Award-winning author Val McDermid offers up a suspense-filled stand-alone novel with A Darker Domain. Karen Pirie is the newly appointed Deputy Inspector of the Cold Case Unit, and her first investigation takes her 25 years into the past to the national miners’ strike. At the time, a kidnapping gone wrong left a small boy missing, but new evidence suggests he might still be alive. As Pirie delves deeper, she realizes the boy’s disapperance may be linked to another cold case involving a missing miner.
©2008 Val McDermid (P)2008 W.F. Howes, Ltd.
"As Karen’s two cases seem to converge, the complex and layered plotlines come together, and McDermid does an excellent job creating tension around a cold case. Sure to be a hit with McDermid’s large fan base, it should also appeal to those who read other Scottish police mysteries, such as Stuart MacBride’s." (Booklist)
I found this book so boring I just gave up. Many characters were so poorly defined and developed that it was hard to keep the names and backgrounds straight. Very little storytelling--but rather endless police detective interviews. After a while I found I couldn't care less. So much so that when I fell asleep I didn't even want to go back and find the spot where I had dropped off. That's when I knew that I had had enough and needed to return the title. Only recommended for diehard police procedural lovers--those who don't mind being talked at about the story rather than having it played out in action, character behavior and activity. Slow.
The book itself is very good; it centers on a reporter and a British police officer solving a 20 year old killing and kidnapping.
The mysteries aren't particularly mysterious, but the whole story is very engaging and interesting, and the narration is excellent.
I've enjoyed Val's other books, but this one is extremely hard to follow. I kept going back a chapter to figure out who the new character was and how he fits into the story. The main story became too cluttered and the main storyline was often over-shadowed by other crisis, people, etc. I'm sorry to say, I gave up and didn't finish this book.
A rounded, complete mystery set in Scotland, with tentacles in Italy. A little far-fetched, perhaps, with two mysteries coinciding and intertwining, but told well, and read well by Eilidh Fraser. The head of the Cold Case Unit, Karen Pirie, investigates the reopened case of the kidnapping of the son of an important capitalist, but discovers it is connected to the disappearance of a union miner.
The characters and the settings are richly described and the mystery progresses with clarit...moreA rounded, complete mystery set in Scotland, with tentacles in Italy. A little far-fetched, perhaps, with two mysteries coinciding and intertwining, but told well, and read well by Eilidh Fraser. The head of the Cold Case Unit, Karen Pirie, investigates the reopened case of the kidnapping of the son of an important capitalist, but discovers it is connected to the disappearance of a union miner.
The characters and the settings are richly described and the mystery progresses with clarity and increasing depth. The tension between journalist, capitalist, striking union, and police is nicely defined. Family and office internecine conflicts feel agonizingly real and punitive and all are on display.
Disabled Alaskan reader of mostly mysteries historical. Also vampires, werewolves, things that go bump in the night! Some scifi and fantasy!
Val McDermid makes writing mysteries look easy. I loved this book, part of it was because my father was a smelterman and I remember the strikes and my Dad having to try and find work elsewhere, so that his family could eat. He was a union man til the day he died.
Past and present collide in this book. Fife, Scotland 1984, Mick Prentiss leaves during the National Miner's strike thinking he was a strikebreaker, he is despised though he never comes back, leaving his family behind. 23 years later, his daughter reports him missing
Fife, Scotland 1985, Kidnapped heiress Catriona Maclennan Grant is killed and her baby son vanishes when the ransom payoff goes horribly wrong. In 2008, a tourist in Tuscany stumbles upon dramatic new evidence that reopens the investigation.
Already immersed in the Prentice affair, Detective Karen Pirie, newly appointed head of the Cold Case Review Team, wants to make her mark with this second unsolved 1980s mystery. But two decades' worth of secrets are leading Pirie into a dark domain of violence and betrayal, a place darker than any she has previously entered.
Am I the only one who caught it? Otherwise, good up till the last few chapters, with excellent portrayal of the '80s miners' strike. I felt that the author rushed through the last bits and couldn't be bothered to tie up loose ends and missed a major plot hole. The performance was overall okay, with a few overwrought moments.
I can't single out a moment. What I liked was the ingenious, absorbing plot.
It was good over all, but she did have a certain cadence that was not naturally conversational. It didn't bother me so much that I would avoid books she narrates (as I do with Scott Brick or Dick Hill).
The main character is supremely unlikable. We're supposed to root for her, but I'm on the side of her antagonists and superiors who find her smug and obnoxious.
Report Inappropriate Content