In 1945, after his capture at the end of the Second World War, Hermann Göring arrived at an American-run detention center in war-torn Luxembourg, accompanied by 16 suitcases and a red hatbox. The suitcases contained all manner of paraphernalia: medals, gems, two cigar cutters, silk underwear, a hot water bottle, and the equivalent of $100,000,000 in cash. Hidden in a coffee can, a set of brass vials housed glass capsules containing a clear liquid and a white precipitate: potassium cyanide. Joining Göring in the detention center were the elite of the captured Nazi regime - Grand Admiral Dönitz, armed forces commander Wilhelm Keitel and his deputy Alfred Jodl, the mentally unstable Robert Ley, the suicidal Hans Frank, the pornographic propagandist Julius Streicher - 52 senior Nazis in all, of whom the dominant figure was Göring.
To ensure that the villainous captives were fit for trial at Nuremberg, the US Army sent an ambitious army psychiatrist, Captain Douglas M. Kelley, to supervise their mental well-being during their detention. Kelley realized he was being offered the professional opportunity of a lifetime: to discover a distinguishing trait among these arch-criminals that would mark them as psychologically different from the rest of humanity. So began a remarkable relationship between Kelley and his captors, told here for the first time with unique access to Kelley’s long-hidden papers and medical records.
Kelley’s was a hazardous quest, dangerous because against all his expectations he began to appreciate and understand some of the Nazi captives, none more so than the former Reichsmarshall, Hermann Göring. Evil had its charms.
©2013 Jack El-Hai (P)2013 Blackstone Audio
College English professor who loves classic literature, psychology, neurology and hates pop trash like Twilight and Fifty Shades of Grey.
leveled at this brilliant narrative concerning unnecessary length and lack of structure. As to the first, I wanted more, not less! I found the book remarkably compelling. As to the second, a stirring and intriguing story should not read like a sixth grade history book, but rather something like a novel. El-Hai accomplishes this wonderfully well here, weaving in and out of plot-lines, developing characters richly and fully along the way. This historical narrative is not nearly so much about Goering--or Kelley--as it is about those incredible accidental meetings of personalities and circumstances at the most telling times in history and how much of what becomes cultural consciousness is developed in dark rooms under conditions and by people of which most remain forever unaware. El-Hai's book is a mystery and suspense tale, told as though Poe or Hawthorne had penned an historical drama. It comes highly recommended from these quarters, especially for anyone who prefers a literary turn put to what would otherwise be dry classroom facts.
The world's fastest fatman specialising in reviewing new and or unreviewed zombie titles see more at audiblereviews dot org
Amazing story, should be compulsive reading in all high schools. Do yourself a favor download this one and listen carefully. We must never allow this history to repeat.
I had just finished listening to Ian Kershaw’s The End: Hitler's Germany, 1944-45 which documented how the Germans continued to do evil even when the end was near. This book takes that question one step further and attempts to answer the 'why'.
I can highly recommend this book! I suggest you also listen to it at the same time as Ian Kershaw’s work (mentioned above)
There has also been some comment regarding the narration on this title. Please don’t let that turn you off. I found the narration good. A couple of times it sounded like German names were edited in later. But it was nothing to drastic. It can easily be listened to at 1.25x speed without any problems.
I couldn’t put this one down and listened to it one day!
I very much enjoyed this book. It was very captivating and well-written. A must-read for folks interested in learning more about the Nazi leadership, and their motivations.
The story was really a new look at the head nazis.
Goering and Hesse in jail and how they reacted.
I didnt really like it. He almost sounded like he was drunk. too slow and labored
No. Once was enough
I guess Kelly
This was a good look at the sick minds of the Nazi criminals. Narration was great.
Painter, musician, bibliophile...
This book might have been a riveting story, but it lacks essential editing and direction. Additionally, the research on Göring is slapdash and many errors made it through to publication, which is unfortunate.
I've read many biographies of Göring in English, German, and Swedish, and recently, Kersaudy's biography in French. These range from those written at the time of his ascendancy in Germany to those of recent days. Without a doubt, he is the most compelling figure in the Nazi regime and remains something of an enigma. In fact, the more I read, the more I want to know who the real Göring is. As this book says, he exists somewhere "between the admirable and the sinister."
I believe El-Hai sees Göring's relationship to his first wife incorrectly. This is important because of the profound effect she had on the direction of his life. Carin von Fock-Kantzow was not, as he says "a glamorous blonde singer," but the non-working wife of a Swedish Army captain. When Göring met her in 1920, he was an unsettled veteran pilot looking to make his way in the world. Her ambition for him was immense, and as many writers have said, she was as vehement a Nazi as ever there was. Even on her deathbed she pushed Göring to return to Germany because Hitler needed him. Without her ambition, support, and help, it is highly unlikely Göring would have been as successful as he was. El-Hai, on the other hand, glosses over the effect she had on his life, and as the only woman Göring ever allowed to influence him and his decision taking, that is a critical misunderstanding.
