©2008 BBC Audiobooks Ltd; (P)2014 Audible, Inc.
"fabric artist and quilter"
Trollope is a master at characterisation. Every one of the main characters are three dimensional and very real even if they aren't very modern - 150 years hasn't changed human character very much at all - we all could feel Lily Dales suffering, Johnny Eames pain, we know self-centred people like Lady Alexandrina and bad boys like Crosbie. The fact we can empathise and identify with the characters shows Trollope's genius.
The fact that I wanted to slap some sense into Lily Dale also shows that genius - and believe me she did need a good slap - we've all been hurt in love but she took the hurt to another level! Her martyrdom so annoyed me and made for a very frustrating heroine in my eyes.
Nevertheless I do hope that someone makes a good movie of this book for it needs to be done. Its a complete story in itself but listening to all the books in the series does make it all the more enjoyable - characters from previous books reappear and their stories continue. Its rather like catching up with a rarely seen friend and hearing their news.
I'm looking forward to the last in the series and then I shall launch into the Pallisers - Trollope is providing me with a feast which I am loving.
I'm an avid listener. Audio books are a mini-vacation for me. They fill my "need to read" when I don't have time - which is most of the time. Great element of multi-tasking!
Trollope is one of the authors a literate person is supposed to read, but I expect that few of us do. To remedy that deficit in my own list, I purchased this book due to the interesting description. What an happy surprise to realize that almost 200 years later, the humor is fresh and the story is still appealing. I loved the self-aware narration speaking to the reader "around" the tale, and the assumption in the writing that we are clever enough to listen between the lines for the meaning of the author. Trollope's use of the language is brilliant. I will listen to more!
Yes, love the reader's way with the story and the story itself.
Obviously it compares to other tales in the Barset series. It also reminds me some of Gaskell's Cranford stories.
The Lady de Courcy
I've listened to 4 of the 5 Barset novels by this producer and like them well enough to go on with the last one. I do have to point out that I'm a little annoyed by some hasty editing in several of the titles in the series. Some editor must have had to cut for time -- maybe for a CD version? Rather than snipping a bit from several places in the program there are great chunks cut from a few places, making a very noticeable difference between long gaps separating most of the chapters and nearly no time at all between a few. I mention it only because I want the makers to know that some people do notice these things and find it a pity to spoil an otherwise pleasant entertainment by skimping on something so simple. An extra 30-40 minutes invested would have been worth the effort. Shame on whoever thought it didn't matter. My thanks to those responsible for everything I did enjoy about the experience.
There are more than enough reviews summing up the book and discussing Trollope, so let me simply say I love this period of literature, and Thackeray, Trollope, and Austin did some very good work. I really enjoyed this work of Trollope in particular. Some of his books have bored me. This did not, which may be in part because of the truly brilliant performance by Timothy West. Normally the performance of female characters by male actors interrupts my enjoyment (as well as females doing male voices), but West simply glides through like a swan on an open lake. He is perfect. I can't stress this enough! He sounds exactly like Trollope looks!
I can say unquestionably that Timothy West is my favorite narrator so far. Did I mention that he's perfect? Oh, I guess I did.
Humanitarian Aid Worker living in Central Asia.
This book creaked out of the starting gate and you had to listen closely to get the gist of who was who and how they were related to one another in the story. However, as it progressed it was a good story and well read. I did not care for Lilly. But perhaps her sentiments were apt for women of her social standing at the time even though it is hard to understand how a woman could so love a man she barely knew and then continue to hold fast to him even after his bad actions and character was revealed. I am still ruminating on whether to try more in the series.
The narrator, Timothy West, did a good job; he has a very distinguished voice and did not detract from this little period romance. However, I think a female voice would probably have fit the tale better. An editorial choice. This was an enjoyable listen, a bit less involved than other works by this author.
I read the reviews and bought the book to listen to. The story was great but the narration was to much, I think it was a bad choice. It needed someone that could produce a softer voice to protray the ladies. It seemed sometimes that they all had the one tone and voice.
I am retired and am busier than when I had a full time career. I don't get time to read; but my Ipod fills the gap.
This missive is dull, slow, and confusing. I'm sorry I bought it even at $4.95.
I bought this book because this one and most of Mr. Trollope's other books had such high review ratings. But I think the author needs to look more to Jane Austen on the character of females (and even males) rather than the sappy, vapid way of life depicted by Victor Hugo. The reader does not help. While Mr. West has a very nice book, I don't think he is especially good for a character driven book. Please Mr. West, stick to nonfiction. Although I cannot entirely fault him. Whoever hired a man to read a insipid soap opera should find a new day job.
All in all - save your bucks!
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.