A white-knuckle account of the First Infantry Division’s harrowing D-Day assault on the eastern sector of Omaha Beach - acclaimed historian John C. McManus has written a gripping history that will stand as the last word on this titanic battle. Nicknamed the Big Red One, First Division had fought from North Africa to Sicily, earning a reputation as stalwart warriors on the front lines and rabble-rousers in the rear. Yet on D-Day, these jaded combat veterans melded with fresh-faced replacements to accomplish one of the most challenging and deadly missions ever. As the men hit the beach, their equipment destroyed or washed away, soldiers cut down by the dozens, courageous heroes emerged: men such as Sergeant Raymond Strojny, who grabbed a bazooka and engaged in a death duel with a fortified German antitank gun; T/5 Joe Pinder, a former minor-league pitcher who braved enemy fire to save a vital radio; Lieutenant John Spalding, a former sportswriter, and Sergeant Phil Streczyk, a truck driver, who together demolished a German strong point overlooking Easy Red, where hundreds of Americans had landed.
Along the way, McManus explores the Gap Assault Team engineers who dealt with the extensive mines and obstacles, suffering nearly a 50 percent casualty rate; highlights officers such as Brigadier General Willard Wyman and Colonel George Taylor, who led the way to victory; and punctures scores of myths surrounding this long-misunderstood battle.
The Dead and Those about to Die draws on a rich array of new or recently unearthed sources, including interviews with veterans. The result is history at its finest, the unforgettable story of the Big Red One’s 19 hours of hell - and their ultimate triumph - on June 6, 1944.
©2014 John C. McManus (P)2014 Gildan Media LLC
“Magnificent! I could not put this book down. John McManus has expanded our knowledge of D-Day history by a considerable factor. It is a great read and will appeal to both devoted students of World War II as well as those with a more casual interest. Don't miss it!” (Joseph Balkoski, author of Omaha Beach and Utah Beach)
I listen to and have recently started to write reviews. I've found the reviews have helped me to select books.
John C. McManus gives the reader an in depth account of what occurred on D-Day on the eastern sector of Omaha Beach. This was where the First Infantry Division had been commanded to attack. The men who had engaged in many battles for the past year felt that they should have been allowed to go home. However, the brass had a different idea. Their division was known to get the job done, Therefore, they sent the First.
The invasion was harrowing, to say the very least. Men were shot dead in the water, which continued to get deeper. The packs the men carried made it almost impossible to tread through the deep water, let alone trudge up the sandy beach.
The beach was inundated with bombs that continued to explode, taking the soldiers with them. Those that made it to the beach had to find cover so as not to be killed or wounded. However, there was hardly any cover to be found. Trenches were dug, cliffs were found but nothing would keep the German's from firing.
The First Infantry Division were not cowards and the medals that some won and the death of too many proved that this was so.
The book was researched in depth. The author used names of the men that were too many to remember. He bared wide open the description of how the men struggled. What happened to the men when the bombs exploded beneath them. All of the gory details were in the words spoken by the narrator, Dan Hagen. He did a very good job. The character's that spoke left no idea of who it was because their sentences were short but their fighting was not.
I found this book provided me with the best description of what occurred on Omaha Beach on D-Day. The men faded into the darkness, both American and German. Tomorrow would come with the sun. Some men slept, yet other's laid awake. Both sides patrolled throughout the night.
The words, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, were not used, instead the words, Battle Fatigue. The words were and are one and the same.
Purchase, The Dead and Those About to Die, and you will be sure to listen and know just what Omaha Beach was then and remembered now and forever. The hallowed ground where American's fought and died to preserve world peace will maintain its memories forever, never to be forgotten.
Book is packed with incredible, brutal and heroic accounts of soldiers taking part in the D-Day invasion. Unfortunately there are just too many incredible accounts, and it begins to sag under its own weight. Maybe this won't bother others, but I found the pacing combined with the exacting detail regarding numbered combat zones and weaponry grating after about the halfway point. Narrator's drone doesn't help, though I'm not sure how much he can be blamed. Overall it's a worthy read for the scenes within, I just think it could be more cohesive as a work.
Great book. Most Americans are probably unaware of the sacrifices made by the Big Red One. This book reminds us if those. Thank a soldier, buy them a beer or a burger and thank them.
Very good account of those in "The Big Red One" and the ultimate sacrifice they faced on Omaha Beach that bloody day in early June. To those who gave all in the face of certain death so we can enjoy the freedoms so takin advantaged of today. My heart goes out to the bravery and sacrifice of these young men to protect our flag and way of life!
This isn't like listening to a novel. As things start you know that for a large number of the people it isn't going to end well. And yet you find yourself hopeful that maybe this one will survive or that calamity won't occur. But they do anyway. How could they not.
Still so sad for the people who lost everything that day. This book does a good job of putting a human face on the names on the tomb stones in the Normandy cemeteries.
I have nothing but respect for the men on the beach. How could anyone have anything else.
But the conclusion that it was a good plan that went astray is harder to respect. Lack of reconnaissance, poor intelligence briefing, worthless bombardment, landing people in the wrong place, USN being too timid to provide close in support, ridiculous loads, lack of medical evacuation. All these and more got so many people killed unnecessarily. But it is all done now.
Faced with mindless duty, when an audio book player slips into a rear pocket and mini buds pop into ears, old is made new again.
John McManus tells a story of one battle in WWII. Directly and indirectly, an estimated 80 million people die. Twenty two to twenty five million military men and women are lost to their families. McManus infers all WWII’ losses are exemplified by 3,000 Allied and 1,200 Axis soldiers that die in battle at Omaha Beach. The D-Day invasion at Omaha Beach contrasts honor, bravery, and leadership with blame, weakness, and powerlessness in battle.
WWII becomes a necessary war when Hitler invades Poland in 1939. Few realize the depth of Hitler’s evil until near the end of the war. Without the honor, bravery, and leadership of Allied Forces before and after D-Day, the world would have little hope for freedom. In spite of mistakes made in life; inherent human weakness, and powerlessness in the face of inept leadership, good prevails over evil. That is the lesson of one battle; i.e. the battle for Omaha Beach. The power of good over evil is exemplified by a young boy, in 2014, who stands with an American flag on a lonely beach in France.
I was extremely pleased with the detail first account history and facts of this book and recommend it to many for reading enjoyment and a trip through history at the landing of Normandy
Thoroughly enjoyed the narrators performance, the style of the book and the historical accuracy of events. All enthusiasts of ww2 military history will enjoy this book
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.