©1994 Susan Elizabeth Phillips; (P)1996 Books on Tape
"A sleek, romantic comedy." (Publishers Weekly)
While my first SEP book experience was positive, I expected a light, fun listen after reading the previous reviewers comments and the book synopsis. True, there were some funny scenes, and some sexy ones as well; however, I found the book mainly dealt with the way Phoebe handled an unresolved trauma in her teen years, changing her life and, to some extent, her personality, in order to deal with it. I am undecided if I will be getting the rest of the series.
Say something about yourself!
I have recommended this book. I love sports and romance so this series is perfect. I've listened to all of the Chicago Stars series and enjoyed all of the books.
No. Fortunately, I listened while I did other tasks so I didn't waste my time. If I had picked it up to read (as opposed to listening), I would have put it down within the first dozen pages. I just hate to waste good credits spent.
I am listening to "Gone Girl," another well-rated book that I am not enjoying as much as I had hoped.
I am always surprised when I choose a book based on the reviews and I am so disappointed. Unfortunately, I had previously downloaded a later book in this series and now I need to decide if it is worth my time to listen to it or just "forfeit" the credit I spent on it.
This is one of my favorite romances, and it sets the foundation for the whole Star series. Try to read the books in order because it really enhances the enjoyment for the series.
Dan and Phoebe's love story is so good that I find myself rereading this whole series. It is such luscious escape. The best part is each book is just as good as the previous one. S.E.P.'s writing is funny, heart warming with great characterization. If you like romances, this one is an all time winner. And the voice of
Anna Fields that was so much associated with S. E. P 's books so sadly has been quieted. Truly a great talent was lost when Ms. Fields tragically died.
I am a big fan of Susan Elizabeth Phillps. Found the first book just by chance and have loved four more since - this being #5. Funny, romantic and this one has a bit of of mystery to it too. I love that her books has real people and not all are rich, powerful and beautiful. Even those that are aren't perfect. If you like SEP books, especially those surrounding the "Chicago Stars", this is a real winner.
This could have been a lot better if it hadn't been so smutty - I read MMIYC and Natural Born Charmer and some other SEP books, which I remember liking - I then bought Fancy Pants and It Had To Be You, and was sorely disappointed. To read these seemed to me a definite and unexpected step into bodice ripper territory.
I was equally disappointed by the lack of wit I remember from other books by SEP. The story also seemed to be brewed on largely the same ingredients as at least two of her other books.
The narrator does a good job, as in the other books, but she will forever sound like someone a bit older than the main characters. I am not put off by it though.
After every SEP book, I always think "this was the best one ever". As far as I know, she has never written a so-so book -- they are all the terrific. Just thinking about some of the scenes she creates makes me laugh out loud.
I am not an avid reader. But, since finding books on CD, I can't get enough!! Susan Elizabeth Phillips is amazing. This is the second of her books I have "read" and I can't get enough. "It Had to be You" is a wonderful love story. I can't wait to download the next!!
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.