Few events have captivated students of American history like the Civil War. Its most striking personalities seem somehow outsized, magnified beyond the ability of books or even legend to contain them. And few among those personalities have ever held our attention like General Robert Edward Lee.
With his Army of Northern Virginia, Lee came to embody the cause of the Confederacy itself, inspiring a commitment from troops and civilians that eventually overshadowed even those given to its political leaders and institutions.
This riveting series of 24 lectures from one of the nation's most respected Civil War historians explains how this came to pass, and how - in a war that produced no other successful Confederate armies - this amazing leader was able to create and inspire an army whose achievements resonated not only across the Confederacy but also throughout the North and in foreign capitals like London and Paris.
You'll learn what Lee was actually like, and gain insights into his ideas about strategy and tactics. You'll grasp how battlefield events influenced public opinion on the home fronts of both the Union and the Confederacy. And, most of all, you'll grasp how crucial Lee's choices in forming his high command were to the war's events and outcome.
These lectures have been designed to appeal to everyone who wants to understand more about the Civil War and why it unfolded as it did, whether your interest is in the strategy and tactics underlying its major battles or in the broader context within which those battles took place.
PLEASE NOTE: When you purchase this title, the accompanying reference material will be available in your My Library section along with the audio.
©2004 The Teaching Company, LLC (P)2004 The Great Courses
Professor Gary Gallagher (a very highly decorated, nationally renown history professor at the University of Virginia) delivers a fast-paced review of Robert E Lee, Confederate principal generals, fast rising young generals and context miliary leadership in the Confederacy. Each bio is carefully presented with both strengths, flaws and outstanding performances coupled with failures. Dr. Gallagher turns these historical figures into real people. His perspective is particularly insightful in that he points out that virtually all Civil War Generals were essentially untrained and unready for their responsibilities. Many succeeded at a lower level and then failed with promotion to wider commands. Few truly met the measure of what was needed. The overwhelming number of deaths and wounding of Southern key generals made rapid replacement with overwhelmed promoted subordinates a recurring issue.
This lecture series gives you context on the literature of the Civil War, wonderful biographies and a blazing pathway through the campaigns. Professor Gallagher has a pleasant, interesting and engaging voice. He delivers his lectures with a fast pace, understandable and with interesting vocal emphasis. He does not get lost in jargon. I found this series of lectures immensely entertaining as well as informative. Each general is either a lecture or two or three (Lee). Some generals were so interesting I found myself listening to their lecture over and over. I highly recommend this lecture series for someone interested in the Civil War, regardless of prior background and study. This series brings these Confederate generals to life.
Clear, spirited, non-biased, expert mastery of the subject.
I never heard a lecture that was of such high quality before, which is sad because I spent 4 years in college. I guess that's the biggest difference between Ivy League universities and the others, the quality of lectures you get.
Professor Gallagher is a master in his field and it is just as simple as that. His lectures are in-depth, clear and crisp, provides much desired non-biased cultural and situational perspective, and you will gain understanding.
I have enjoyed several offerings of the Great Courses Lectures on Historical events and this was one of the more interesting ones.
Professor Gallagher has done an excellent job in detailing all of these interesting leaders within Lee’s high command. I especially like the balance he utilizes in showing both the strengths and weaknesses of the individuals. With very few exceptions the assessments are even handed, although there are one or two officers that his take seems to be more of a personal like or dislike than one of looking simply at the facts. A few things in the book really stuck out – first was the incredible attrition rate of the officers in the Army of Northern Virginia due to deaths/wounding in battle. There were rarely back to back battles in which the same command structure was actually in place, other than Lee himself. There was a constant need to reshuffle leadership following the engagements. Another interesting analogy made by Professor Gallagher was his comparison of Lee’s role with that of Dwight Eisenhower, who also had to deal with strong, aggressive and competitive personalities of subordinates such as Patton and Montgomery, with Lee that role was even a greater necessity as a large number of his Senior Leaders seemed to stay in perpetual conflict with each other. On numerous occasions there were officers arresting other officers for what seemed to be more out of a competition than any real military error. Lastly, it was really amazing to see how successful many of the officers were at one level, then as they gained rank they become ineffectual or only marginally successful – the Peter Principle.