Furthermore, there is little if any mention of the profound personality changes that can and do take place after extended periods of opiate abuse. Megalomania is the most extreme result. If one takes an already over-confident, not to say conceited, personality such as
Göring had, the exacerbation of these tendencies shouldn't be glossed over.
The section on Nuremberg provides nothing new, and may be tedious to those who have read a great deal about it already. For those who haven't, it may be of some interest.
I could go on and on, but suffice to say, those familiar with Göring's life will find many errors and laborings under misapprehension. I believe all of these would have been put to right if deeper research had been done.
As for Kelley, I knew nothing of him. He is certainly an unforgettable, somewhat bizarre, character. However, El-Hai seems to be making a case that the way in which Kelley committed suicide was directly related to his interactions with Göring at Nuremberg. In my opinion, he fails to make his case. Psychiatrists do have an unusually high, and perhaps understandable, rate of suicide. I felt very sorry for Kelley's family and what they endured. Clearly Kelley was deeply troubled and it is tragic that he could not find the help he needed before it was too late.
Overall, I would not recommend this book. El-Hai can certainly write, but I think this book was rushed. If he took the time to deeply research his subject, I think his work could be stunning. On the other hand, three of us read it and we all disagreed about what we thought. So that means the work has some level of vitality. You decide for yourself.
Reading allows me to travel through time; to visit the world's unique and stunning places. To become somebody I am not... It is glorious.
So, first I will say that the title of this book is excellent. It provokes interest and questions immediately. And, luckily the text of the book lives up to the initial reaction.
I am a bit of a history nerd and love to read quality historical fiction which I usually follow with research on the related history to determine the accuracy of the book. I don't read as many nonfiction books as I often find them to be dull, dry books filled with recitation of dates and names but little story. The best nonfiction history books, for me, are those that read more like a novel. This one mostly succeeds at doing that. I would probably rate it at about 4.5 stars.
Many reviewers have complained that this book is too long. I disagree. If anything, I wanted more. I am sure there is so much more story to mine and I would have loved to know more about Dr Kelley's interactions with the Nazis -- particularly Hermann Goring.
It is an excellent story of the intersection of these two extraordinary men's lives for a brief moment of time -- and how one influenced the other for many years after. It is a glimpse into the things that occurred post-WWII with the Nazis who remained alive. We see the arrogance when learning about the expectations they had regarding their treatment by the Allies. We see the desire to learn what made a Nazi a Nazi. And we see something we might call PTSD today affecting the doctor for the remainder of his life.
This book is excellent -- informative, compelling and absorbing. It reads quickly. I read it in two sittings.
This is not an easy review to write as I dont want to spoil this audiobook for the listeners to come.
This is an eight hour audiobook that should be only six hours long. The portions of this book dealing with the notable nazi leaders and the Nuremberg trials of 1946 are exceptional. This is not a book about the war crimes of the accused but rather an attempt as portraying the men
( mostly Hermann Goring ) clinically.
The main psychiatrist, Dr. Douglas Kelley, tries to locate "the nazi gene" that these defendents share that would possibly help in preventing such nazi horrors from reoccurring. Hermann Goring, the senior most nazi in custody, is also the most flamboyant personality. It is Goring that commands much of Kelley's attention. As the book progresses, both lives become inter entwined.
Where the book loses it is the two plus hours of the book that deals with Kelley's post Nuremberg life. Can anyone out there actually get excited about the personal life of a psychiatrist? I couldnt
If you buy this book, skip the last two hours
I love author Morey and excellent narrator one of my favorites. If you think you've heard all the auto books and booked you can about nazi crimes and the Holocaust. Listen to this one. It puts a twist on at telling about the psychiatrist that treated the Nazis his similarities with them and their findings. Very interesting highly recommended
I am a lover of history and the fantastic tales of human achievement (or folly). Sometimes, a grand author captures my imagination.
When I started reading this book, I was expecting a riveting history of two men engaged in a do or die mind duel to elaborate on the Nazi psychology. Instead, the book dryly details the psychological testing carried out by Captain Douglas M. Kelley on the Nuremberg defendants over a 6 month period. In this particular case atleast, history was not that colorful or enjoyable.
In a positive note, there is still much to glean from the interaction and discourse amongst the various criminal parties concerned. I particularly enjoyed the background on top Nazi officials and their demeanor living in their cramped prison cells. Their conversations between themselves as well as with the US military personnel are truly fascinating. There is no doubt, that the stress on these men must have been immense as the trial began.
A fair amount information is provided on Goring who is the most bombastic figure within the party of 22 defendants. He is without doubt the master manipulator and the author clearly wonders if Kelly himself was manipulated during his research. Nevertheless, Kelley went onto publish his works after returning to the US postulating that there was no specific human trait that drove the Nazi mind. Frighteningly, he concluded that any one of us could become a Nazi of the future.
A disturbing fact remains that Kelley seems to have borrowed or even stole his colleagues work during the time they both worked at Nuremberg. Kelley himself was a strange figure and suffered from mental illness which ultimately led to his suicide following Goering’s exact steps.
Recommend for the history buff!
Report Inappropriate Content