's; but not enjoying anything written about an era other than the present seems ridiculous to me. It is charming, not especially deep, and lively. I recommend it for a refreshing change of pace from sex, violence, horror. Sweet, but not saccharin, and not a kids' book.
I haven't listened to many yet, but narration was good and well paced and I enjoyed the book
The plot moved along well and I was very curious to find out their mysterious
I think she did a great job conveying each character
I love Dorothy Gilman books and thoroughly enjoyed this one. The ending seemed to lose a little pace, and I'm not sure why I felt that way. Era it was written or maybe something else I can't put my finger on but didn't take away from the story and left me wishing for a sequel with the Sisters and their friends!
I love Dorothy Gilman's books. She is so imaginative with her storyline and characters. This is no exception!! You will get so caught up in the story, you want want to put it down!! Enjoy!!
A 50-something who loves sci-fi, cozy mysteries, thrillers, an occasional romance, and any genre if it is a good story. And especially if it makes me laugh! No vampires or zombies though - these are NOT sci-fi!
I love this book! Set in the 70s, it will make people of all generations laugh. Sister John and Sister Hyacinth are so cool. I wish Dorothy Gilman had written more books about them!
I would definitely listen to another book narrated by Roslyn Alexander. Not sure about Dorothy Gilman. I have mixed feelings about her.
I found that the characters were more characterizations than real. The 60's radicals, the gangsters and even the nuns seemed to fit into the mold. In the beginning it was amusing, but by the end it seemed tedious and predictable.
Her ability to make each character unique. It was not difficult to identlfy who was speaking.
It must have been because I did finish it, which I don't if I don't like the story at all so I gave it 3 stars.
The story of two cloistered nuns checking out an inherited property that comes with a dubious past is a delightful story line. It is a fun and light listen and the character development is engaging. The narrator made it sparkle though, with well-defined, colorful characters and a pleasant and imaginative style. She is one of the really great American narrators. I plan to look into other books she has narrated. Good narration makes all the difference.
I would because I so loved her Ms. Polifax series. The narrator did a solid job but she just didn't have much to work with.
No, it just really fell flat as a novel that accomplished much. No suspense, character development was flat, and the story line wasn't interesting at all.
She does use voices for the different characters but the nuns all sound alike.
Honestly both of the nuns were forgettable characters. So much so I can't remember their names.
It just lacks the remarkable characters that her Ms. Polifax books have. Don't give up on this author, her Polifax series is one of my favorites.
A man in nun's clothing. What fun.
Really liked this book. There is something to be said for a mystery without the sex and language that is usually included. I would not hesitate to share this one with my grandmother. It was funny in places. There is something about nuns trying to figure out life that makes for a good book. I only bought this one based on the Mrs. Pollifax books also by Dorthy Gilman. Mrs. Gilman is missed as she had a way with the worlds that she created. Hope you will enjoy this as much as I did.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.