If you are interested in the make-up of the officers in the book then you will really find the book interesting. I will say though, if you are more interested in details of their actions taken in famous battles; this book may not be what you would be looking for. The Battles are only described in the most general of terms.
This lecture series is one of the best I've listened to. Professor Gallagher truly knows history and he presents the material in a very easy to understand way while also proving a ton of insight about each particular general and their strengths and weaknesses.
I would highly recommend this series to anyone with an interest in the Civil War.
I wish there was a companion audiobook about the Union army's high command as well, preferably from the same professor.
This is only the third audiobook Ive given 5 / 5 / 5 stars to
A tremendous lecture series presented by Prof. Gallagher. The professor does such a great job presenting this course to us that no maps are necessary as you need for so many other military works. Each general is presented with both his strengths and faults not only individually but how each general inter reacted with each other and how this affected the total picture
On a personal note Id have liked to hear about Nathen Bedford Forrest
Buy this series
I just finished my second great courses series with Gary Gallagher at the helm. He narrates splendidly, offers excellent insight into the realm of a civil war commander, and keeps it relevant 100% of the time. Love this series, love the lectures, I need more!!
Dr. Gallagher is an outstanding presenter! If more students has a history teacher like him, more people would love history and not dread it. His enthusiasm is electrifying, and he is clearly not reading a script. I am going to search out his other books here, and in print.
He knew so much about the topic, had wonderful insights, and provided the little details so missing, yet humanizing, in many history tomes.
He did not "perform". He presented his information and was fantastic. I was really sorry when it was over.
I have no idea.
Worthwhile and educational. And entertaining.
I think Mr. Gallagher has great information and does a great job presenting it. While I recognized most of the generals and knew of their big picture contributions to a few of the campaigns, I did learn a lot about the backstory and a much more detailed view on their actions during the war.
My only major complaints was with the beginning and the end. The beginning seemed to be a very godlike praise of R E Lee. One example is I guess I'm part of the group that criticizes him a little for resorting to bloody frontal assaults during key battles or campaigns (think seven days, Gettysburg, etc. etc.). I felt he did a very amateur job of ignoring the criticism with the throw away statement of "everyone does frontal assaults."
My other criticism regards his views on the confederacy, he has very strong views regarding what he considers "revisionist" history and the generals attempts to reframe the debate. For a war that is over 150 years old, he sure seems to hold a grudge, almost makes me wonder if he wishes we still had an occupation army in the south.
But besides those two issues at the very beginning and very end he does a marvelous job when he discusses the other generals. If you have an interest in the Civil War, I would strongly recommend this title. And even with my criticisms, if you feel the same way as me, it never hurts to listen to someone who disagrees with your thoughts. A little too much groupthink is a bad thing.
Definitely. Great content and good presenter! This is the first course from Great Courses I completely finished and the first one I think I will want to revisit.
Very easy to listen to. Extremely informative, well researched. I may not always agree with Dr Gallagher ' s conclusions or opinions but he stuck to historical fact and not speculation. This was my first listen to an audible book and I am sold. looking forward to starting my next book.
"A promise fulfilled"
It was middle of the road for me. The high marks came from the fact that, should you like Confederate/Civil War history (turns out I don't), this is one of the best overviews of Robert E. Lee and His High Command and indeed the war effort I've yet come across. If you really want an intermediate level lecture series on the Civil War, get it on.
Touching on the lost cause (or any of the bits regarding the greater ramifications)
But seriously, he's a great lecturer.
Robert E. Lee and His High Command: The tale of Robert E. Lee and His High Command
"Seen from abroad."
Profound, dispassionate, engaging.
The course is didactic without being pedantic.
His clear and obvious enthusiasm for his subject.
No, because one needs time to consider and digest each lecture.
The Civil War continues to divide the United States and Prof. Gallagher is American, therefore attuned and involved in the continuing debate. To foreigners the debate is much more clear cut, the Civil War was the true American Revolution.
Lee is seen abroad as a great captain, no doubt about that, but one with feet of clay and Gallagher sees him in the soft focus that is commonplace in the US. However, he is generous to Longstreet which is nice to hear.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.