© and (P)2014 Audible, Inc.
Female, love a good mystery, Victorian English literature and love to laugh (Dickens, Austen, Trollepe, Wodehouse, Gaskell, Elliot
Loved "everything" about this book. Intelligent author and most beautifully narrated by Prunella Scales.
It was all good.
No but I will seek out books she narrates because she is an outstanding narrator and does both male and female voices beautifully.
This is a stupid question; however I will respond by saying that I would enjoy knowing all the characters in this book.
It is obvious why Elizabeth Gaskell's books have been chosen by Masterpiece Theatre for dramatization.
The Reading is beautiful, this book is very much worth a listen
But you should be aware that the last chapter was never finished by the author so if you need everything tied up in a neat little bow its not going to happen
Its fairly easy to guess from where its left what happens to the characters though and don't let that put you off.
Wonderful book! This particular narrator tends to rush the dialogue, especially when reading the characters with heavier accents, which made many lines difficult for me to understand.
This is my first audio book, so I don't have a lot of context in which to judge, but I enjoyed every second of it. I already knew the story, and was impressed with Prunella Scales's voicing of the characters. Unlike a reviewer below, I didn't find her narration "flat;" I don't want the reader's voice to overwhelm the text. I think I'm going to purchase more of Mrs. Gaskell, as read by Scales.
While Elizabeth Gaskell novels are always excellent, the narration of this one surpassed all expectations and enhanced the story immeasurably. From Welsh to Scots, from high-born to low, Ms Scales was spot on and could slip from one to the other seamlessly. Astonishing gift and perfect vehicle. One of my favourite purchases from Audible.
Prunella Scales brings great variety to the characters here, and her superb reading allows us to savor the profound depths of Elizabeth Gaskell's masterpiece. It's a great narrative of a great novel -- I didn't want it to end, and Ms. Scales is able to give us every character distinctly. A real triumph. I wish she read more Victorian novels!
Really excellent! I love the characters in the world Ms. Gaskell has created. They are engrossing, some are devilishly clever, some are very flawed, some extremely kind. And, even though she was unable to finish it, we all know how it ends. Lovely
Wanda the artist
She is like a speed reader. Perhaps the director told her she had only **so** many CDs for her work, so she had to pace herself to get all of the unabridged text on the CDs. For whatever reason, she reads the text so incredibly fast that even a seasoned reader or listener has to pay 100% attention to her reading to understand what is happening. THAT is not why I buy an audio book. I purchase an audio book to HELP me get through a tedious task, or actually to help me go to sleep at night. NOT to listen to it, and it alone. I can’t even tell you what the story line is about … after having tried to listen to it three times! Beware. Unless you are a speed listener this book might not be for you. I will watch out for this narrator.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.