With all the warmth and poignancy fans have come to expect from Cecelia Ahern, this is a magical novel, and a surprising love story.
©2005 Cecelia Ahern; (P)2005 HarperCollins Publishers Ltd, London UK
A number of things disappointed me in this book. One was the story, which was slow to get going and moved along at a slow pace. So was boring and hard to follow. Another was the characterization, which was shallow. So the characters were hard to get to know and I didn't care what happened to them at all. The narrators were another disappointment, as personally I found their reading styles irritating and hard to follow, especially the male narrator. So I had to listen intently all the time, which was not relaxing and beat the point of listening to the book to chill out. A further disapppointment was the twee and stereotypical, ersatz Irish music played at irregular intervals during the book, which got on my nerves and added nothing to the already poor narration and weak story. So kept pulling me out of the book. All in all, a very disappointing waste of time.
I found this book more patronizing than the others. It assumed, for example, that the reader must not know what basic Irish words mean, which was the most patronizing thing--anyone who has read Ahern's previous works or is familiar with Marian Keyes' books will be familiar with these. So instead of pulling me into a whimsical, grown-up fairytale, I felt that this book was talking down to me and ruined my enjyment of the story.
Both readers were inconsistent in their reading--inconsistent reading speeds, speech patterns and (mis)use of volume for (no) dramatic effect. Degas' portrayal of the child Luke was the most irritating thing. So I didn't finish the book. I had to stop after little more than one chapter as Degas' reading style was so irritating.
I would cut Ivan from the book. The premise of having an imaginary friend character that was actually real was the most intriguing thing and could have worked well for a whimsical tale. However, the execution was poor and the character seemed like a muddle of disparate elements--not fully adult or fully child and about as boring as the adult characters.
Such a shame to come across this weak offering from Ahern after enjoying some of her other books.
"An Adult fairy tale"
If you were sorry when you grew up that magic stories came to an end, then read this.... You may begin to believe again.
Magical, would make a good and very funny film, but don't spoil it!
A sweet story but lacking in humour and some of the narration was week. Not a favourite but worth a listen for an easy read.
Report Inappropriate Content