1939: Nerys Watkins leaves rural Wales to accompany her husband on a missionary posting to India. Travelling from lonely Ladakh, high in the Himalayas, Nerys discovers a new world in the city of Srinagar.
Here, in the exquisite heart of Kashmir, the British live on carved wooden houseboats and dance, flirt and gossip as if there is no war. But the battles draw ever closer. Nerys is caught up in a dangerous friendship, and by the time she is reunited with her husband, the innocent Welsh bride has become a different woman.
Years later, when Mair Ellis clears out her father’s house, she finds an exquisite antique shawl which holds a lock of child’s hair. Tracing her grandparents’ roots back to Kashmir, Mair embarks on a quest that will change her life forever.
©2011 Rosie Thomas (P)2014 Audible, Inc.
This is an extraordinary historical drama. It mostly concerns the fortunes of three British women living during the British Raj period in India. They are the wife of a missionary, a hapless and naive soldier's wife, and an engineer's wife. Their characters grow--or are crushed--as the story develops. The setting and time are shown in both their brutality and beauty. The story shifts back and forth between the present day descendant of the missionary's wife and the 19th c. era, with the emphasis on the latter. Some aspects of this book are truly heart breaking, but in a way that gives the book a great sense of historical authenticity and emotional truth. The narration is spectacular, with Welsh, Scottish, English, and Indian accents effortlessly limned. There is romance, but it is far, far more than a sappy romance. Can NOT recommend this highly enough.
Truly vintage Rosie Thomas, a captivating story in a fabulous setting.
The characters were so real, so varied and so believable.
The setting between rural Wales & vibrant India transported the reader.
The thread of the story made it un-put downable.
I read the book but was unsure of the pronounciations so her reading helped to bring it to life for me.
I loved the description of the shawl being spread out & drifting with all the beautiful colours being seen for the first time.
I rated this book as highly as "Sun at midnight " & "White" which I have always considered superb stories.
i actually enjoyed the grandmothers staory most i think that could have been a book on its own! not sure why the granddaughters story was such a big part, it was a bit of a let down
yes but i dont want to spoil it!
I have always wanted to travel to Kashmir, so I loved how the setting of the novel was portrayed! The contrast between life as a privileged Brit and poor native people was well-researched and believable. The natural beauty of Kashmir, and the descriptions of the houseboats were also intriguing. The end of the British Raj was an epic time in human history, and I thought the flashbacks between then and now were an effective method of spinning a wonderful mystery. As to the romance: I did not find the main character's extra-marital affair very sympathetic or compelling. I enjoyed the narrator's voice and thought it contributed well to the story.
This was a lovely listen. Epic, beautiful, interesting and entertaining. I'd love more from this author available on audible. Yes!
Yes and no. Rosie Thomas has a gift for beautiful descriptions of lush unfamiliar landscapes, Nerys Hughes' accents were compelling, but her dialogue was a bit flat and I found myself not being able to relate to the main characters.
For the most part. Her accents were good, but her pitch differentiation was not so much.
I will definitely check out other Rosie Thomas books. Those who have read her other books seem to think that this is not her best work.
It was enjoyable but much too long. The narrative would have had much more impact if about 100 pages had been trimmed off. The ending was much too drawn-out and anti-climatic.
Probably not. There are other more interesting stories about India.
Narrator was fine.
It took me a while to get into this book but then I was hooked! Want to visit Kashmir now. Great storyline.
"Interesting and enjoyable"
different believable interesting
several of the characters are well drawn and interact well with one another several female characters are strongly drawn
several too numerous to pick out one If I had to choose one it is where the child escapes from Ravi
no but it includes lots of cultural and historical issues
"Great story, well told!"
Accents not quite as well defined - except for the Welsh! But kept me listening!
"An intricate woven story, of different generations"
The book gripped me from the beginning. Excellent theme, skilfully interwoven between places and years. Perfect narration befitting the story teller!
Wish I could hear it again for the first time.
"A little Disappointing"
The story was at first intriguing, but became somewhat drawn out, and not helped by a childlike narration, with inaccurate accents .
I really enjoyed this book especially the parts set in Kashmir in the past. Great characters and a super story! It would make you want to visit India although it'd be very different now to the portrayal in the book. Meets Hughes has a very good narrator voice.
I had already read the book but so wished to read it again. It was beautifully narrated and I think it would make avery good film.
A beautiful story with so many depths
"Just as I imagined Kashmir to be"
I loved the way The Kashmir Shawl was written. By using the inter generational aspects of the different lifestyles together with the bringing out the similar human experiences made the story come alive. However I thoroughly enjoyed the descriptions of the landscape.
The Kite Runner because the landscapes are so similar and intrigue me, but also the inter-action between the characters in the different generations.
Many times, the poignancy of the miscarriage oa a much wanted baby, the death of a child, the need to find the truth of the Kashmir Shawl.
A thoroughly good listen, it left me feeling I must visit Kashmir.
"I was a little bit dissapointed"
This book although easy to follow was a little slow in the middle for me and I found myself loosing interest.
Nerys Hughes Narration was great, but although I liked the book it is not a favourite.
"The shawl carries such a story"
I enjoyed the book which was two stories within one novel the story of Mair and her hunger for information on the shawl and Nerys and her life in India and the rich imagery that brings.
It was an interesting story and I personally found the character of Nerys much more interesting than Mair although both were essential to the story as it unfolded. I especially enjoyed the rich descriptive text which really drew me into the novel and made it interesting.
I have not read any other books by Rosie Thomas but would consider them and really enjoyed the narrative by Nerys Hughes.
I would recommend the book as I enjoyed it but would concede that it would not be to everyones taste.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.