When he's found not guilty, Kate and Jim and the rest of Nilniltna, Alaska, are certain that a man has gotten away with murder, and that it's only a matter of time before he tries again. Sure enough, a few weeks later, a woman and her son are shot, the victims of an apparent robbery. But this time, Kate and Jim have a witness, and they're determined that Deem will not get away again. Or will he?
©2007 Dana Stabenow; (P)2007 Books on Tape
"Kate Shugak is becoming a leader among her people and is already a leader in the sorority of women detectives." (Publishers Weekly)
"An engaging plot, the fascinating Native American frame, the well-developed characters, and the vivid depiction of the Alaskan wilderness add up to another strong entry in this consistently satisfying series." (Booklist)
NO!!! She was horrible & cannot pull the characters off the page. I only finished the audible as I was on a long drive & couldn't read the book. She made everyone sound like school girls or cartoon characters none of which fit Dana Stabenows books.
No, if I had realized it was not Margaruite Gavin & listened to a sample when I purchased it I would have read it instead. Bernadette Dunne should not be a narrator.
Love the books but this was painful to listen too. It was my fault for thinking it would be the same narrator as the other books.
The change in narrator this far into the series made it difficult to objectively judge Bernadette Dunne. Margaret Gavin has become the voice of Kate. I stopped listening and thought I was finished with the series but I see that Gavin is back in the next book.
I am a voracious reader (average about 4-5 Audible books a week, in addition to those I "eyeball".) I have been hooked on recorded books since the time of cassettes/CDs and was thrilled when I became an Audible member in 2007. I find reader reviews good guides to spending my credits, so have finally decided to write a few (although, I would rather be reading!)
It must be very difficult for Stabenow to write a bad mystery book, as she doesn't disappoint here. This book is a bit more sombre fare than some of the earlier Kate Shugak stories, perhaps because we get flashbacks to earlier deaths from the point of view of the victims. The setting is the Park, so we get further development of the Park Rats we have come to know through the previous volumes and we become invested in learning the outcome of the events. I recommend reading as many of the previous books as possible to get more out of this story.
Dunne did a good job with the narration; however, those who have become acclimated to Marguerite Gavin's narration of Stabenow's universe (both the Kate Shugak and Liam Campbell series) may be distracted by Dunne's rendition of the voices. I am fan of Dunne's other narrations (particularly of "The Sharing Knife" series), so I wasn't off put by her narration, although it did take an adjustment at the beginning of the book.
Yes. I love the writing.
Vivid detail makes you feel like you know these characters personally. Alaska is as much a character as any of the people. It's fun to see the developing relationships in Kate's life.
She should have listened to at least one of the previous books. She does a mediocre job with the voices and intonation. She's not horrible but the change in narration was continually intrusive throughout the book -not just at the beginning. Not a lot of variation in the voices.
Dana's books always make me laugh and cry.
Yes. Another good book in the series.
All - simply enjoy the series.
Missed M. Gavin as narrator. Dunne is a good narrator, but M. Gavin is THE voice of the Sugak series!
I've been a long time Kate Shugak fan -- this was a hard story line for me because of the treatment of young women. Still not sure how I feel about the ending…
Reading allows me to travel through time; to visit the world's unique and stunning places. To become somebody I am not... It is glorious.
I have no idea why M. Gavin was not back to narrate this installment of the Kate Shaguk story but it was terrible disappointing. If Ms. Dunne had read the previous novels I probably would have like her, but she suffers in comparison. Ms. Gavin is Kate. She is the perfect voice for the strong, loyal Aleut woman we love.
Now, as to the story. This one is not my least favorite. Nor is it in the top favorites either. It is a decent mystery, with a incomprehensible crime. The antagonist was a bit too evil making him a caricature. Bobby remains off the canvas. And there wasn't much story about Alaska either. I found it an average book, and nothing more.
I have read all Kate Shugak series books to 15, I am so sure the story is and would be as great as the others, but the performance took away from any interest I had. The monotone voice was boring, and expressionless changes for different character was very disappointing. I am blind in my left I and 40% in my right, so I depend on the performances, even though I purchase the Kindle book also, just to follow along on my computer. I will not finish this book because of the performance. Very disappointed. I will check who the performers are for the following books in the series before I commit to another purchase.
Not sure - it is SO disorienting to have such a different performance in a long established series like this. The men especially are just, well, not very manly sounding and Johnny, is 15 now and pretty mature for his age and he sounds like and 8-year old! It's not a terrible performance - it's just too different.
When Louis Deem gets shot! Hooray! has anyone "needed killing" more??
No - I'm sure she is fine but it is unfair to judge when she is following someone who is so connected with this series!
I have actually read this before, so I already knew Mutt would be okay but my heart stopped the first time I read it!!! I love Dana Stabenow's books and especially the Kate Shugak books. I wish I could go to her homestead and hang out with her and Mutt :-) She is strong, fierce and independent. She has a strong sense of right and wrong and stands up for what she believes in - a GREAT role model!!
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.