This dazzling story in the Redwall series is packed with wit, wisdom, humor, and blood-curdling adventure, but has the added bonus of taking the listener to the heart and soul of Redwall Abbey and the characters who live there.
©1987 Brian Jacques; (P)2007 Penguin Group USA
"This epic adventure contains elements of all grand quests, with heroic archetypes that will keep fans of Tolkein and King Arthur tales engaged to the final battle." (Publishers Weekly)
Redwall is a great series, and this first book is something our whole family enjoys. I won't go into detail about the story but save my comments for the audio. Stuart Blinder offers up a very good version at a good price. I have listened to the version narrated by the author in its entirety, and it is better, but it's also quite a bit more expensive. Stuart Blinder's version is also a bit easier to understand for those not used to the author's more pronounced local accent (which I find charming). Brian Jacques's "Cluny" voice is far better than Stuart Blinder's, and if you can splurge, go for that version.
Classic story of good over evil, but told in such an entertaining fashion that you just have to smile and cheer: REDWALL! Having said that I have to say that the narrator was not up to par, he takes a great story and makes it boring. I prefer the way Brian Jacques narrates.
If you like evil villains, noble warriors, hilarious accents, and lots of food this is the book for you. (but maybe not the narrator?)
No, I wouldn't, but it is well worth listening too! Brain Jacques has produced such wonderful stories with warm engaging characters. All with believable fantastical situations and incredible world building. All of which are just a little better as you interpret the depth and breadth of his words without interprtation from another.
Mathias who is a great warrior and leader in a diminutive little mouse, he's a wonderful character.
He does a very good job of interpreting a complex endearing tale.
No but that's not to say you don't or that I didn't feel a different array of feelings from this tale
While this is indeed a children's bookit can be appreciated and enjoyed at almost any age
Delightfully entertaining journey
Of course it has to be Mathias.... my new hero
I enjoyed the narration just fine. Since I purchased this rendition, it has come to my attention there is another which is full cast. I have never listened to a full cast narration before, but to continue the series that is the only option. I much prefer journeying through a series, with the same narrator for all books. It is because of that, I probably would have purchased the full cast edition, had I known of it.
I was not aware of this series until a teen told me of it very recently. It is a great discovery and plan on introducing my grandchildren to the wonderful world that is Redwall.
I'm an old goat who loves kid's stuff...like Harry
Potter, Lord of the Rings, books where the writer's
pen becomes, itself, a magic wand, capable of transporting even an old man like me, into a new
and brilliant creation.
This is not one of those books. There is no magic
flowing from the author's word processor. It wasn't poor narration, bad plotting, or grating
style that caused me to stop listening after
several chapters. Pure and simple, this book
must be for very little children at the Peter
Rabbit level of comprehension or it was just
too, too trite. I don't know how an adult could
read it for his or her own pleasure. Reading it
as a bedtime story to a 6 year old, yes. Except
that there's maybe more violence than a 6 year
old needs to be exposed to.
This is a very stock children's tale, with recycled characters and events. Reading this would be preferable to poking one's eye out with a stick if it were a rainy day and the kids had absolutely nothing better to do.
AUDIO: Blinder is pretty overblown and florid.
I thought this would be a delightful read along the lines of Watership Down, or other children's fantasies, but I just couldn't get into it at all. Didn't even finish part 1. Maybe a younger listener would enjoy it more.
Report Inappropriate Content