New York Times best-selling author of The Joy Luck Club Amy Tan brings us her latest novel: a sweeping, evocative epic of two women's intertwined fates and their search for identity - from the lavish parlors of Shanghai courtesans to the fog-shrouded mountains of a remote Chinese village
Shanghai, 1912. Violet Minturn is the privileged daughter of the American madam of the city's most exclusive courtesan house. But when the Ching dynasty is overturned, Violet is separated from her mother in a cruel act of chicanery and forced to become a "virgin courtesan." Half-Chinese and half-American, Violet grapples with her place in the worlds of East and West - until she is able to merge her two halves, empowering her to become a shrewd courtesan who excels in the business of seduction and illusion, though she still struggles to understand who she is.
Back in 1897 San Francisco, Violet's mother, Lucia, chooses a disastrous course as a sixteen-year-old, when her infatuation with a Chinese painter compels her to leave her home for Shanghai. Shocked by her lover's adherence to Chinese traditions, she is unable to change him, despite her unending American ingenuity.
Fueled by betrayals, both women refuse to submit to fate and societal expectations, persisting in their quests to recover what was taken from them: respect; a secure future; and, most poignantly, love from their parents, lovers, and children. To reclaim their lives, they take separate journeys - to a backwater hamlet in China, the wealthy environs of the Hudson River Valley, and, ultimately, the unknown areas of their hearts, where they discover what remains after their many failings to love and be loved. Spanning more than forty years and two continents, The Valley of Amazement transports listeners from the collapse of China's last imperial dynasty to the beginning of the Republic and recaptures the lost world of old Shanghai through the inner workings of courtesan houses and the lives of the foreigners living in the International Settlement, both erased by World War II. A deeply evocative narrative of the profound connections between mothers and daughters, imbued with Tan's characteristic insight and humor, The Valley of Amazement conjures a story of inherited trauma, desire and deception, and the power and obstinacy of love.
©2013 Amy Tan (P)2013 Brilliance Audio, all rights reserved.
I found listening to this book an incredibly good way to fall asleep. One of the narrators in particular spoke in a low drone that was like white noise. I found no purpose to the story - it was boring basically, with whole hours devoted to how to behave like a courtesan. I didn't really like any of the main characters and this is probably why I didn't enjoy this book.
Sadly, I would not. I stopped listening five chapters before it ended. I gave it a good try but by then, I had stopped caring about Violet and her mother. I agree that people usually make the same mistakes over and over, but Violet's self-created problems were too predictable and ultimately not very believable.
I found the lovemaking (if you can call it that) too graphic.
Often authors who narrate their own books disappoint but Ms. Tan's voice and those of the other narrators are expressive and credible.
I enjoyed Ms. Tan's other books so I was disappointed that this one fell short.
I read Amy Tan's first book and thought this would be even better. Not. This is either an aberration or sign of slow decline. the reading was laughable: women attempting to voice a Chinese man with an English accent. Absolutely awful. As if the story weren't written poorly enough based on a story so trite in too many ways. I think she was going for classy pornography and she missed by a mile. Or several kilometers.
Maybe she wrote this when she was 16 in which case, it isn't too bad. I'd say she needs to mature. So much stereotypical trash. It's hard to describe the many ways this books was disappointing.
Readers were so stiff I think I could hear them crackle. There was nothing smooth or natural about this reading. Poor voicing of different characters, overly formal storytelling. This was very difficult to listen to. I'm not sure why I did.
All of the overly-descriptive sexual encounters. Those were torture. The "deep, philosophical" thinking the characters go through trying to figure out the intentions of other characters. Probably easier to describe what I would keep.
Awful, awful, awful.
Amy Tan is a talented writer, however this book is one of the worst I've ever read. The plot is predictable and boring. The characters were never really likable and I couldn't connect with any of them. The character Magic Gourd's lessons on how to be the perfect courtesan seem to be a list taken straight from a text book. I was constantly wanting to just stop listening and kept falling asleep.
