The French and Indian War and the Conquest of New France

By: William R. Nester

Narrated by: Philip Benoit

Length: 17 hrs and 9 mins

Publisher's summary

The French and Indian War was the world's first truly global conflict. When the French lost to the British in 1763, they lost their North American empire along with most of their colonies in the Caribbean, India, and West Africa. In The French and Indian War and the Conquest of New France, the only comprehensive account from the French perspective, William R. Nester explains how and why the French were defeated. He explores the fascinating personalities and epic events that shaped French diplomacy, strategy, and tactics and determined North America's destiny.

What began in 1754 with a French victory - the defeat at Fort Necessity of young Lieutenant Colonel George Washington - quickly became a disaster for France. The cost in soldiers, ships, munitions, provisions, and treasure was staggering. France was deeply in debt when the war began, and that debt grew with each year. Nester describes missed diplomatic and military opportunities as well as military defeats late in the conflict.

Nester masterfully weaves his narrative of this complicated war with thorough accounts of the military, economic, technological, social, and cultural forces that affected its outcome. Listeners learn not only how and why the French lost, but how the problems leading up to that loss in 1763 foreshadowed the French Revolution almost 25 years later.

One of the problems at Versailles was the king's mistress, the powerful Madame de Pompadour, who encouraged Louis XV to become his own prime minister. The bewildering labyrinth of French bureaucracy combined with court intrigue and financial challenges only made it even more difficult for the French to succeed. Ultimately, France lost the war because Versailles failed to provide enough troops and supplies to fend off the English enemy.

©2014 William R. Nester (P)2016 Redwood Audiobooks

A great narrative of the Real First World War

What made the experience of listening to The French and Indian War and the Conquest of New France the most enjoyable?

This book is the first I've read that explained how France lost it's hold in the new world.

What was one of the most memorable moments of The French and Indian War and the Conquest of New France?

It brought to light and life the struggle for power in the 18th century western nations, and showed how the inattentive, capricious leadership of the French royals cost them everything by setting the stage for the revolution.

Who would you have cast as narrator instead of Philip Benoit?

Anyone who actually speaks French. He murdered the pronunciation of the names and titles to the point of distraction. For me, this was the major flaw in an otherwise well written, thoroughly documented book. Simon Vance would have done much better.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?

How France lost the new world.

Interesting topic, terrible narration

The narrator’s inability to pronounce any French names correctly distracts from the content. I would have given it a higher rating if the narration was better.

Great perspective from the French side of the war!

This is a great book for anyone wanting to go deeper into the French and Indian War (7 Years War) from the French view point. There are so many interesting details on the conflict and the actors in it. I would describe it as an "academic" book so it may not be as enjoyable for someone with little knowledge of the period and conflict. (For those people start with Crucible of War: The Seven Years' War and the Fate of Empire in British North America then read this as a follow-up).

Narrator really struggled with French names

A very compelling story, but if you're going narrate a book about France, you should know how to pronounce French names. It became something of a distraction trying to figure out what the narrator was mispronouncing.

Woulda Coulda Shoulda

Yes the narrator boldly mispronounces French names. However, I could overlook this quirk. What’s truly galling is how frequently the author states that the war, economy, etc would have gone differently had Louis XV done “x” instead of “y”. Additionally, despite often stultifying detail, the author doesn’t even try to explain just why Mme Pompadour disagreed with this or that adviser. We’re there no letters or diaries? Book reads like an accounting ledger with no notes in the memo section

Mistitled and Poorly Focused, but other than that...

The title would more accurately be something like “A History of France’s Global Military and Diplomatic Incompetence and Corruption in the 18th Century,” but only a third or half of the book is about The French and Indian War at most. Very little of the book is about French or British Strategy or, for that matter, the perspective of the various Indian Chiefs and alliances that played a huge part in the tactical victories and defeats. The reader has to wade through several whole chapters of French palace and political corruption, as well as conflicts involving Germany, Spain, Russia, Austria and others, in order to find out about the French and Indian War and why they lost Canada to the British. Hint: The powerful and highly competent British Royal Navy. One would also hope that in a book containing several hundreds of French names, titles, terms and cities, the narrator would have more than an American tourist’s knowledge of accepable pronunciation. It was so bad that it went from disconcerting to laughable, but a reader from France would likely declare war.

Title is misleading

This has almost nothing to do with French and Indian war in America- probably about 1 hr. Takes 5 hrs to get 1750 in France. Most of the story is about France’s war in Europe with about 1/3 of time in Canada. If you’re interested in France’s ineptitude this is for you.

Dry as burnt toast with a side of sand jam

I couldn’t even finish this book. If you are going to write a book about France’s involvement in the French and Indian War, when you turn it into an audio book, maybe, just maybe, get a narrator that can pronounce French nouns in the French tongue. This coupled with the narrators constant whistles at the end of words, it was hard to listen to.

I thought I might just buy the book and read it but the structure is so all over the place. It’s next to impossible to follow along based on a linear timeline as nothing is linear in this book. This isn’t so much of a story of French involvement from beginning to end, but rather the author just discussing it at random. This book also relies on the reader having a fairly basic, and in some instances an in depth knowledge of the conflict.

If this is a must read for you and you know nothing of the war of Austrian succession, the 7 years war and the French and Indian war, please go read (listen) to Fred Anderson’s “Crucible of War”, before getting into this. It’s the only way you will know what this author is talking about regarding many aspects of the global conflict.