John le Carré's second novel, A Murder of Quality, offers an exquisite, satirical look at an elite private school as it chronicles the early development of George Smiley.
Miss Ailsa Brimley is in a quandary. She's received a peculiar letter from Mrs. Stella Rode, saying that she fears her husband - an assistant master at Carne School - is trying to kill her. Reluctant to go to the police, Miss Brimley calls upon her old wartime colleague, George Smiley. Unfortunately, it's too late. Mrs. Rode has just been murdered. As Smiley takes up the investigation, he realizes that in life - as in espionage—nothing is quite what it appears.
©2012 John le Carre (P)2012 Penguin Audio
I write for myself, for my own pleasure. And I want to be left alone to do it. - Salinger ^(;,;)^
Not le Carré's finest, but that is like saying here a minor Faulkner, a good-effort Chandler or even a throwaway Conrad. 'A Murder of Quality' finds George Smiley out of his element (although to be fair, Smily IS defined by always being just a little out of his element). Instead of in an espionage thriller, he is dropped by le Carré into a boys school murder.
It is as if, with his second novel, le Carré is wondering whether spy fiction or detective fiction should be his future calling. It does make me briefly pause and imagine how the arc of his career might have turned out if le Carré had pursued crime instead of espionage writing.
If you are new to le Carré, don't start with this one. If you love le Carré this will be a short and interesting break from his brilliant espionage œuvre.
Photographer, nature & water geek, music lover, book fiend.
My mother-in-law gave me my first George Smiley/ John LeCarre novel, & he's become one of my favorite authors of all Tim, if not my very favorite. Character developments & story-telling genius are large factors, but it's his lyrical turn of phrase and near-poetic prose that won me over & keep me coming back.
I'd read the bulk of the more spycentric Smiley bibliography before learning of his first two books, "Call for the Dead" & "A Murder of Quality", & so I think I was a little let down on my first reading of " A Murder......", expecting more Cold War intrigue.
Over the last ten years, I've switched to almost exclusively audio book "reading", & consequently listen to three times as many books annually, maybe four. It's so much more convenient, and one can listen to an audiobook during chores, driving, etc. But the other big factor is that a narrator can make or break a book. Thankfully, all of the Smiley works are read by the inestimable Michael Jayston. He's an incredible talent, & also so very very British, which is a must with this series.
Anyway, my point is this: I don't know if it's my approaching this particular book ten years after my first reading (when I'd found it to be my lest favorite of all LeCarre's novels), or life experience, but this time around I found A Murder of Quality to be far more favorable & in depth. And Michael Jayston's impeccable narration of course adds to the experience immensely. I'm happy to have revisited this novel & would highly recommend it.
Smiley is still "retired" apparently from secret service after Call for the Dead but this is a very good murder mystery that stands on it's own. Le Carre is a fine author thus far and I know #3 In from the Cold is genius and one of my favorite novels and so I am on my way to #4 in this series and plan to go on with more Smileys and more JLC in general.
Lean. Logical. Engrossing.
The down-to-earth humaness of all the characters coupled with the well-polished and logical plot.
I love a good book...
George Smiley is a delicious character which captures my attention. It sort of feels a little like Columbo, but the books take me into the past as well. I enjoyed this story which proves that anyone can lie...and they often do.
I was born near Chicago, and moved to Texas 22 years ago. I taught high-school English for probably too many years. Love a good mystery.
This is one of the best mysteries I have read. The writing is excellent and the characters are different. The clues are clear but not obvious.
Had to read in one sitting to discover the murderer.
This is the first time so I cant compare , but I thought he did a good job.
It is a film.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.