In every possible way. The voices were the worst possible choices. I was bored to death.
The lessons from Magic Gourd could have been the most fun part of the book. Sadly it was just a list and when read it sounded like someone reading a list of do's and don'ts.
I would not recommend this book. Don't waste your money.
I have not finished this reading yet. I am in the midst of the Narrator for Magic Cloud. I want to throw the IPOD through the window -the voice is so slow and grating!! I can only tune it out. I want to skip it, but I might miss something-and it is really a pain to skip things. It's too bad. I didn't like the first narrator's version of Magic Cloud either. I don't think there is any reason for more than one narrator-but one that reads to improve the story is absolutely needed. I think reading this in book form would be tolerable. I could skip the parts that are unneeded and don't add to the story.
Overall, Amy Tan's fiction is wonderful and this book fits that description.
I liked the vivid descriptions of people and places. I especially liked the descriptions of Shanghai because I have been to most of the neighborhoods that she describes.
The book needs to be edited down a little. There are too many repetitive stories within the story. Also, it is sexually explicit, not for young adult listeners .
i like to read. i like to listen.
honestly i expected more from amy tan. i dont know why. i've only read one other book by her (joy luck club), and i really did enjoy that one...but its been 6 years since i read it -- and 25 years since she wrote it. thats a lot of time, and a lot of other novels, that i've missed. but i guess because she's so prolific, and so popular, i figured that this novel was bound to be another amazing story. i kind of didn't feel that way.
to be frank, i found the story to drag on and on...with all of the main characters making all of the same mistakes over and over and over again. without learning or growing.
Violet is one of the dumbest female protagonists i have ever encountered. i kept grimacing over every choice she made, every person she trusted, every word she uttered. she kept saying 'i'm smart' 'i am clever' 'i could figure a way' -- and i wanted to scream back at here - no you aren't!!! you really really aren't! her story took way to long to unfold. leaving precious little time to get through the other two women's stories, which then felt rushed and cut short. Lulu was semi-interesting....but as i said, i felt i didn't get to really invest myself in her story because it was told so quickly and so near to the end of the novel -- i knew that it was being told only to move the story along to the ending.
obviously i don't know anything about being a courtesan in turn of the century China...how would i. and this story did give you an interesting look into that lifestyle, whether chosen or forced upon a woman. it was extremely graphic in it's sexual encounters -- which didn't bother me -- but i also didn't find those scenes necessarily helped to move the plot along. they were a bit gratuitous.
what frustrated me the most in this novel was the two child kidnappings that took place. the complacency of both mothers was astounding...like they lost an old silk scarf -- not a child from their own womb! there was no lamenting except a few words here and there 'i long for my daughter' 'i think about her all the time.' but that didn't seem like what was going on. it seemed, to me, that each woman was moving along with her life without looking back....without giving any effort to rescue her poor child. perhaps it was the times, or the country they were in, but i found the fact that no recourse was even attempted frustrating and bothersome. then the ending comes, everyone hugs and "we can all live happily moving forward and love each other again" -- it was just ridiculous.
to end, this book was frustrating, and drawn out, and overall disappointing to me.
This book just went on and on. I am an Amy Tan fan but this book disappointed.
Yes. The storyline was good.
A lot to like, but I did get tired of the main characters whining that their mother's didn't love them. Lots of good parts, I couldn't put it down, but I felt let down by the sappy ending.
Too much wallowing about past pain. We have all been hurt, most of us try to move forward, which the characters did in the early parts of the novel, but when things turned out well, they went on like they were in a bad romance novel.
I LOVE Amy Tan and the readers were great, but this one was a disappointment.
I hope not
It was a romance and fantasy of the life of a working girl
Yes, it was slow to get into but once there fun like cotton candy.
It was a light adventure so easy to listen while doing other chores.
Sometimes it is nice to just listen to a light fantasy of life in another culture.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.