Pulitzer Prize, General Nonfiction, 1998
Guns, Germs and Steel examines the rise of civilization and the issues its development has raised throughout history.
Having done field work in New Guinea for more than 30 years, Jared Diamond presents the geographical and ecological factors that have shaped the modern world. From the viewpoint of an evolutionary biologist, he highlights the broadest movements both literal and conceptual on every continent since the Ice Age, and examines societal advances such as writing, religion, government, and technology. Diamond also dissects racial theories of global history, and the resulting work—Guns, Germs and Steel—is a major contribution to our understanding the evolution of human societies.
©1997 Jared Diamond (P)2011 Random House
I'm going with a strong 3 stars. This book was well researched. The kind of book that your professors want you to write. Very logical, with each point being addressed, and an 'area for further study' at the end of the book. He is a professor at UCLA...so it kinda feels like a dissertation...definitely more readable than that, but tedious for the average reader like myself.
Jared Diamond has lived a really interesting, global life. While in New Guinea a young politician asked him "why do you have cargo and we don't?" Cargo meaning stuff, boats, technology, etc. Diamond boils this down to the most essential advantages the Europeans had that others did not: Guns, Germs and Steel.
Then he asks, why did the Europeans get guns, germs and steel and not people from other places?
Then you have lots and lots and lots of information that I mostly got lost in...and you realize he's saying: Geography. The geography of places led to them having 'advantages' in moving towards settled societies with technology and literacy and food crops. ...My professors at Jerusalem University College would love that.
This book is especially valuable because the subconsciously assumed answer to the question of why one race has more cargo is generally that certain races are more superior in some way, but he's saying no and giving a good, well thought out reason for this. This book will make subsequent history books better. For the average reader, you could probably get away with reading the intro and the conclusion...that's mostly what I will remember.
It is a huuuuge undertaking to answer the question of how everything happened and became the way it did and he does it in about as concise a manner as I can imagine anybody doing...but still, for my desires, it was still too scientific feeling and not enough stories. I would have liked it if it followed a few biographies or something. Too tedious for me. Maybe I need to read a bit more around the topic and then come back to it.
I did like when he dabbled in Linguistic history, I think I have a little connection to that having studied a few languages and asking a few questions in that realm. I listened to this on audiobook and my ears perked up when he started making those connections.
A lot of people have recommended this book to me over the years and I finally got the chance to read it…
I came away from this book with a mind full of questions to ponder for the rest of my life!
Yes, its a very good book. Well writen and well explained.
Nothing I have yet read. Though I hope to find others.
Clear and well voiced.
History: A real world story
Hard to say. I have read the book and remember that I keept going back and forth in the book to check facts and to compare when the author referenced to earlier wrtitings in the book. That is a tad harder/cumbersum to do with the audiobook. Having read the book for three years ago I didnät feel the need to go back and forth though.
There are several scenes when Jarrod puts our world in perspective using different naturetribes ho been working with as examples.
This book didn't touch my heart, it did touch my brain though.
Read it to get a firmer ground to stand in both the evolution and history of mankind.
Yes. Great ideas and context for why the world has become how it is today.
This is very dry material. He did as good of a job as any could (i imagine) reading it.
This book is a great 'read' for information. The author is very thourough. He circles around on a topic for 5 minutes before landing. This is because of his research and giving a full explanation. I prefer cliff notes.
That said, I've wanted to read this book for years now and much prefer having listened to it!
I enjoyed listening to this story not based on Theology and instead on factual findings.
I am little boring so this is unfair but when the wife cracked the husband over the head for his admittance to something he had done.....yes I laughed.
This book was used for help in my Religion and Culture class.
What a brilliant book! If you like broad strokes history and history that does not dwell on details but rather explains cause and affect, then this is a book for you. In a very convincing manner Jared Diamond explains the rise of the civilizations, and why some rose quicker than others. I have read a lot of history books, and this is a definite top 10.
Jared Diamond sets out to answer the question of a New Guinean about why history has favored some societies over other when it comes to riches.
His explanations are that coincidences with respect to geography, domesticable plants and animals have been major 'first causes' to this uneven distribution of wealth. He makes his point very convincing.
He starts with an explanation on a small scale before taking on explanations on differences between entire continents. In this he is very thorough and presents overwhelming details in comparing many different societies throughout history throughout the world.
A real eye opener for me were the descriptions of clashes of societies where both parties were non-european. These have been as brutal as where european societies invaded.
The performance fits the style of the book. Never excited never dull in tone, like a lecturer I really enjoyed.
Very interesting book! They say that people's mouths are more dirty than dogs' mouths. Now I know why! The better to destroy indigenous populations with, my dear.
The information is interesting, but its a bit of a slog to get through. I had a tough time paying attention while driving. Certainly helped me sleep. The voice actor is a bit on the dry side. Reminded me a bit of Alan Greenspan.
Report Inappropriate Content