This book is a rare act of creative imagination in which the listener will be equally moved by the warm happy village life Will shares with his large family and the nearly overwhelming danger he encounters, often in other centuries and places, while he seeks the Signs and learns their power. Interweaving ancient Celtic and English traditions with the legends of the Buckinghamshire hills and valleys where she grew up, Susan Cooper has written a superlative dramatic fantasy of the eternal conflict between good and evil out of which all myth is made.
Listen to more in the Dark Is Rising Sequence.
©1973 Susan Cooper; (P)2000 Random House, Inc., Listening Library, an imprint of the Random House Audio Publishing Group
"As narrator, Alex Jennings superbly conveys Will's mixed emotions." (AudioFile)
"So perfect is the match between Alex Jennings' voice and this mysterious magical tale that it is difficult to imagine any other voice reading these words." (The Horn Book Magazine)
Well, I have to say I never thought I'd hear Susan Cooper criticized for not creating a believable world, though everyone's tastes are different. I read these books frequently as a child and absolutely adored them. The whole series weaves together a large number of old British folk traditions and legends to form a tight plot fabric. I have no trouble deciphering British accents, so the reader isn't a problem for me either.
Will Stanton was the Harry Potter of MY childhood - a hermetic, pagan, and somewhat fatalistic Harry Potter - but a kid wizard nonetheless.
That being said, this is an extraordinary children's book. If it is unrealistic and predictable, then it is so only to the degree that all children's novels don't pay the same attention to place and plot-twist as some adult novels.
The appeal of this piece to a non-child "Audible" listener should be akin to that of well-done animation and fairy tales. Cooper interweaves somber Celtic myth with modern middle-class life. The effect is enchanting and - at times - unsettling. The accomplished narrator, too, I insist performs a conscientious and careful re-telling of what is, essentially, a dark and pre-adolescent Arthurian legend. Unlike the tales of the other kid sorcerer, Will's story wraps around archetypal imagery and highly abstract themes from the vantage of a sympathizable "everyboy" protagonist. Thus - it does not FEEL like a children's novel - nor at any point will a listener feel condescended to by the novel. It treats its child-audienced readers like adults and with dignity. It does not make itself easily accessible for them as some childrens' books do.
Freud could have a hey-day, carrying on about child-Narcissism and the damaging effects of fantasy writing on childhood development, so I won't recommend it for children anymore than I would Harry Potter. But if you must choose of the two - pick this piece for its 'humanist-responsibility' theme, impressive lexicon, and broad spectrum of emotional imagery. And for adults ... we all like cartoons and crayons - try out this title, which I highly recommend for that exceptionally gifted pre-adolescent in everyone.
I read "The Dark is Rising" for the first time at eleven and absolutely loved it- it pulled me into its world so completely that finishing the story was actually disorienting. I read it again at fourteen and couldn't understand it at all. When I purchased the audio version as an adult I fully expected to be royally confused again, but I just couldn't resist the chance to- maybe- recapture some of the magic I remembered from my first read. It was, in fact, confusing- the timeshifts and the 'logic' of the world were surreal and difficult to wrap my head around... but when I was able to stop *trying* to wrap my head around the story and just let it carry me along, it was almost like I was eleven again. I could feel the wonder and excitement. At least until some more grown up sensibility popped in to my head and spoiled the effect, rather like having the most amazing dream and then realizing that it's just a dream and can't be real. Would I recommend this story to others? Yes. Especially if they happen to be around eleven years old and in that age where they can just let stories happen. For grown-ups I'll just say that the narrator is excellent, the production is crisp and clear, and that if you didn't read this in your youth and love it, you probably won't "get" it.
This series has always been one of my favorites and I've read this book innumerable times. I was hesitant about the audio version, because it can change the way you perceive the book. My only complaint would be that the recitation of the poems/chants wasn't, to my opinion, done very well, but that is a minor complaint. I really enjoyed the addition of the correct accent to the way I've always "heard" the story narrated in my mind.
I'm not blind drunk, I'm just blind.
This is the sequel to Over Sea, Under Stone. Set an indeterminate though presumably relatively brief time after the events of that first tale, this story centers around Will Stanton, who is one day away from his eleventh birthday and several days before Christmas, a chaotic time in his large family. And it's at this time that strange things begin to happen. It started when Will and his elder brother James went to get some hay from a local farmer who gives Will a strange ornament and tells him to wear it always on his belt like an extra buckle. Following a night of troubled sleep and a sudden snowstorm, Will wakes to find a strange landscape outside his window and, after a few encounters with a sinister black rider and a pathetic, frightened tramp, Wil makes his way to a strange set of doors leading into a great hall where a strange woman known simply as the Lady waits with a tall man, Meriman Lyon. These two tell Will that he is the last of the Old Ones, an ancient order of guardians whose purpose is to protect the world from the forces of evil, the Dark, and that this day, Will's birthday, marks the beginning of his quest. Will learns that he must find the six signs of light, one of which, the sign of iron, he already possesses. He learns that the mysterious, frightened vagrant he met earlier possesses the second of the six, but that finding the others will be much more difficult, and the forces of the Dark will stop at nothing to prevent the six from being joined. Can Willl recover the signs before all is lost?
As before British actor Alex Jennings does a standup job of bringing this tale to life. I would, however, recommend that you download the enhanced format version from Audible, as I know that the Format 4version in particular seems to be either damaged, corrupted or in a format that some MP3 players can't play properly. All I know is that it got to a certain point and then stopped, and while I could conceivably have just skipped past that chapter it would have been a shame to skip even just the small part that seemed to be damaged. The enhanced format worked more or less perfectly though, so I got the entire story, which was just as gripping as I remembered it from my teenage years. It's just unfortunate that Hollywood, in their usual fashion, had to totally mangle the story in the 2007 film adaptation, The Seeker. Almost makes me want to become a film director so I could make film adaptations of the entire series that would actually do it justice, particularly in view of the fact that Susan Cooper herself has expressed extreme disappointment with the way The Seeker washandled.
I read this when I was in 6th grade and couldn't put it down! Now I am thrilled to share it with my own children. It keeps us entertained on the way to and from school.
This series was my favorite when I was twelve. As an adult listening to it, I am not quite so entranced anymore. I found it slow this time around, but remember how much I loved it when I was little. This book gives a lot of information that is needed to understand the rest of the series, so it is worth downloading. The entire series was wonderful (my favorite was The Grey King), so I started buying it for my little brother. He is thirteen and seems to like it as much as I once did.
I found it to be dull, boring and a prime example of an authoring failing to 'show and not tell' a story. Expands the myths from the first book by tells a whole new story of kid who discovers he's special and must use his powers to save the world.
Thinking back the concepts, themes and character developments were interested but the story was poorly executed. The first book had interesting children interaction to keep the story interesting which is lacking here.
The author has done a lot of great world building but failed to tell a compelling story in it so far.
I loved the first book in the sequence, but this second book is a completely different genre. Frankly, I wouldn’t have guessed that it was written by the same author. It has far too many just-so scenarios, and too much lying by the main character. I have no idea why this book won the Newbery Honor.
No, I don't think I will.
As with the first book, Alex Jennings does an excellent job. Too bad the story itself wasn’t worth his talents.
Disappointment. Not disgust, but almost.
There are no listener reviews for this title yet.
Report Inappropriate Content