©1992 Jodi Picoult; (P)2009 Recorded Books LLC
Loved it, couldn't stop listening.
The story is told well, all the narrators are good (the one who reads Rebecca sounds like she is reading but she playing a teenager so it sort of works)
If you like Picoult other books you should like this one. Was very happy that there wasn't a court case or a sick kid in this one, nice change.
I like this author, but this book is not a good one. Story about letters and driving looked very unreal and borring. I would say the whole book looked unreal and borring.
I really liked this story, and I wish I could give it a higher rating. I'm glad that it's not the first book I listened to by this author. But the main reason I didn't rate it higher is that it's very confusing trying to follow the story because it is written in reverse sequence of events. Maybe my old high school English teacher would be able to give reasons why an author would do that, but I'm not in school any more and I just want to listen to a good story.
In the first few chapters I almost gave up on this book. All of a sudden the characters were talking about the death of someone who had not even been previously introduced into the story. I turned off my player to check the track, thinking that perhaps I had jumped a chapter or downloaded incorrectly, but no, so I struggled to keep going. After a while I caught on. I think that the character's death would have made more of an impact if the story had been told in the correct order so that he died at the end; as it was, I knew what was coming all along and so the ending felt spoiled.
Once I figured out the weird system of telling the story, I was able to follow along so it got easier, sort of like learning to count backward. So overall, it was a great story, just told in a strange way. If you like Picoult's novels, go for it and stick with it. If you're not already a fan, I'd give it a pass and try another one.
I have read a few Picoult (audio)books and quite liked the story of this one. How she draws parallels between humans and whales, how she describes a passion that takes over and threatens to ruin a family. I like the road movie part of Jane and Rebecca travelling cross country to escape. The only little doubt came when Jane is in love with Sam after only a few days.
I like her eye for detail on whales, apples etc
The story is well read and well written. It pulls you along until the end. A good read.
This is the first book by Jodi Picoult that I have read so I don't know if it is just her style of writing or if it is just this book but, I found it quite confusing at times. I really enjoyed the story and the narration was great (even the teenage girl who sounded like she was reading was ok by me) but, I found that a chapter would start and it would take me 5 mins to work out who the character talking is.It turns out to be that she has jumped forward in time to a character we have not been introduced to yet in a place that the main characters are going to but have not arrived at yet. It is so confusing but, when you get to the end of the book, all is revealed and everything falls into place. Anyway, I did enjoy it and it was a bit rounchy at times. I don't think I will read another one of her books though
I normally love Jodie's books, but I thought this book was simply dull and basically had no story line. I would say she is my favorite author so I was a little miffed that I wasted a credit on this book.
"Great, but a downer"
I have listened to all of Picoult's books and you really need to be made of strong stuff, not to be pulled into the emotional tornadoes she produces. The use of different voices added greatly to this recording; as each character explains the fateful cross country trip and meeting at the orchard.
I like Jodi Picoult and have read most of her novels, but this is not one of the best, it's not even her usual standard. It's her first novel, in fact, and her fans (conquered by later novels) can tell the difference.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.